Click to flag this message as abuse

What is abuse? (1) personal attacks, (2) commercial solicitation, (3) spam. See terms of use.

Group:  Working Class ignore
Topic:  Is writing work? 0 / 5 read

Feb 27, 2008, 9:35pm (top)Message 1: ostrom

Whether writing is work depends on how you define "writing" and "work" (but not, I think, on how you define "is," apologies to a recent president), I guess. One certainly needs to work at writing, as well as play it--in terms of improvisation and invention. So there's that. And if you get paid for writing, that might make writing, officially, work. But are writers laborers? As a writer in many venues, I've worked hard, but as a former laborer, I do have, in the back of my mind, a voice that whispers, "Writing really isn't work." Opinions?

Feb 28, 2008, 1:03pm (top)Message 2: TLCrawford

Writing really isn't work. I would love to discuss it at length but in addition to work I have three papers to write in the next nine days.

Not to mention read 300 pages, take one midterm and one final exam and give a Powerpoint presentation.

Feb 28, 2008, 5:57pm (top)Message 3: krolik

Writing is hard work of a sort but in macroeconomic terms it is largely irrelevant so I would be reluctant to describe it as labor.

Maybe it's similar to the exertions of someone who tries to excel at sport. A person expels much energy, maybe extreme amounts, and a few might achieve something extraordinary; but there is also something rarefied or even frivolous about it.

That requires no apology. No reason to go about pofaced--a little frivolity can be a tonic in a tough world.

Feb 29, 2008, 12:17am (top)Message 4: ostrom

Great responses. I enjoyed them immensely, and they generally reflect my own views, even as I keep scribbling. ;-)

Apr 29, 2008, 4:41am (top)Message 5: BGP

It is certainly work, and, while not always laborious, labor as well.

(back to top)

Debug test: your member name is:

Help/FAQs | About | Privacy/Terms | Blog | Contact | APIs | WikiThing | Common Knowledge | 46,920,314 books!