Recommended for you
Join LibraryThing to post.
This topic is currently marked as "dormant"—the last message is more than 90 days old. You can revive it by posting a reply.
Blog post: http://www.librarything.com/blogs/librarything/2011/06/recommended-for-you/
1. It doesn't have a "divot" and can't be moved. I need to talk to ConceptDawg about how a sometimes-appearing work-page element works in his section system.
2. The little number is the position on the list of recommendations. This number is changed by the way recommendations now put series together, but it can be seen on the "Recommendations" subpage for each work. Only the first 20 are considered—as it is, you'll notice some wonkiness. (We only show the first 10 on the main page for a work.)
It would be nice if it compressed books in the same series, like the regular recommendations do.
On the whole it seems interesting and potentially useful, though the fact that this came out of nowhere, presumably without a huge investment of time, really makes me wish you would give us access to other data too.
Yeah. Not a big deal. But it took a major database schema change. I'm doing a lot of that recently. So...
This was a quick detour from what I'm trying to work on today—Facebook. Don't distract me!
Okay, back to FB. But maybe you can spare a day sometime for a quick detour to things people have been asking about for ages?
So.... you are working, however "quick detour"-ly, on Recommendations. Does that mean that the multiple Recommendations-based bugs are going to be fixed soon? Please?
From the blog: It only lists books which you have marked to “include in recommendations.”
I take it this means collections so marked?
If a book is in two collections, do they both have to be so marked?
I freely admit I'm as hungover as ten men, but I'm not seeing this section.
This is an interesting idea, but I find the presentation confusing.
There has long been a module headed "Librarything recommendations" and below this header are books that LT recommends based on the work page you are looking at.
Now there is a module headed "Recommended for you" with the not particularly more helpful subheading "Recommended for you based on your books..." that lists books from your catalog that form part of the basis for recommending the work whose page you are currently looking at.
So, I figured it out but when I first looked at it I thought, wait, what's recommended for me? Those books are already in my catalog. What's this about?
I'd prefer a flashier "Recommended for you!" sticker at the top of that page that only displays the reasons for the recommendation if you click on it.
It sounded kind of confusing to me, too, but then I finally found a page with it in action and I kind of see how it works now.
It does make me wish there were a way to see the recommendations I hit "no thanks" for, so I could reverse that if I did it a few years ago, and now my reading tastes have changed... But then, any time something changes regarding the way recommendations are used/displayed, I hope to get a No Thanks List.
Yeah, I also find the presentation confusing for the same reasons others have mentioned. I do like the idea, though.
Perhaps it would be better as an icon at the top of the page, or a box on the sidebar. Is there some kind of image or icon that could represent "recommended"?
Please excuse my clumsiness but where is this new feature exactly?
I can't use Jim's excuse but I can't see this anywhere either...
15> For you, look at this work. Most people will see it on different pages.
To see this feature go to your recommendations page and click on any work on the list.
What I like is that Tim's example included a book by a Professor on my Dissertation committee--the 1688 book. I hadn't thought of that book in awhile. Dr. Wills was really nice too. Cool. Now I need to go look at the new feature. :) --Kim
Why a new recommendation feature? Why not improve the existing recommendation feature? I am going to be confused with two sorts of recommendations, when I only have the need for one.
It's not a new feature, just a new way of presenting the old one. It now shows on the work page if that book is on your current recommendation list.
It's not a new recommendation feature. It's a box on the pages of recommended books that explains why the book was recommended.
I agree that it would be better to have an icon at the top of the page that only showed the books if we clicked "why?".
Tim, I know you didn't want to put a lot of time into this but I agree with the others that the difference between Recommended for You and LibraryThing Recommendations isn't clear and this would work best as some sort of banner across the top of the page.
I wasn't aware that you could mark books to be included in recommendations or to be excluded from recommendations. How does one do this?
I appreciate you making this feature. A header change would be good, but the feature is very nice. :)
If you click "Why" under a title on the Recommendations page isn't this the same list, only more stable and in a different location?
29> Yes. It's the same info displayed in a different place. It probably didn't take Tim away from his other duties very long at all.
Yeah, the frustrating thing isn't the time spent for this, but the thought of how many other useful improvements could also be made very quickly if he'd just get around to it.
Not being a programmer I have no idea how long any of this would take.
They actually not QUITE the same list. Why would really get me into the weeds. But they are drawn from the same list--just deeper or shallower depending on context.
Not to mention that the "why" on the recommendations page is still giving a lot of errors.
Very cool, Tim. The parenthetical numbers still look a little "buggy" on a couple of the titles I looked at, but I'm sure you'll get them straightened out.
I just finally got around to checking this feature out, and I had some of the same confusion as above. I just really did not get what the heck "Recommended for you based on your books..." meant. As some posts above, I thought it meant the following things were recommendations.
I wonder if it couldn't be better phrased. Maybe: "This book is recommended for you based on your books:"
What are your thoughts about changing the display entirely? I'd find it much more useful as an icon near the top of the page, as someone suggested above. By the time I'm interested enough to scroll down and look at the work page further, it doesn't really matter whether it's recommended or not. On the other hand, an easily-noticeable recommendation icon might make me look further when I would otherwise just have passed by.
#37 by timspalding> Cool, thanks. I also debated book/work, as it's always a judgment call which one sounds right in a given place (even when it's technically one or the other).
I think there is something to be said for the icon idea. Right now, I'm about as likely to notice the recommendation as I am to notice the Wikipedia citation...
38> Right, as a quick fix the wording change is good but this is something about the book and you, not just about the book. So it makes sense to highlight that LT is recommending this book to you! It really doesn't belong with the rest of the information that is just about the book that would be the same for anyone.
This group does not accept members.
This topic is not marked as primarily about any work, author or other topic.