Author picture

About the Author

Includes the names: Brian Cull, Brian Cull et al

Works by Brian Cull

Twelve Days in May (1995) 13 copies

Tagged

Common Knowledge

Gender
male

Members

Reviews

 
Flagged
Iznik | Aug 25, 2018 |
This work has the usual set of characteristics one finds in a Grub Street publication. On one hand you get day-by-day coverage of events and unique source material. On the other you wish that there was more attention paid to editing and documentary apparatus; the need for orders of battle and a better index particularly come to mind. Some of the sources are a little dubious too, such as accepting the claim from Peter Elphick's controversial "Singapore: The Pregnable Fortress" that there were German officers serving in the Imperial Japanese Army; oh really? It makes one wonder why Louis Allen's "Singapore" or Bayly & Harper's "Forgotten Armies" aren't included in the sources.

That said, this is a great story that I really enjoyed reading, as a band of mostly Aussie and Kiwi pilots find themselves stuck with the impossible task of defending the propaganda mirage of Fortress Singapore against the Japanese military at its peak, in obsolete equipment, while led by the indifferent cast-offs of the British military. If you want a telling anecdote there is the case of Pilot Officer Tom Watson, RCAF who apparently flew the last Brewster Buffalo out of Singapore, and for his trouble was "reprimanded...for flying an airplane on which I had not officially been checked out." Even if you start to wonder if the authors are laying on the varnish of Commonwealth lions being led by British donkeys a little too thick, there is no lack of documented incompetance at Singapore not to make you shake your head at the waste of it all.
… (more)
½
1 vote
Flagged
Shrike58 | Feb 23, 2009 |
The particular virtue of this book is that it gives you about the best available blow-by-blow accounting of the aerial aspects of the first Arab-Israeli war. In fact it's a rather wider study then that, as the authors also provide an overview of military aviation in the Middle East during World War II, such as coverage of the British defense of Iraq and the conquest of the French Levant. Most enjoyable are the stories about the improvised war of the first few weeks after Israeli independence was declared. This is not to mention that the British presence as observers, and occasional participants in the combat, is also discussed. If there is any particular problem it's that enough time has elapsed to render some of the book's perspectives a little dated, particularly in regards to the wider context of the Arab-Israeli conflict.… (more)
½
 
Flagged
Shrike58 | May 10, 2007 |

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

David Nicolle Contributor
Geoff Fisken Foreword
Leo Nomis Foreword

Statistics

Works
26
Members
250
Popularity
#91,401
Rating
3.8
Reviews
3
ISBNs
34
Languages
2

Charts & Graphs