| Titles | Order |
| The Forgotten Beasts of Eld by Patricia A. McKillip | Best Novel, 1975 |
| Pages From A Young Girl's Journal by Robert Aickman | Short Fiction, 1975 |
| Worse things waiting by Manly Wade Wellman | Collection, 1975 |
| The Enquiries of Doctor Eszterhazy by Avram Davidson | Collection, 1976 |
| Somewhere In Time by Richard Matheson | Novel, 1976 |
| Doctor Rat by William Kotzwinkle | Novel, 1977 |
| Frights by Kirby McCauley | Anthology / Collection, 1977 |
| There's A Long Long Trail A-winding by Russell Kirk | Short Fiction, 1977 |
| The Chimney by Ramsey Campbell | Short Story, 1978 |
| Murgunstrumm and Others by Hugh B. Cave | Anthology / Collection, 1978 |
| Our Lady of Darkness by Fritz Leiber | Novel, 1978 |
| Gloriana by Michael Moorcock | Novel, 1979 |
| Naples [short story] by Avram Davidson | Short Fiction, 1979 |
| Shadows by Charles L. Grant | Anthology / Collection, 1979 |
| Amazons! by Jessica Amanda Salmonson | Anthology / Collection, 1980 |
| Mackintosh Willy by Ramsey Campbell | Short Story, 1980 |
| Watchtower by Elizabeth A. Lynn | Novel, 1980 |
| Dark Forces by Kirby McCauley | Anthology/Collection, 1981 |
| The Shadow of the Torturer by Gene Wolfe | Novel, 1981 |
| The Ugly Chickens by Howard Waldrop | Short Fiction, 1981 |
| Elsewhere: Tales of Fantasy by Terry Windling | Anthology / Collection, 1982 |
| Little, Big by John Crowley | Novel, 1982 |
| The Reach by Stephen King | Short Story, 1982 |
| Beyond Any Measure by Karl Edward Wagner | Novella, 1983 |
| Nifft the Lean by Michael Shea | Novel, 1983 |
| Nightmare Seasons by Charles L. Grant | Anthology / Collection, 1983 |
| Black Air by Kim Stanley Robinson | Novella, 1984 |
| The Dragon Waiting by John M. Ford | Novel, 1984 |
| High Spirits by Robertson Davies | Anthology / Collection, 1984 |
| Books of Blood 1-3 by Clive Barker | Anthology / Collection, 1985 |
| Bridge of Birds: A Novel of Ancient China That Never Was by Barry Hughart | Novel, 1985 |
| Mythago Wood by Robert Holdstock | Novel, 1985 |
| Unconquered Country by Geoff Ryman | Novella, 1985 |
| Imaginary Lands by Robin McKinley | Anthology / Collection, 1986 |
| Paper Dragons by James P. Blaylock | Short Fiction, 1986 |
| Song of Kali by Dan Simmons | Novel, 1986 |
| Hatrack River [Short story] by Orson Scott Card | Novella, 1987 |
| Perfume: The Story of a Murderer by Patrick Süskind | Novel, 1987 |
| Red Light by David J. Schow | Short Fiction, 1987 |
| Tales of the Quintana Roo by James Tiptree Jr. | Anthology / Collection, 1987 |
| The Architecture of Fear by Kathryn Cramer | Anthology, 1988 |
| Buffalo Gals, Won't You Come Out Tonight by Ursula K. Le Guin | Novella, 1988 |
| The Dark Descent by David G. Hartwell | Anthology, 1988 |
| The Jaguar Hunter by Lucius Shepard | Collection, 1988 |
| Replay by Ken Grimwood | Novel, 1988 |
| Angry Candy by Harlan Ellison | Collection, 1989 |
| Koko by Peter Straub | Novel, 1989 |
| The Skin Trade by George R. R. Martin | Novella, 1989 |
| Storeys from the Old Hotel by Gene Wolfe | Collection, 1989 |
| The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: First Annual Collection by Ellen Datlow | Anthology, 1989 |
| Great Work of Time by John Crowley | Novella, 1990 |
| Madouc by Jack Vance | Novel, 1990 |
| Richard Matheson: Collected Stories by Richard Matheson | Collection, 1990 |
| The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: Second Annual Collection by Ellen Datlow | Anthology, 1990 |
| Best New Horror 1 by Stephen Jones | Anthology, 1991 |
| Only Begotten Daughter by James Morrow | Novel, 1991 |
| The Start of the End of It All by Carol Emshwiller | Collection, 1991 |
| Thomas the Rhymer by Ellen Kushner | Novel, 1991 |
| Boy's Life by Robert McCammon | Novel, 1992 |
| The Ends of the Earth: 14 Stories by Lucius Shepard | Collection, 1992 |
| The Ragthorn by Robert Holdstock | Novella, 1992 |
| The Somewhere Doors by Fred Chappell | Short Fiction, 1992 |
| The Year's Best Fantasy and Horror: Fourth Annual Collection by Ellen Datlow | Anthology, 1992 |
| The Ghost Village by Peter Straub | Novella, 1993 |
| Graves by Joe Haldeman | Short Fiction, 1993 |
| Last Call by Tim Powers | Novel, 1993 |
| Metahorror by Dennis Etchison | Anthology, 1993 |
| The Sons of Noah & Other Stories by Jack Cady | Collection, 1993 |
| Alone With The Horrors by Ramsey Campbell | Collection, 1994 |
| Full Spectrum IV by Lou Aronica | Anthology, 1994 |
| Glimpses by Lewis Shiner | Novel, 1994 |
| The Calvin Coolidge Home for Dead Comedians by Bradley Denton | Collection, 1995 |
| A Conflagration Artist by Bradley Denton | Collection, 1995 |
| Little Deaths by Ellen Datlow | Anthology, 1995 |
| The Man in the Black Suit by Stephen King | Short Story, 1995 |
| Towing Jehovah by James Morrow | Novel, 1995 |
| The Penguin Book Of Modern Fantasy By Women by Various | Anthology, 1996 |
| The Prestige by Christopher Priest | Novel, 1996 |
| Radio Waves by Michael Swanwick | Novella, 1996 |
| Seven Tales and a Fable by Gwyneth Jones | Collection, 1996 |
| A City in Winter by Mark Helprin | Novella, 1997 |
| Godmother Night: A Novel by Rachel Pollack | Novel, 1997 |
| Starlight 1 by Patrick Nielsen Hayden | Anthology, 1997 |
| The Wall of the Sky, the Wall of the Eye by Jonathan Lethem | Collection 1997 |
| Bending the Landscape: Original Gay and Lesbian Writing: Fantasy by Nicola Griffith | Anthology, 1998 |
| The Physiognomy by Jeffrey Ford | Novel, 1998 |
| Streetcar Dreams by Richard Bowes | Novella, 1998 |
| The Throne of Bones by Brian McNaughton | Collection, 1998 |
| The Antelope Wife: A Novel by Louise Erdrich | Novel, 1999 |
| Black Glass by Karen Joy Fowler | Collection, 1999 |
| Dreaming Down-Under by Jack Dann | Anthology, 1999 |
| The Specialist's Hat by Kelly Link | Short Story, 1999 |
| The Summer Isles by Ian R. MacLeod | Novella, 1999 |
| Moonlight & Vines by Charles de Lint | Collection, 2000 |
| Reave The Just And Other Tales by Stephen R. Donaldson | Collection, 2000 |
| Silver Birch, Blood Moon by Ellen Datlow | Anthology, 2000 |
| Sky Eyes by Laurel Winter | Novella, 2000 |
| Thraxas by Martin Scott | Novel, 2000 |
| Beluthahatchie and Other Stories by Andy Duncan | Collection, 2001 |
| Dark Matter: A Century of Speculative Fiction From the African Diaspora by Sheree R. Thomas | Anthology, 2001 |
| Declare by Tim Powers | Novel, 2001 |
| Galveston by Sean Stewart | Novel, 2001 |
| The Man on the Ceiling by Steve Rasnic Tem | Novella, 2001 |
| The Pottawatomie Giant by Andy Duncan | Short Fiction, 2001 |
| The Bird Catcher by S.P. Somtow | Novella, 2002 |
| The Museum of Horrors by Dennis Etchison | Anthology, 2002 |
| The Other Wind by Ursula K. Le Guin | Novel, 2002 |
| Queen For A Day by Albert E. Cowdrey | Short Fiction, 2002 |
| Skin Folk by Nalo Hopkinson | Collection, 2002 |
| Creation by Jeffrey Ford | Short Fiction, 2003 |
| The Facts of Life by Graham Joyce | Novel, 2003 |
| The Fantasy Writer's Assistant and Other Stories by Jeffrey Ford | Collection, 2003 |
| The Green Man: Tales from the Mythic Forest by Ellen Datlow | Anthology, 2003 |
| Leviathan Three by Forrest Aguirre | Anthology, 2003 |
| The Library by Zoran Zivkovic | Novella, 2003 |
| Ombria in Shadow by Patricia A. McKillip | Novel, 2003 |
| Bibliomancy by Elizabeth Hand | Collection, 2004 |
| A Crowd of Bone (short fiction) by Greer Gilman | Novella, 2004 |
| Don Ysidro by Bruce Holland Rogers | Short Fiction, 2004 |
| Strange Tales by Rosalie Parker | Anthology, 2004 |
| Tooth and Claw by Jo Walton | Novel, 2004 |
| Acquainted with the Night by Barbara Roden and Christopher Roden | Anthology, 2005 |
| Black Juice by Margo Lanagan | Collection, 2005 |
| Dark Matter: Reading the Bones by Sheree R. Thomas | Anthology, 2005 |
| The Growlimb by Michael Shea | Novella, 2005 |
| Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke | Novel, 2005 |
| Singing My Sister Down by Margo Lanagan | Short Fiction, 2005 |
| Commcomm by George Saunders | Short Fiction, 2006 |
| The Fair Folk by Marvin Kaye | Anthology, 2006 |
| Kafka on the Shore by Haruki Murakami | Novel, 2006 |
| The Keyhole Opera by Bruce Holland Rogers | Collection, 2006 |
| Voluntary Committal by Joe Hill | Novella, 2006 |
| Journey Into The Kingdom by M. Rickert | Short Fiction, 2007 |
| Map of Dreams by M. Rickert | Collection, 2007 |
| Salon Fantastique: Fifteen Original Tales of Fantasy by Ellen Datlow | Anthology, 2007 |
| Soldier of Sidon by Gene Wolfe | Novel, 2007 |
| The Evolution Of Trickster Stories Among The Dogs Of North Park After The Change by Kij Johnson | Short Story, 2008 |
| Illyria by Elizabeth Hand | Novella, 2008 |
| Inferno by Ellen Datlow | Anthology, 2008 |
| Singing Of Mount Abora by Theodora Goss | Short Story, 2008 |
| Tiny Deaths by Robert Shearman | Collection, 2008 |
| Ysabel by Guy Gavriel Kay | Novel, 2008 |
| Paper Cities: An Anthology of Urban Fantasy by Ekaterina Sedia | Anthology, 2009 |
| The Shadow Year by Jeffrey Ford | Novel, 2009 |
| Tender Morsels by Margo Lanagan | Novel, 2009 |
| American Fantastic Tales:Terror and the Uncanny from Poe to the Pulps (Library of America) by Peter Straub | Anthology, 2010 |
| The City & The City by China Miéville | Novel, 2010 |
| There Once Lived a Woman Who Tried to Kill Her Neighbor's Baby by Ludmilla Petrushevskaya | Collection, 2010 |
| The Very Best of Gene Wolfe by Gene Wolfe | Collection, 2010 |
