| Titles | Order |
| Watchful at night by Julius Fast | First Novel, 1946 |
| The Horizontal Man by Helen Eustis | First Novel, 1947 |
| The Fabulous Clipjoint by Fredric Brown | First Novel, 1948 |
| Twelve Against The Law by Edward D. Radin | Fact Crime, 1948 |
| The Room Upstairs by Mildred Davis | First Novel, 1949 |
| Bad Company by Joseph Henry Jackson | Fact Crime, 1950 |
| What a Body! by Alan Green | First Novel, 1950 |
| Nightmare in Manhattan by Thomas Walsh | First Novel, 1951 |
| Twelve Against Crime by Edward D. Radin | Fact Crime, 1951 |
| Strangle Hold by Mary McMullen | First Novel, 1952 |
| True Tales from the Annals of Crime and Rascality by St. Clair McKelway | Fact Crime, 1952 |
| The Court of Last Resort by Erle Stanley Gardner | Fact Crime, 1953 |
| Don't Cry for Me by William Campbell Gault | First Novel, 1953 |
| Beat Not the Bones by Charlotte Jay | Novel, 1954 |
| A Kiss Before Dying by Ira Levin | Best First Novel, 1954 |
| Someone Like You by Roald Dahl | Short Stories, 1954 |
| Go, Lovely Rose by Jean Potts | First Novel, 1955 |
| The Long Goodbye by Raymond Chandler | Novel, 1955 |
| Beast in View by Margaret Millar | Novel, 1956 |
| Dead and Gone by Manly Wade Wellman | Fact Crime, 1956 |
| The perfectionist by Lane Kauffmann | First Novel, 1956 |
| A Dram of Poison by Charlotte Armstrong | Novel, 1957 |
| Night fell on Georgia by Charles Samuels | Fact Crime, 1957 |
| Rebecca's Pride by Donald McNutt Douglass | First Novel, 1957 |
| The D.A.'s Man by Harold E. Danforth and James D. Horan | Fact Crime, 1958 |
| Knock and Wait a While by William Rawle Weeks | First Novel, 1958 |
| Room to Swing by Ed Lacy | Novel, 1958 |
| The Bright Road to Fear by Richard Martin Stern | First Novel, 1959 |
| The Eighth Circle by Stanley Ellin | Novel, 1959 |
| They died in the chair by Wenzell Brown | Fact Crime, 1959 |
| Fire at Sea: The Mysterious Tragedy of the Morro Castle by Thomas Gallagher | Fact Crime, 1960 |
| The Grey Flannel Shroud by Henry Slesar | First Novel, 1960 |
| The Hours Before Dawn by Celia Fremlin | Best Novel, 1960 |
| The Man in the Cage by Jack Vance | First Novel, 1961 |
| Mystery of the Haunted Pool by Phyllis A. Whitney | Juvenile, 1961 |
| The Overbury Affair by Miriam Allen De Ford | Fact Crime, 1961 |
| The Progress of a Crime by Julian Symons | Best Novel, 1961 |
| Death And The Supreme Court by Barrett Prettyman | Fact Crime, 1962 |
| Gideon's Fire by J. J. Marric | Novel, 1962 |
| The Green Stone by Suzanne Blanc | First Novel, 1962 |
| The Phantom of Walkaway Hill by Edward Fenton | Juvenile, 1962 |
| Cutlass Island by Scott Corbett | Juvenile, 1963 |
| Death and the Joyful Woman by Ellis Peters | Best Novel, 1963 |
| The Fugitive by Robert L. Fish | First Novel, 1963 |
| Tragedy in Dedham: The Story of the Sacco-Vanzetti Case by Francis Russell | Fact Crime, 1963 |
| The deed by Gerold Frank | Fact Crime, 1964 |
| Florentine Finish by Cornelius Hirschberg | First Novel, 1964 |
| The Light of Day by Eric Ambler | Novel, 1964 |
| Mystery of the Hidden Hand by Phyllis A. Whitney | Juvenile, 1964 |
| Friday the Rabbi Slept Late by Harry Kemelman | First Novel, 1965 |
| Gideon's Trumpet by Anthony Lewis | Fact Crime, 1965 |
| Mystery at Crane's Landing by Marcella Thum | Juvenile, 1965 |
| Seance on a Wet Afternoon by Bryan Forbes | Best Foreign Film Screenplay, 1965 |
| The Spy Who Came in From the Cold by John le Carré | Novel, 1965 |
| In Cold Blood by Truman Capote | Fact Crime, 1966 |
| In the Heat of the Night by John Ball | First Novel, 1966 |
| The mystery of 22 east by Leon Ware | Juvenile, 1966 |
| The Quiller Memorandum by Adam Hall | Novel, 1966 |
| The Boston Strangler by Gerold Frank | Fact Crime, 1967 |
| The Cold War Swap by Ross Thomas | First Novel, 1967 |
| The King of the Rainy Country by Nicolas Freeling | Novel 1967 |
| Sinbad and Me by Kin Platt | Juvenile, 1967 |
| Act of Fear by Michael Collins | First Novel, 1968 |
| God Save the Mark by Donald E. Westlake | Best Novel, 1968 |
| The Oblong Room by Edward D. Hoch | Best Short Story, 1968 |
| A Private Disgrace: Lizzie Borden by Daylight by Victoria Lincoln | Fact Crime, 1968 |
| Signpost to Terror by Gretchen Sprague | Juvenile, 1968 |
| Bait by Dorothy Uhnak | First Novel, 1969 |
| A Case of Need by Michael Crichton | Novel, 1969 |
| The House of Dies Drear by Virginia Hamilton | Juvenile, 1969 |
| Poe the Detective: The Curious Circumstances Behind the Mystery of Marie Roget by John Walsh | Fact Crime, 1969 |
| The Case That Will Not Die: Commonwealth Vs. Sacco and Vanzetti by Herbert Brutus Ehrmann | Fact Crime, 1970 |
| Danger at Black Dyke | Juvenile, 1970 |
| The Dragon's Eye by Scott C. Stone | Paperback Original, 1970 |
| Forfeit by Dick Francis | Novel, 1970 |
| A Time of Predators by Joe Gores | First Novel, 1970 |
| The Anderson Tapes by Lawrence Sanders | First Novel, 1971 |
| A Great Fall by Mildred Savage | Fact Crime, 1971 |
| The Intruder by John Rowe Townsend | Juvenile, 1971 |
| The Laughing Policeman by Maj Sjöwall | Novel, 1971 |
| Operation Flashpoint by Dan J. Marlowe | Paperback Original, 1971 |
| The Day of the Jackal by Frederick Forsyth | Novel, 1972 |
| Finding Maubee by A. H. Z. Carr | First Novel, 1972 |
| For Murder I Charge More by Frank McAuliffe | Paperback Original, 1972 |
| Night Fall by Joan Aiken | Juvenile, 1972 |
| Deathwatch by Robb White | Juvenile, 1973 |
| Hoax; The Inside Story of the Howard Hughes-Clifford Irving Affair | Fact Crime, 1973 |
| The Invader by Richard Wormser | Paperback Original, 1973 |
| The Lingala code by Warren Kiefer | Novel, 1973 |
| Squaw Point by R. H Shimer | First Novel, 1973 |
| The Billion Dollar Sure Thing by Paul E. Erdman | First Novel, 1974 |
| Dance Hall of the Dead by Tony Hillerman | Novel, 1974 |
| Death of an informer | Paperback Original, 1974 |
| Legacy of death by Barbara Levy | Fact Crime, 1974 |
| Long Black Coat by Jay Bennett | Juvenile, 1974 |
| The Long Black Coat: A Mystery | Juvenile, 1974 |
| The Corpse That Walked by Roy WiNsor | Paperback Original, 1975 |
| The Dangling Witness. | Juvenile, 1975 |
| The Dangling Witness. by Jay Bennett | Juvenile, 1975 |
| Fletch by Gregory Mcdonald | First Novel, 1975 |
| Helter Skelter: The True Story of the Manson Murders by Vincent Bugliosi | Best Fact Crime, 1975 |
| Peter's Pence by Jon Cleary | Novel, 1975 |
| The Alvarez Journal by Rex Burns | First Novel, 1976 |
| Autopsy by John R. Feegel | Paperback Original, 1976 |
| Hopscotch by Brian Garfield | Novel, 1976 |
| A Time to Die by Tom Wicker | Fact Crime, 1976 |
| Z for Zachariah by Robert C. O'Brien | Juvenile, 1976 |
| Are You in the House Alone? by Richard Peck | Juvenile, 1977 |
| Blood and Money by Thomas Thompson | Fact Crime, 1977 |
| Confess, Fletch by Gregory Mcdonald | Paperback Original, 1977 |
| Encyclopedia of Mystery and Detection by Chris Steinbrunner | Critical / Biographical, 1977 |
| Promised Land by Robert B. Parker | Best Novel, 1977 |
| The Thomas Berryman Number by James Patterson | Best First Novel,1977 |
| Catch Me: Kill Me by William H. Hallahan | Novel, 1978 |
| Confessions by Barbara Amiel | Fact Crime, 1978 |
| A French finish by Robert Ross | First Novel, 1978 |
| The Quark Maneuver by Mike Jahn | Paperback Original, 1978 |
| A Really Weird Summer by Eloise Jarvis McGraw | Juvenile, 1978 |
| Rex Stout: A Biography by John McAleer | Critical / Biographical, 1978 |
| Alone in Wolf Hollow by Dana Brookins | Juvenile, 1979 |
| ALONE IN WOLF HOLLOW | Juvenile, 1979 |
| Deceit and Deadly Lies by Franklin Bandy | Paperback Original, 1979 |
| The Eye of the Needle by Ken Follett | Best Novel, 1979 |
| Killed in the Ratings by William L. Deandrea | First Novel, 1979 |
| The Mystery of Agatha Christie by Gwen Robyns | Critical / Biographical, 1979 |
| Till Death Us Do Part: A True Murder Mystery by Vincent Bugliosi | Fact Crime, 1979 |
| Deathtrap: A Thriller in Two Acts by Ira Levin | Best Play, 1980 |
| Dorothy L. Sayers: A Literary Biography by Ralph E. Hone | Critical / Biographical, 1980 |
| The Falcon and the Snowman: A True Story of Friendship and Espionage by Robert Lindsey | Fact Crime, 1980 |
| The Great Train Robbery by Michael Crichton | Motion Picture Screenplay, 1980 |
| The Hog Murders by William L. Deandrea | Paperback Original, 1980 |
| The Kidnapping of Christina Lattimore by Joan Lowery Nixon | Juvenile, 1980 |
| The Lasko Tangent by Richard North Patterson | First Novel, 1980 |
| The Rheingold Route by Arthur Maling | Novel, 1980 |
| Public Murders by Bill Granger | Paperback Original, 1981 |
| The Seance by Joan Lowery Nixon | Juvenile, 1981 |
| A true deliverance by Fred Harwell | Fact Crime, 1981 |
| Twentieth-Century Crime and Mystery Writers by John M. Reilly | Critical / Biographical, 1981 |
| The watcher by Kay Nolte Smith | First novel, 1981 |
| Whip Hand by Dick Francis | Novel, 1981 |
| Chiefs by Stuart Woods | First Novel, 1982 |
| The Old Dick by L.A. Morse | Paperback Original, 1982 |
| Peregrine by William Bayer | Novel, 1982 |
| The Sting Man by Robert W. Greene | Fact Crime, 1982 |
| Taking Terri Mueller by Norma Fox Mazer | Juvenile, 1982 |
| What About Murder? A Guide to Books About Mystery and Detective Fiction by Jon L. Breen | Critical / Biographical, 1982 |
| Billingsgate Shoal by Rick Boyer | Novel, 1983 |
| The Butcher's Boy by Thomas Perry | First Novel, 1983 |
| Cain by Roy Hoopes | Critical / Biographical, 1983 |
| The Murder of Hound Dog Bates by Robbie Branscum | Juvenile, 1983 |
| Triangle by Teri White | Paperback Original, 1983 |
| The Vatican Connection by Richard Hammer | Fact Crime, 1983 |
| The Bay Psalm Book Murder by Will Harriss | Best First Novel, 1984 |
| The Callender Papers by Cynthia Voigt | Juvenile, 1984 |
| The Dark Side of Genius by Donald Spoto | Critical / Biographical, 1984 |
| LaBrava by Elmore Leonard | Novel, 1984 |
| Mrs. White by Margaret Tracy | Paperback Original, 1984 |
| Very Much a Lady: The Untold Story of Jean Harris and Dr. Herman Tarnower by Shana Alexander | Fact Crime, 1984 |
| Double Play: The San Francisco City Hall Killings by Mike Weiss | Fact Crime, 1985 |
| Grandmaster by Warren Murphy | Best Paperback Original, 1985 |
| The Lord Peter Wimsey Companion by Stephan P. Clarke | Special Award, 1985 |
| Night Cry by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor | Juvenile, 1985 |
| Novel Verdicts by Jon L. Breen | Critical / Biographical, 1985 |
| Strike Three, You're Dead by Richard Dean Rosen | First Novel, 1985 |
| Briarpatch by Ross Thomas | Novel, 1986 |
| JOHN LE CARRE. by Peter Lewis | Critical / Biographical, 1986 |
| Pigs Get Fat by Warren Murphy | Paperback Original, 1986 |
| The Sandman's Eyes by Patricia Windsor | Juvenile, 1986 |
| Savage Grace by Natalie Robins | Fact Crime, 1986 |
| The Suspect by L. R. Wright | Novel, 1986 |
| When the Bough Breaks by Jonathan Kellerman | First Novel, 1986 |
| Careless Whispers by Carlton Stowers | Fact Crime, 1987 |
| A Dark-Adapted Eye by Barbara Vine | Novel, 1987 |
| Here Lies by Eric Ambler | Critical / Biographical, 1987 |
| The Junkyard Dog by Robert Campbell | Paperback Original, 1987 |
| No One Rides for Free by Larry Beinhart | First Novel, 1987 |
| The Other Side of Dark by Joan Lowery Nixon | Juvenile, 1987 |
| Bimbos of the Death Sun by Sharyn McCrumb | Paperback Original, 1988 |
| The CBS Murders by Richard Hammer | Fact Crime, 1988 |
| Death Among Strangers by Deidre S. Laiken | First Novel, 1988 |
| An Introduction to the Detective Story by Leroy Lad Panek | Critical / Biographical, 1988 |
| Lucy Forever and Miss Rosetree, Shrinks by Susan Shreve | Juvenile, 1988 |
| Old Bones by Aaron Elkins | Novel, 1988 |
| Carolina Skeletons by David Stout | First Novel, 1989 |
| A Cold Red Sunrise by Stuart M. Kaminsky | Novel, 1989 |
| Cornell Woolrich: First You Dream, Then You Die by Francis M. Nevins | Critical / Biographical, 1989 |
| In Broad Daylight by Harry N. MacLean | Fact Crime, 1989 |
| Incident at Loring Groves by Sonia Levitin | Young Adult, 1989 |
| Megan's Island by Willo Davis Roberts | Juvenile, 1989 |
| The Telling of Lies by Timothy Findley | Paperback Original, 1989 |
| Black Cherry Blues by James Lee Burke | Novel, 1990 |
| Doc: The Rape of the town of Lovell by Jack Olsen | Fact Crime, 1990 |
| The Last Billable Hour by Susan Wolfe | First Novel, 1990 |
| The Life of Graham Greene, Volume I: 1904-1939 by Norman Sherry | Critical / Biographical, 1990 |
| The Rain by Keith Peterson | Paperback Original, 1990 |
| Encyclopedia of World Crime Criminal Justice, Criminology, and Law Enforcement 6 Volume Set by Jay Robert Nash | Special Award, 1991 |
| In a Child's Name: The Legacy of a Mother's Murder by Peter Maas | Fact Crime, 1991 |
| The Man Who Would Be F. Scott Fitzgerald by David Handler | Paperback Original, 1991 |
| Mote | Young Adult, 1991 |
| New Orleans Mourning by Julie Smith | Novel, 1991 |
| Postmortem by Patricia Cornwell | First Novel, 1991 |
| Stonewords: A Ghost Story (Harper Trophy Books) by Pam Conrad | Juvenile, 1991 |
| Trouble is Their Business: Private Eyes in Fiction, Film, and Television, 1927-1988 by John Conquest | Critical / Biographical, 1991 |
| A Dance at the Slaughterhouse by Lawrence Block | Novel, 1992 |
| Dark Maze by Thomas Adcock | Paperback Original, 1992 |
| Edgar A Poe: Mournful and Never-ending Remembrance by Kenneth Silverman | Critical / Biographical, 1992 |
| Homicide: A Year on the Killing Streets by David Simon | Best Fact Crime, 1992 |
| Slow Motion Riot by Peter Blauner | Best First Novel, 1992 |
| Wanted...Mud Blossom by Betsy Byars | Juvenile, 1992 |
| The Weirdo by Theodore Taylor | Young Adult, 1992 |
| Alias S S Van Dine by John Loughery | Critical / Biographical, 1993 |
| The Black Echo by Michael Connelly | First Novel, 1993 |
| Bootlegger's Daughter by Margaret Maron | Novel, 1993 |
| Coffin on a Case by Eve Bunting | Juvenile, 1993 |
| A Cold Day for Murder by Dana Stabenow | Paperback Original, 1993 |
| A Little Bit Dead by Chap Reaver | Young Adult, 1993 |
| Swift Justice: Murder & Vengeance In A California Town by Harry Farrell | Fact Crime, 1993 |
| Dead Folks' Blues by Steven Womack | Paperback Original, 1994 |
| A Grave Talent by Laurie R. King | First Novel, 1994 |
| Legal Tender by Lisa Scottoline | 1994 |
| The Name of the Game Was Murder by Joan Lowery Nixon | Young Adult, 1994 |
| The Saint: A Complete History in Print, Radio, Film and Television of Leslie Charteris' Robin Hood of Modern Crime, Simon Templar, 1928-1992 by Burl Barer | Critical / Biographical, 1994 |
| The Sculptress by Minette Walters | Novel, 1994 |
| The Twin in the Tavern by Barbara Brooks Wallace | Juvenile, 1994 |
| Until the Twelfth of Never: The Deadly Divorce of Dan & Betty Broderick by Bella Stumbo | Fact Crime, 1994 |
| The Absolutely True Story... by Willo Davis Roberts | Juvenile, 1995 |
| The Caveman's Valentine by George Dawes Green | First Novel, 1995 |
| Encyclopedia Mysteriosa: A Comprehensive Guide to the Art of Detection in Print, Film, Radio, and Television by William L. Deandrea | Critical / Biographical, 1995 |
| Final Appeal by Lisa Scottoline | Paperback Original, 1995 |
| The Red Scream by Mary Willis Walker | Novel, 1995 |
| To Protect and to Serve: The LAPD's Century of War in the City of Dreams by Joe Domanick | Fact Crime, 1995 |
| Toughing It by Nancy Springer | Young Adult, 1995 |
| Circumstantial Evidence: Death, Life, And Justice In A Southern Town by Pete Earley | Fact Crime, 1996 |
| Come to Grief by Dick Francis | Novel, 1996 |
| Looking for Jamie Bridger by Nancy Springer | Juvenile, 1996 |
| Penance by David Housewright | First Novel, 1996 |
| Prophecy Rock by Rob MacGregor | Young Adult, 1996 |
| Savage Art: A Biography of Jim Thompson by Robert Polito | Critical / Biographical, 1996 |
| Tarnished Blue by William Heffernan | Paperback Original, 1996 |
| The Chatham School Affair by Thomas H. Cook | Novel, 1997 |
| The Clearing by Dorothy R. Miller | Juvenile, 1997 |
| Fade Away by Harlan Coben | Paperback Original, 1997 |
| Power to Hurt by Darcy O'Brien | Fact Crime, 1997 |
| The Secret Marriage of Sherlock Holmes and Other Eccentric Readings by Michael Atkinson | Critical / Biographical, 1997 |
| Simple Justice by John Morgan Wilson | First Novel, 1997 |
| Twisted Summer by Willo Davis Roberts | Young Adult, 1997 |
| 'G' Is for Grafton : The World of Kinsey Millhone by Natalie Hevener Kaufman | Critical / Biographical, 1998 |
| Charm City by Laura Lippman | Paperback Original, 1998 |
| Cimarron Rose by James Lee Burke | Novel, 1998 |
| The Death of Innocents: A True Story of Murder, Medicine, and High-Stake Science by Richard Firstman | Fact Crime, 1998 |
| Ghost Canoe by Will Hobbs | Young Adult, 1998 |
| Los Alamos by Joseph Kanon | First Novel, 1998 |
| Sparrows in the Scullery by Barbara Brooks Wallace | Juvenile, 1998 |
| A Cold Day In Paradise (Alex McKnight Novels) by Steve Hamilton | First Novel, 1999 |
| The Killer's Cousin by Nancy Werlin | Young Adult, 1999 |
| Mr. White's Confession: A Novel by Robert Clark | Novel, 1999 |
| Mystery and Suspense Writers by Robin W. Winks | Critical / Biographical, 1999 |
| Sammy Keyes and the Hotel Thief by Wendelin Van Draanen | Juvenile, 1999 |
| To The Last Breath: Three Women Fight For The Truth Behind A Child's Tragic Murder by Carlton Stowers | Fact Crime, 1999 |
| The Widower's Two-Step by Rick Riordan | Paperback Original, 1999 |
| Blind Eye: The Terrifying Story Of A Doctor Who Got Away With Murder by James B. Stewart | Fact Crime, 2000 |
| Bones by Jan Burke | Novel, 2000 |
| Fulton County Blues by Ruth Birmingham | Paperback Original, 2000 |
| Never Trust a Dead Man by Vivian Vande Velde | Young Adult, 2000 |
| The Night Flyers by Elizabeth McDavid Jones | Juvenile, 2000 |
| The Skull Mantra by Eliot Pattison | First novel, 2000 |
| Teller of Tales: The Life of Arthur Conan Doyle by Daniel Stashower | Critical / Biographical, 2000 |
| The Black Maria by Mark Graham | Paperback Original, 2001 |
| Black Mass: The True Story of an Unholy Alliance between the FBI and the Irish Mob by Dick Lehr | Fact Crime, 2001 |
| The Bottoms by Joe R. Lansdale | Novel, 2001 |
| A Conspiracy of Paper by David Liss | First Novel, 2001 |
| Conundrums for the Long Week-End : England, Dorothy L. Sayers, and Lord Peter Wimsey by Robert Kuhn McGregor | Critical / Biographical, 2001 |
| Counterfeit Son by Elaine Marie Alphin | Young Adult, 2001 |
| Dovey Coe by Frances O'Roark Dowell | Juvenile, 2001 |
| Adios Muchachos by Daniel Chavarria | Paperback Original, 2002 |
| The Boy in the Burning House by Tim Wynne-Jones | Young Adult, 2002 |
| Dangling by Lillian Eige | Juvenile, 2002 |
| Edgar Allan Poe A to Z: The Essential Reference to His Life and Work (The Literary A to Z Series) by Dawn B. Sova | Critical / Biographical, 2002 |
| Line of Vision by David Ellis | First Novel, 2002 |
| Silent Joe by T. Jefferson Parker | Novel, 2002 |
| Son of a Grifter: The Twisted Tale of Sante and Kenny Kimes, the Most Notorious Con Artists in America by Kent Walker | Fact Crime, 2002 |
| The Blue Edge of Midnight by Jonathon King | First Novel, 2003 |
| Fallout by Daniel Parker | Young Adult, 2003 |
| Fire Lover by Joseph Wambaugh | Fact Crime, 2003 |
| Harriet Spies Again by Helen Ericson | Juvenile, 2003 |
| The Mammoth Encyclopedia of Modern Crime Fiction by Mike Ashley | Critical/Biographical, 2003 |
| Out of Sight by T.J. MacGregor | Paperback Original, 2003 |
| Outsmart by Daniel Parker | Young Adult, 2003 |
| Trust Falls by Daniel Parker | Young Adult, 2003 |
| Winter and Night by S. J. Rozan | Novel, 2003 |
| Acceleration by Graham McNamee | Young Adult, 2004 |
| Beautiful Shadow: A Life of Patricia Highsmith by Andrew Wilson | Critical / Biographical Work, 2004 |
| Bernie Magruder & the Bats in the Belfry by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor | Juvenile, 2004 |
| Death of a Nationalist by Rebecca Pawel | First Novel, 2004 |
| The Devil in the White City by Erik Larson | Fact Crime, 2004 |
| Find Me Again by Sylvia Maultash Warsh | Paperback Original, 2004 |
| Resurrection Men by Ian Rankin | Novel, 2004 |
| California Girl by T. Jefferson Parker | Novel, 2005 |
| Chasing Vermeer by Blue Balliett | Juvenile, 2005 |
| The Confession (Hard Case Crime) by Domenic Stansberry | Paperback Original, 2005 |
| Conviction: Solving the Moxley Murder: A Reporter and a Detective's Twenty-Year Search for Justice by Leonard Levitt | Fact Crime, 2005 |
| Country of Origin: A Novel by Don Lee | First Novel, 2005 |
| In Darkness, Death (The Samurai Mysteries) by Dorothy Hoobler | Young Adult, 2005 |
| The New Annotated Sherlock Holmes (Omnibus) by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle | Critical / Biographical Work, 2005 |
| The Boys of San Joaquin by D. James Smith | Juvenile, 2006 |
| Citizen Vince by Jess Walter | Novel, 2006 |
| The Girl in the Glass by Jeffrey Ford | Paperback Original, 2006 |
| Girl sleuth: Nancy Drew and the women who created her by Melanie Rehak | Critical / Biographical Work, 2006 |
| Last Shot: A Final Four Mystery by John Feinstein | Young Adult, 2006 |
| Officer Down by Theresa Schwegel | First Novel, 2006 |
| The Rescue Artist: A True Story of Art, Thieves, and the Hunt for a Missing Masterpiece (P.S.) by Edward Dolnick | Fact Crime, 2006 |
| Buried by Robin Merrow MacCready | Young Adult, 2007 |
| The Faithful Spy by Alex Berenson | First Novel, 2007 |
| The Janissary Tree by Jason Goodwin | Novel, 2007 |
| Manhunt: The 12-Day Chase for Lincoln's Killer by James L. Swanson | Fact Crime, 2007 |
| Room One: A Mystery or Two by Andrew Clements | Juvenile, 2007 |
| The Science of Sherlock Holmes by E. J. Wagner | Critical/Biographical Work, 2007 |
| Snakeskin Shamisen by Naomi Hirahara | Paperback Original, 2007 |
| Arthur Conan Doyle: A Life in Letters by Jon Lellenberg | Critical/Biographical Work, 2008 |
| Down River by John Hart | Novel, 2008 |
| In the Woods by Tana French | Best First Novel 2008 |
| The Night Tourist by Katherine Marsh | Juvenile, 2008 |
| Rat Life by Tedd Arnold | Young Adult, 2008 |
| Reclaiming History: The Assassination of President John F. Kennedy by Vincent Bugliosi | Fact Crime, 2008 |
| The Song Is You: A Novel by Megan Abbott | Paperback Original, 2008 |
| American lightning: terror, mystery, movie-making, and the crime of the century by Howard Blum | Fact Crime, 2009 |
| Blue Heaven by C. J. Box | Novel, 2009 |
| China Lake by Meg Gardiner | Paperback Original, 2009 |
| Edgar Allan Poe: An Illustrated Companion to His Tell-Tale Stories by Harry Lee Poe | Critical / Biographical, 2009 |
| The Foreigner: A Novel by Francie Lin | First Novel, 2009 |
| Paper Towns by John Green | Young Adult, 2009 |
| The Postcard by Tony Abbott | Juvenile, 2009 |
| Body Blows: A Joe Grundy Mystery (Castle Street Mysteries) by Marc Strange | Paperback Original, 2010 |
| Closed for the Season by Mary Downing Hahn | Juvenile, 2010 |
| Columbine by Dave Cullen | Fact Crime, 2010 |
| In the Shadow of Gotham by Stefanie Pintoff | First Novel, 2010 |
| The Last Child by John Hart | Novel, 2010 |
| The Lineup: The World's Greatest Crime Writers Tell the Inside Story of Their Greatest Detectives by Otto Penzler | Critical/Biographical, 2010 |
| Reality Check by Peter Abrahams | Young Adult, 2010 |