|
Loading... Siddarthaby Hermann Hesse
LibraryThing recommendationsMember recommendations
Loading...
won't like
will probably not like
will probably like
will like
will love Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. A classic story of the search for enlightenment, Buddhist-style. Translation by Hilda Rosner I reread this for my book club more than 30 years after my first read, and found it less compelling than it was then. Siddhartha is a strange little book. It tells the life story of a Buddha-like figure who spends his entire life seeking enlightenment, and I don't feel like it's much of a spoiler to reveal that in the end he finds it. But though it longs to achieve a high level of profundity, I found it to be too brief and simplistic to make, at least on me, the kind of impact that the book is renowned for. Perhaps it was a poor choice of edition for me, but I was dismayed after reading the back of the book to find that the first sentence of the blurb essentially summarized the entire first half of the book. The young Siddhartha, a young Brahmin, endeavors to discover enlightenment when his education and pursuit of knowledge leave him feeling empty. He follows the ascetic lifestyle of the Samanas with his friend Govinda, but is again left unsatisfied. He then pursues a life of the flesh, which (unsurprisingly) doesn't do it for him either. How he does find his true enlightenment I shall leave the reader to discover. My own description of the plot, which admittedly mirrors the aforementioned blurb, highlights what I feel is the novel's weakness. It reads overly simplistically, presenting each conflict and situation that Siddhartha faces as a decision to follow the opposite path when one path runs empty. The move from Samana to wealthy businessman, for instance, feels particularly forced, for it feels like someone as devoted as Siddhartha (even if he is dissatisfied) would find it difficult to go so completely against his character. Hesse, I think, wants us to find the journey a challenge, but his insistence on relying on extremes makes the impact feel hollow and forced. The result is of Siddhartha's lack of complexity is that the Eastern life, the major theme of the book, feels overly simple and uncomplicated as well. Siddhartha's rearing as the son of a Brahmin, one of the higher castes, allows him the kind of freedom that is not entitled to the lower castes, and Hesse does not give us a good sense of the sacrifices he makes when he abandons all of his possessions to pursue the Samana's lifestyle. There is also very little sense of the excess that he experiences as an associate of Kamaswami. It is as if Hesse is more satisfied to tell, rather than show, what things are like for Siddhartha throughout the story, and this diminishes the impact significantly. What the book lacks in impact, however, it does make up for in readability, which is why my assessment is so mixed. The book is written in simple, straightforward language and is very easy to digest, which I'm sure is a huge part of its appeal. But I can't help thinking that a book that deals with such a serious and involved topic would take such a common, simplistic approach. I was left expecting more from Siddhartha--and for a novel that wants so badly to be complete, that is perhaps its strongest downfall. Auf der Suche nach dem Ich: Siddharta ist auf der Suche. Nach dem eigenen Ich, Erkenntnis, Erfüllung, Glück. Auf seiner Suche probiert er viele Wege aus: Von der Askese bis hin zum Leben im Überfluss...Wird Siddharta sich selbst finden? Ein Buch zum Genießen. Hermann Hesse lässt den Leser in einer wunderschönen Sprache an seiner Gedankenwelt teilnehmen. "Siddharta" ist kein Buch, das man mal so eben verschlingen kann. Es braucht Zeit die Geschichte aufzunehmen und zu verarbeiten und manchmal kann auch erneutes Lesen erforderlich sein. Vor allem das Ende hat mich persönlich sehr zum Nachdenken gebracht und ist mir trotzdem noch nicht ganz klar geworden. Dafür offenbart das Buch nach jedem neuen Lesen auch wieder neue Erkenntnisse, von denen ich persönlich einige als sehr hilfreich empfand, einige Ansätze jedoch gar nicht teilen kann. All die Leser, die von der hektischen Welt einmal Abstand nehmen wollen und die Ruhe finden sich "dem Suchen" zu öffnen, werden es mögen. A very inspiring story about Siddhartha's transcendence to become the Buddha. This novel takes the reader through Siddhartha's entire journey starting from his decision, as a child, to trade in his life of luxury, for a more simplistic one as he sets off to reach enlightenment. A very intriguing book. I felt enlightened as i read it! Enjoy :)
[It] attempts to postulate an answer to the riddle of man's confused and contradictory existence in this universe.
Amazon.com Amazon.com Review (ISBN 0553208845, Mass Market Paperback)In the shade of a banyan tree, a grizzled ferryman sits listening to the river. Some say he's a sage. He was once a wandering shramana and, briefly, like thousands of others, he followed Gotama the Buddha, enraptured by his sermons. But this man, Siddhartha, was not a follower of any but his own soul. Born the son of a Brahmin, Siddhartha was blessed in appearance, intelligence, and charisma. In order to find meaning in life, he discarded his promising future for the life of a wandering ascetic. Still, true happiness evaded him. Then a life of pleasure and titillation merely eroded away his spiritual gains until he was just like all the other "child people," dragged around by his desires. Like Hermann Hesse's other creations of struggling young men, Siddhartha has a good dose of European angst and stubborn individualism. His final epiphany challenges both the Buddhist and the Hindu ideals of enlightenment. Neither a practitioner nor a devotee, neither meditating nor reciting, Siddhartha comes to blend in with the world, resonating with the rhythms of nature, bending the reader's ear down to hear answers from the river. In this translation Sherab Chodzin Kohn captures the slow, spare lyricism of Siddhartha's search, putting her version on par with Hilda Rosner's standard edition. --Brian Bruya(retrieved from Amazon Tue, 05 Jan 2010 11:41:40 -0500) The first test round has been closed. Visit the Open Shelves Classification group for details. |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
I think this book is relevant to everyone, because although it is telling the tale of a spiritual and religious man, it is also a tale about life and how our life experiences make us who we are. Many of Siddhartha's feelings and thoughts are common to us all as we make our way along the road of our own lives. This book reaffirms the fact that in the end we are all the same, and someone who has stayed in the same place all their life can be as wise as someone who has spent his life travelling on a long search for the truth. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book. Its message appears to be that we are all the same and all of our life experiences whether good or bad, are necessary for us to find ourselves, and even though everyone will go through different things, we are all bonded by the fact that we are on the same journey. I believe everyone who reads this book will be touched in some way by the simple and poignant words. I would recommend this to everyone, it's a very enlightening and though-provoking read. (