|
Loading... The Tin Drumby Gunter Grass (otherwise under Günter Grass)
LibraryThing recommendationsMember recommendationsLoading...
won't like
will probably not like
will probably like
will like
will love Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. Could The Onion Cellar be the greatest mise-en-scène in German literature? To date, I think so. ( )I was so excited to finally read this book, but I can't finish it. Oskar is a narcissistic brat. Oskar's likes: intentionally breaking glass with his piercing shrieks, incessantly banging on his tin drum, and comparing himself to Jesus (but in a boring way). Oskar's dislikes: narrating from one point-of-view, not obsessing over his stupid tin drum. He may be self-absorbed because he's young, and his tin drum may symbolize something, but the author makes it impossible to care enough to investigate further. Maybe this would make a good short story, but as a 565 page novel, it's just tedious. Couldn't Grass throw a plot or sympathetic characters in somewhere? Or does it happen later? This won a prize? Can somebody tell me why? What a strange book. I'm not sure how else to describe the life story of a midget with a neurotic attachment to his toy drum and a voice that can shatter glass. Add in the fact that most of it takes place in Germany during WWII and it's all narrated from a bed in a mental hospital, and you have one truly bizarre tale. It took me an unusually long time to read this book. It wasn't bad, just very dense and difficult to read a lot of at a time. In fact, the absurdity was quite funny in places, but maybe I just have a strange sense of humor. The passages I read out loud baffled my husband. In short, I have absolutely no idea why this book is considered a classic in some circles, but I'm glad I read it. It's definitely one story I won't be forgetting anytime soon. I would give the movie 4/5. The novel was too heavy for me with many long sentences. Suitable if you want to write a thesis, but not very good as an entertaining read. The characters are interesting to analyze, but I think they are fairly unlikeable. The bizarre and disturbing Oscar burns into your brain, whether you like or dislike "The Tin Drum." This is not an easy read and shouldn't be taken on lightly. Gunter Grass is a powerful, very European writer - some of this work has echoes of dark mittel-European forest folk tales. Indeed Grass is including an awful lot of heavy stuff and repacking it in the macabre tale of Oscar's life. Perhaps this is a redemptive or rather palliative exercise - certainly the discharge can be hard to take. A dark masterpiece. Oh and John Irvine, take a real look at Owen Meany, compare him to Oscar and weep. Drum beats armadillo hands down. No contest. no reviews | add a review
References to this work on external resources.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Book description |
|
There was once a grocer who closed his store one day in November, because something was doing in town; taking his son Oskar by the hand, he boarded a Number 5 streetcar and rode to the Langasser Gate, because there as in Zoppot and Langfuhr the synagogue was on fire. The synagogue had almost burned down and the firemen were looking on, taking care that the flames should not spread to other buildings. Outside the wrecked synagogue, men in uniform and others in civilian clothes piled up books, ritual objects, and strange kinds of cloth. The mound was set on fire and the grocer took advantage of the opportunity to warm his fingers and his feelings over the public blaze.As Oskar grows older (though not taller), portents of war transform into the thing itself. Danzig is the first casualty when, in the summer of 1939, residents turn against each other in a pitched battle between Poles and Germans. In the years that follow, Oskar goes from one picaresque adventure to the next--he joins a troupe of traveling musicians; he becomes the leader of a group of anarchists; he falls in love; he becomes a recording artist--until some time after the war, he is convicted of murder and confined to a mental hospital.
The Tin Drum uses savage comedy and a stiff dose of magical realism to capture not only the madness of war, but also the black cancer at the heart of humanity that allows such degradations to occur. Grass wields his humor like a knife--yes, he'll make you laugh, but he'll make you bleed, as well. There have been many novels written about World War II, but only a handful can truly be called great; The Tin Drum, without a doubt, is one. --Alix Wilber
(retrieved from Amazon Fri, 24 Apr 2009 07:58:17 -0400)
The first test round has been closed. Visit the Open Shelves Classification group for details.
Quick Links |