HomeGroupsTalkZeitgeist
Arrr! (Celebrate International Talk Like a Pirate Day) Thar be a hunt for treasure, Mateys!
This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.
  • LibraryThing
  • Book discussions
  • Your LibraryThing
  • Join to start using.

Tarzan DLE

Easton Press Collectors

Join LibraryThing to post.

1astropi
Oct 1, 2012, 1:56pm Top

Greetings all...
Some of you remember me, some probably do not. I don't post much any more for a number of reasons, but I still follow the "news" around the forum. EP has been releasing quite a number of DLEs many of which don't personally interest me, however I feel that EP has done great with their newest DLE, which they note:

"a stunning Deluxe Limited Edition, featuring eight new full-color works of art and several ornamentation illustrations by nine-time Hugo Award-winning artist Bob Eggleton, commissioned exclusively for this volume. Each book is personally signed by the artist."
item #: 2335

I think this is EP acting like the LEC, and I applaud it! If you like this, order the book, and let EP know you want more like it! By the way, a wonderful choice by EP as well (I've always wanted a high-quality edition of Tarzan of the Apes)

2UK_History_Fan
Oct 2, 2012, 12:07am Top

> 1
"I think this is EP acting like the LEC"

While I understand the point you are making, publishing a few overpriced "deluxe" editions of out of copyright titles does not really come close to what George Macy accomplished with the LEC. There is no letterpress printing, no regular subscription, no monthly letters, and with the possible exception of this volume, no original artwork and rarely any signatures by those involved in the book production. Quite frankly the DLEs from EP are barely distinguishable in quality from their "standard" works, just priced significantly higher and with the added exclusivity of a limited production run with numbered copies.

Seems to appeal primarily to two audiences: MBI owners padding their profit margins and resellers hoping to make a profit out of sold out copies of an apparently limited printing, mostly artificially manufactured through clever marketing.

That said, I have bought several titles, though I have no interest in this one, not because I have been fooled by the marketing hype, but because it was a book that greatly interested me for one reason or another. In retrospect, while I don't plan to return or resell any DLE titles I've purchased, I certainly don't put them in the same category as even the most pedestrian LEC and I always realized I was vastly overpaying for the privilege of ownership.

3SaxonWarlord
Oct 3, 2012, 9:56am Top

Not overly impressed with this one judging by the picture on the website.
I like the standard Tarzan series they did a few years ago better.

4jlabeatnik
Oct 3, 2012, 10:23am Top

I think it looks nice. I wouldn't mind knowing to how many copies it is actually limited to.

5iluvbeckett
Oct 3, 2012, 10:34am Top

>4 jlabeatnik:: I noticed the lack of a number too. Can they really call it a "Deluxe Limited Edition" and not tell how many copies there will be?

6astropi
Oct 3, 2012, 2:04pm Top

To my understanding this is limited to 800 copies.

7wailofatail
Oct 3, 2012, 2:09pm Top

>5 iluvbeckett:: I've noticed that with more recent announcements of DLEs, E/P often does not immediately indicate the number of copies to which the publication will be limited. The skeptic in me conjectures that they wait to see how much interest there is in the release before determining to how many copies to limit the edition. If there is high initial demand, probably 800 copies, less demand, perhaps 400 copies. In fact, we've previously seen DLE editions initially announced with higher limitations than they actually ended up printing, according to the number of copies indicated on the limitation page of the delivered copies, leading me to believe that the demand was less than they had originally anticipated and subsequently reduced.

It makes more sense from a marketing perspective to simply advertise a new release as 'limited' than to advertise it as less limited than it may actually turn out to be, which I suspect is the motive behind the new policy. I believe it will be limited but E/P may not even know yet just how limited. Which leads me back to my same old song ... aren't nearly all E/P editions limited editions, excepting their ongoing subscription series such as 'The 100 Greatest'?

8Arknight
Oct 3, 2012, 2:40pm Top

>7 wailofatail:

I would love to know how much a "normal" printing is, say for a book in the Reader's Choice series, for example.

9SilentInAWay
Oct 3, 2012, 8:26pm Top

10SilentInAWay
Oct 3, 2012, 8:29pm Top

>7 wailofatail: ...aren't nearly all E/P editions limited editions

Yes...but I assume that EP will not be reissuing those editions that they've published as a DLE. If they ever do, I would feel seriously misled.

11wailofatail
Edited: Oct 4, 2012, 12:27am Top

10: Good point ... they probably won't reissue the very same DLE. But what about the Super Deluxe Limited Edition, which might be a previously published Deluxe Limited Edition with a built-in fan, cup holder, arm rest and signatures of all the employees who handled the book during production?

Wasn't the Deluxe Limited Edition of Fahrenheit 451 simply a revamped edition of the previously released Signed Modern Classic, with a fancier cover and a slip case? The Signed Modern Classic edition itself was a recycled edition of the Masterpieces of Science Fiction edition but with the inclusion of the author's signature. And isn't the new Tarzan of the Apes a re-make of the previously re-leased edition from the Masterpieces of Science Fiction, but with a few extra illustrations and the artist's signature? I've already noted the previously advertised limited edition of Ulysses that is now part of the Great Books of the Twentieth Century series.

Regarding non-deluxe editions, even when Easton does re-issue particular titles, they typically introduce some cosmetic change that makes them unique from previously released issues, so each essentially becomes its own limited edition.

I realize I am being somewhat contrarian. I love E/P, including the DLEs, but I question if the dramatic difference in price between a DLE and a standard edition truly reflects added value or merely limited supply. Perhaps I too am feeling a bit manipulated by Easton Press marketing using the 'Limited' stamp as a cheap and easy means of increasing profit margins.

12Neil77
Jan 16, 2013, 10:27am Top

Received this DLE yesterday - its amazing - loved it - the illustrations are gorgeous, the leather is soft, the DLE is signed and the endpapers are gorgeous - a "must buy". I am glad that I had placed an order for it.....

13astropi
Jan 16, 2013, 7:49pm Top

12: indeed. One of the best DLEs I have seen, and frankly in my opinion this is on par with the Limited Editions Club books. The main difference being that LEC books are letterpress. Sure, letterpress would be nice, but it would never be affordable. Overall, a truly amazing book, and make sure to email EP and tell them you want to see more such books printed! Also, this was printed on the 100th anniversary of the publication of Tarzan, which is an added bonus!

14astropi
Jan 19, 2013, 4:20am Top

Not sure, but I think this DLE is now sold out.

15Wootle
Jan 19, 2013, 9:05am Top

14--Doubtful with 800 copies printed.

16wailofatail
Jan 19, 2013, 12:31pm Top

>14 astropi:: It still shows up on their web site as available, for what that's worth.

17eastonlionel
Feb 1, 2013, 7:57am Top

>2 UK_History_Fan: Good to know this is not a letterpress edition. I was wondering about that, and would have considered buying this as my first DLE if it had been.

With respect to EP and their printing policies, look at MBI, Inc.'s website and the brief history on there. The owners started the company to make "collectibles", starting with the Danbury Mint. Anyone out to make "collectibles" is 100% about marketing.

After owning the EP Jane Austen library for a couple of months, I finally had a chance to look through the books - very poor print quality, and not up to the quality of the HP reprints that EP does. I called EP customer service to ask about this, and was told very quickly that they don't modify the appearance of books from the original edition they are using as the basis for the EP edition (seemed like they were not answering this question for the first time!) So, essentially these are facsimile copies of the "first illustrated edition" from the early 1900s, warts and all! However, this is not stated anywhere in their advertisement or description of the books. (To the credit of EP, the rep had no problem taking them back for a refund, since I was unhappy with them, even though I was well past the 30 days return period.) This just leads me to conclude that EP is putting essentially no effort into the books they issue. They just find a book that is either out of copyright, or to which they own the copyright (the HP catalog), and reprint them in facsimile fashion with a leather cover, which often is not very imaginative. This explains why the 100 Greatest and other books based on HP/George Macy designs are such nice quality. Unfortunately, it means the prospective buyer needs to know something about the original edition of the title that EP is copying.

18UK_History_Fan
Feb 1, 2013, 10:24am Top

> 17
You are absolutely on point with the following statements:
"Anyone out to make "collectibles" is 100% about marketing." "This just leads me to conclude that EP is putting essentially no effort into the books they issue. They just find a book that is either out of copyright, or to which they own the copyright (the HP catalog), and reprint them in facsimile fashion with a leather cover, which often is not very imaginative."

I am disappointed to hear about the EP Austen Library. I own this but it is still shrink-wrapped and I have not examined it yet.

19eastonlionel
Edited: Feb 1, 2013, 11:27am Top

>18 UK_History_Fan:

Yes, I too was very disappointed. I hesitated calling EP about the Austen set, because the exterior is stunning with the red leather, gold stamping and black background to the gold lettering. If one can live with about one lettering defect per page (such as smudged or fuzzy letters, missing punctuation or parts of letters, or even a missing letter near the edge of the printing) then it's a nice set. However, at $60 per book, I expect clear printing. I would have admitted this is not Easton Press's fault if they had advertised the books as facsimile and even shown a sample page on the website and/or in the print catalog, but again, nothing is said about that in their advertising. Sometimes I think they count on people not reading their books.

20UK_History_Fan
Feb 1, 2013, 2:29pm Top

> 19
"Sometimes I think they count on people not reading their books."

Oh absolutely. I would be surprised if a majority of their customers actually read the books. I imagine they get a good number of people who merely "collect" things for the look rather than the info.

21LucasTrask
Feb 1, 2013, 7:07pm Top

"This just leads me to conclude that EP is putting essentially no effort into the books they issue. They just find a book that is either out of copyright, or to which they own the copyright (the HP catalog), and reprint them in facsimile fashion with a leather cover, which often is not very imaginative."

I agree 100% and it is why I much prefer Folio Society publications. Even when they go for out of copyright works FS resets the type and almost always pay for newly commissioned illustrations.

I have been sorely disappointed with E/P for both using images of the original pages and even more, the poor quality of many of the illustrations in their books. After finding how the illustrations in the E/P edition of Beowulf are supposed to look I created a comparison for the ten illustrations in common with the 1939 Heritage Press (or 1952 Limited Editions Book Club) edition. I was also disappointed to learn that E/P only used 10 of the 12 Ward illustrations.

22kdweber
Feb 1, 2013, 7:17pm Top

>21 LucasTrask: and yet for Fahrenheit 451 the E/P used one more Mugnaini illustration than did the LEC

23eastonlionel
Feb 1, 2013, 7:25pm Top

>21 LucasTrask:

Wow, thanks for sharing that comparison. It's almost like the EP pictures are totally different illustrations than the HP/LEC. The EP colors are so dark and blotchy, pretty bad. I've got a lot of EP books, but I guess I never knew the difference between their illustrations and the originals in the HP editions. Supposedly, the illustrations in the "Famous Editions" series were better than the 100 greatest series, hence the higher price of the famous editions, at least that is what I was told by an EP rep on the phone.

24EclecticIndulgence
Feb 1, 2013, 11:13pm Top

For these reasons, I stopped purchasing EP's. Specialized sets like Tolkien, Hemingway or a few DLE's... I make an exception for.

No 100 Greatest or Famous editions for me anymore...

I own the Beowulf Famous edition and I am incredibly disappointed with it. I also think the EP translations are generally poor, as they are generally past copyright and the age shows.

25kdweber
Feb 2, 2013, 2:37pm Top

>24 EclecticIndulgence: The Leonard Ellery translation of Beowulf was pretty standard when the great illustrated editions of the 20th century (e.g. Random House edition illustrated by Rockwell Kent or the LEC edition illustrated by Lynd Ward) were commissioned. These are beautiful editions; though, for reading purposes I definitely prefer Seamus Heaney and think the FS did a wonderful job with their bilingual deluxe edition. I wouldn't be without any of the three.

26astropi
Oct 26, 2014, 11:04pm Top

Does anyone know when this DLE sold out? I really wish EP would keep their webpage updated a bit better. Currently this is not listed at all on the EP website, while older DLEs are listed as "SOLD-OUT". By the way, there are some copies on ebay which are reasonably priced... I can only assume that resellers have not yet figured out that this is sold out (so purchase one now if you're thinking about)! By the way, this remains one of my favorite DLEs...

27supercell
Edited: Nov 26, 2014, 6:54pm Top

This message has been deleted by its author.

28jroger1
Edited: Oct 27, 2014, 12:47pm Top

>27 supercell:
I don't see Ovid there either. Wasn't it a DLE? Also "London." Their omission might be just an oversight.

29astropi
Oct 28, 2014, 4:05am Top

28: Wholly-molly! Good point. Ovid was one of the most amazing DLEs they released! Truly magnificent. I did not even notice that London sold out...

30Wootle
Edited: May 28, 4:04pm Top

I recently acquired this volume at a great price. Well worth picking up if you can get it for retail or thereabouts, which you can if you use a little patience. Larger than I had expected, lots of white space, but it looks fine. Illustrations are nice. Overall a nice package for a reasonable price. Lots of photos in the album, click the pic.

31HugoDumas
Edited: May 11, 4:52pm Top

>30 Wootle: is that my imagination or are there 5 inch margins? If so what possessed EP to design the book like that?

32Wootle
May 11, 3:29pm Top

The margins are 1.5" and 3" on the sides, and 3" on the bottom.

33supercell
Edited: Jun 29, 12:01am Top

This message has been deleted by its author.

34jroger1
Edited: May 11, 7:06pm Top

>33 supercell:
“Bringhurst describes a book page as a tangible proportion, which together with the textblock produce an antiphonal geometry, which has the capability to bind the reader to the book, or conversely put the reader's nerve on edge or drive the reader away.” - From the Wikipedia article, “Canons of Page Construction”

I have no idea what that means but it sounds very erudite. I have found all the page layouts in this series to be pleasant. Most of the stories are fairly short and so allow for significant white space on the pages. The 9x11 format might seem to be unnecessarily large, but it is needed to properly display the art, and yet is comfortable enough to read on one’s lap.

35astropi
May 11, 5:03pm Top

Easily one of the best DLEs in my opinion. You won't find other "fine editions" of Tarzan, thus this is quite unique, with fabulous illustrations of course.

36GOBOGIE
May 11, 6:41pm Top

It’s either TMC or AMC is running a Tarzan marathon this week

37jroger1
Edited: May 11, 7:23pm Top

>36 GOBOGIE:
Ignore this post.

Sorry, I thought I had the movie schedule but it was for the wrong year.

38astropi
May 11, 8:02pm Top

37: hate it when that happens :)

Group: Easton Press Collectors

550 members

28,511 messages

About

This topic is not marked as primarily about any work, author or other topic.

About | Contact | Privacy/Terms | Help/FAQs | Blog | Store | APIs | TinyCat | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | Common Knowledge | 128,808,988 books! | Top bar: Always visible