|
Loading... The Bounty : The True Story of the Mutiny on the Bountyby Caroline Alexander
LibraryThing recommendationsMember recommendationsLoading...
won't like
will probably not like
will probably like
will like
will love Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. A how-to book on making history boring. ( )I've had this book in my library for years and finally picked it up a month or two ago. I had no idea that I'd be swept into one of the most interesting narrative histories I've ever read. Alexander has done her research thoroughly and what I find most astounding is just how much source material she had to work with. I'm new to British Naval history and I was amazed that they'd managed to preserve the logs and letters. What was even more astonishing was that the evidence she compiles for this book paints Bligh in such a contrasting light than the rest of the world knows him. We can all spout what we've 'heard' about the reputation of Captain Bligh, but when the facts are laid bare, the story changes dramatically. I now find myself defending Captain Bligh at every turn and encouraging people to read this fantastic book. Alexander's writing is clear and supremely interesting. She takes the time to explain the naval lingo and the ramifications of log entries and the actions of the Admiralty. I ended up feeling sympathy for Bligh and just a bit of rage at how he was mistreated. You may not be swept along as thoroughly as I was, but I doubt you'll be able to look at this epic true story in the same way again. Perhaps it's because I was trying to listen to this story while I was driving on a boring stretch of I55, but I found this book hard to follow. Alexander clearly did a terrific job of researching because the level of detail in this story is high and, I assume, accurate. There are numerous characters and lots of switching gears from one aspect of the story to another. I'll have to try it again because I never finished it -- I simply lost interest because it was boring. The story of The Bounty is a fascinating one, and in this book, Caroline Alexander handles it skillfully. She quotes extensively from journals, letters, and court transcripts. William Bligh, of course, has the most say, because he kept the official ship’s log as well as a personal diary. However, Alexander makes a point of quoting others or seeking out facts to back up Bligh’s assertions. The true facts are at times difficult to discern, and Alexander is careful to indicate where different people’s accounts agree and disagree, and where their stories change over time. Like most popular histories, this book does not include footnotes, but the sources are described in detail in the back of the book. There are times when Alexander goes into too much detail for a general reader like me; I was not especially interested in the details of each crewman’s background and ultimate fate, and the point-by-point description of the trial got tedious. However, once I decided that I didn’t need to remember every crewman’s name and position, as well as where he was on the night of the mutiny, this was less of a problem. If you’re at all interested in seafaring stories of the 18th century, I highly recommend this book. It’s readable and very well researched. Alexander seems able to get her mind into an entirely different culture, looking at these sea-faring men in context and accepting their values for what they were instead of expecting them to live by the rules of the 21st century or of the landlubber. And that’s what I like in a history. See my complete review at my blog. Re-images Captain Bligh from tyrant to victim. Good, but a bit dry. no reviews | add a review
References to this work on external resources.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Book description |
|
(retrieved from Amazon Fri, 24 Apr 2009 07:58:05 -0400)
The first test round has been closed. Visit the Open Shelves Classification group for details.
Quick Links |