Join LibraryThing to post.
This topic is currently marked as "dormant"—the last message is more than 90 days old. You can revive it by posting a reply.
Illustrations are very interesting...I want to compare them to the FS edition tonight.
Can't wait, they told me today it shipped out a bit ago, I should get it this week. Looks great. Thanks for the photo's.
Looks gorgeous! Thanks for the pics... I think. Is it good to say thanks for something that gives you bookenvy?
5: Thanks, but I'm not the one who purchased it. Congratulations should be sent to Wootle!
I noticed that E/P used Signed Modern Classics signature sheets while the title page just states 'signed limited edition'. What do the title pages of the normal Signed Moderen Classics state?
The title page of the SMC book says "Signed Collector's Edition" I also noticed that the first four lines of the poem on the title page have been omitted from the LE edition. The omitted lines are
A fourth-generation German-American
now living in easy circumstances
on Cape Cod
and smoking too much,
It's not only the SMC - there are two copies of this book in my house from different publishers and they both have the complete 'poem' on the title page. Why would the first four lines be omitted from this expensive LE?
I also thought that a first, but I see no reason to also remove the first three lines. Maybe it was a consortium of the anti-smoking, anti-German(-American), anti-easy circumstances and anti-Cape Cod lobbies. ;-)
The first thing that comes to mind--why on earth did they use the same skull and crossbones illustration for the cover of a limited edition as you find on the $5 paperback???
I'll follow that with a pair of general questions about E.P. LEs:
Is the leather of a higher quality than, say, the 100 Best series?
Could they perhaps have been a bit more imaginative with their endpapers? Silk is what they use on their run of the mill productions!
I love Vonnegut and particularly SH5, but I guess I'm in a bit of a critical mood.
8: Tom, that was a good observation. I wonder if originally the poem was shorter and later Vonnegut changed it? That is one possibility, or perhaps EP simply screwed up? I would not call this omission serious, but definitely perplexing. If you had not point it out, I would never have noticed.
I can't find any mention of the title page ever changing, therefore it seems plausible that EP simply messed-up. Ah well, no one is perfect!
I checked on wikipedia and the "poem" is part of the the book's full title. It is hard to understand why EP would abridge the title of an LE book when they haven't done it in their other publications of the book.
This might be a "stretcher" (as Huck Finn would have said) of a guess, but maybe EP is covering themselves
(legally and/or copyright speaking) with that omission; those lines say "now living" etc. Vonnegut has been dead for four years now and maybe it ties in with it being a signed edition. The previous signed edition from EP was in 1998(?) (We've speculated in another thread about this new DLE how Vonnegut could have signed 850 copies AFTER he shuffled off.) How do such emendations of text or title page matter (if unauthorized) stand in terms of copyright issues? Any fine legal minds care to chime in?
Lastly, how many other people have noticed that there is a "smiling face" on the bottom of the spine of the Slaughterhouse-Five book? It's evil...
>16 iluvbeckett: Vonnegut must have signed many pages for the SMC edition in 1998, which would explain the SMC logo in the LE. Even though the page sizes of the LE and SMC are different, perhaps all EP's signature pages are a standard size and are cut to fit the actual volumes. When I subscribed to SMC, Vonnegut was alive and Slaughterhouse Five was the first book sent to new subscribers, which might explain the large number of signed pages. Does anyone know if that is true today and if the SMC edition is even still available?
A quick short review and set of pictures on this DLE are now up at Books and Vines, though no matching Wootle's pictures!
Hi, I'm new to this board and have a question that hopefully someone can answer:
I originally purchased the Signed Modern Classic of "Slaughterhouse Five" in 1999 and have the original invoice from Easton.
It is still sealed, and is the dark blue leather version, however on the binding it does not say "signed edition". I want to sell it as signed but don't want to open it to verify it's signed. I saw the exact style sold as signed through Heritage Auctions but they had no photo of the signed page.
Any help/information would be greatly appreciated. Thank You in advance.
This topic is not marked as primarily about any work, author or other topic.