This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.
  • LibraryThing
  • Book discussions
  • Your LibraryThing
  • Join to start using.

Why I voted "no"? (Tag separation/combination) #12

This is a continuation of the topic Why I voted "no"? (Tag separation/combination) #11.


Join LibraryThing to post.

Sep 16, 10:55pm Top

NINE people think brain cancer and breast cancer are the same thing.


Sep 16, 10:55pm Top

NINE people think brain cancer and breast cancer are the same thing.


Sep 17, 11:30am Top

Regarding Edward III from the previous thread, the tag "Edward III" already has "Edward III of England" and "Edward III (1327 - 1377)" and "Edward III Plantagenet". I would separate them out, but I'd rather combine the other Edward III tags into it instead.

Sep 22, 9:55am Top

Children--Conduct of Life--Juvenile Fiction and Children-Conduct of life-Juvenile literature are Library of Congress Subject Headings with different meanings. The former is for fiction and the latter is for works that aren't fiction, drama or poetry.

Sep 23, 12:33pm Top

Series: Gap Cycle and series:gap saga have been proposed for combination with Gap Series even though the latter (unlike the first two) have two books in a different Gap series by a different author that haven't been tagged as sagas or cycles (voting here).

The Flower Shop Mystery Series and Flower Shop Mysteries series are used on different flower shop mystery series books by different authors (voting here).

book series: percy jackson is up for combo with series-percy jackson even though the series has two movies out, though admittedly not yet tagged in the latter (voting here). I similarly voted against Percy Jackson and the Olympians #1 with Book One Percy Jackson and the Olympians (voting here).

Critias can refer to the dialogue by Plato where the reference to the person in the title is apparently a matter of dispute, so not necessarily Critias 460B-403BC (voting here).

genre fiction is up for combination with fiction. genre which is maybe used to tag a book the owner deemed genre fiction, or maybe just indicating one "genre" of the book is fiction (genre fiction is something specific, not just any or all fiction), but in any case, fiction. genre has also been proposed for combination with Genre -Fiction and - GENRE: Fiction, which are both being used to indicate that the books are fiction, but not necessarily genre fiction (lots are children's books) (voting here).

Sep 27, 8:27pm Top

>6 omargosh: And yet, there are seven yes votes...

Sep 27, 8:31pm Top

Those most be "farseers" who know that one day two will indeed equal three.

Sep 27, 8:50pm Top

Maybe a sign of these post-truth times we live in?

Sep 27, 8:58pm Top

I voted against combining Victorian Era (1837 -1901)* with Victorian Era because an era is not always tightly defined. 1837-1901 is the years of Victoria's reign, but not necessarily what a particular person might consider the era.

* http://www.librarything.com/tag/Victorian+Era+%281837+-1901%29

Oct 6, 12:05pm Top

https://www.librarything.com/tag/ile+rien+series is up for combination with
even though others have long ago made these into 2 different series:
with the overlap reflected in the tagging. The "fall of" books seem just to be a subset (voting here).

Edited: Oct 7, 4:58pm Top

"Carriere" is used for the artist and the playwright, as well as "careers": http://www.librarything.com/tag/detail/Carriere#combinations

"Carreras" is used primarily for the tenor: http://www.librarything.com/tag/detail/Carreras#combinations

"Pagano" is an architect: http://www.librarything.com/tag/detail/pagano#combinations

"Hadas" is also used for Moses Hadas: http://www.librarything.com/tag/detail/hadas#combinations

Oct 8, 8:23pm Top

"Newbery" may refer to Newbery Medal books as well as Newbery Honor books. They are not the same.

"Newberry", while it may at times be a misspelling of "Newbery", may also refer to the Newberry Library, the Newberry Consort, authors named "Newberry", etc.


Oct 9, 11:09pm Top

Well, here they are again: http://www.librarything.com/tag/detail/fiction#combinations

(proposals to combine "fiction" with "skönlitteratur" and "Belletristik")

Oct 10, 5:21am Top

>15 lilithcat: Okay, we have the disambiguation area now, can we fill it in to slow these down?

Oct 12, 1:37am Top

>17 omargosh: It's good to remember that the notice will stay when the suggestion is history. It is important to mention the two things that shouldn't be combined and to put it on both tags.

Oct 14, 2:56pm Top

James M. Buchanan (diplomat) (1803–1876), American jurist and diplomat
James M. Buchanan (1919–2013), American economist, Nobel prize winner


Group: Combiners!

820 members

48,418 messages


This topic is not marked as primarily about any work, author or other topic.


No touchstones

About | Contact | Privacy/Terms | Help/FAQs | Blog | Store | APIs | TinyCat | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | Common Knowledge | 129,544,099 books! | Top bar: Always visible