HomeGroupsTalkZeitgeist
Hide this

Results from Google Books

Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.

The Lost History of 1914: Reconsidering the…
Loading...

The Lost History of 1914: Reconsidering the Year the Great War Began

by Jack Beatty

MembersReviewsPopularityAverage ratingMentions
743161,401 (3.8)2
None

None.

Loading...

Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book.

No current Talk conversations about this book.

» See also 2 mentions

Showing 3 of 3
Interesting treatment of "what if" scenarios for preventing the First World War. Or.....conversely, scenarios of reasons why world leaders acted the way they did due to circumstances in their own country. There always has been a thesis that countries enter wars (or seek external enemies) in order to quell internal disturbances (revolutions).

Beatty does a nice job of reviewing situations in France, Germany, Britain, Russia and Austria-Hungary which if there had been different decisions or different leadership the war could have been at least postponed or perhhaps avoided. He even expands on the relationship between Mexico and the US which lead to the infamous "Zimmermann telegram".

An interesting read. ( )
  douboy50 | Sep 25, 2012 |
Most people learn that the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria was the spark that ignited World War I, and that, because of interlocking military alliances, the war was inevitable even without that specific immediate cause. However, in The Lost History of 1914, Jack Beatty challenges the theory of the war’s inevitability. Countries are not monolithic, and Beatty shows that there were statesmen around in 1914 who might have avoided war. He writes, “Regarding war as improbable…leaders took risks that made it possible. Armageddon happened because men believed it could not happen.”

Beatty describes the situation in each of the principal belligerent states in the years immediately prior to the outbreak of the war. In each country, an event or events that “almost happened” might have been sufficient to keep them out of the war.

Pre-war Germany could be characterized as an army with a state rather than a state with an army. This status was exacerbated in 1912 when the Social Democrats, an anti-militarist party, made a political misjudgment, allowing for militaristic parties to build a majority coalition.

In Russia, some officials wanted peace at any cost, since they understood that a war would undoubtedly bring about a revolution of the country’s oppressed classes. Unfortunately, Germany was aware of Russia’s dilemma and sought to exploit it, sending a German general to command a Turkish army corps based in Constantinople. Russia became fearful that Germany might close the Turkish Straits to her, cutting off her only all-season sea route. Thus, fear of encirclement motivated Russia to mobilize against Austria after the assassination despite the risk of domestic revolution. (As Henry Morganthau later observed, “In the perspective of history, [the Bolshevik Revolution] may well appear as nothing more than the economic consequences of the closing of the Straits.”)

In 1914, it was actually England that may have been the country in Europe closest to revolution. The issue of Home Rule for Ireland had become extremely contentious. Beatty opines that the Ulster crisis was a contributing cause of the war rather than a barrier because Germany and Austria believed England would be unable to fight a continental war, being so close to civil war. In the event, the Irish mostly rallied around the Crown in 1914. Nevertheless, even when faced with severe manpower shortages, the British never drafted Irish soldiers because they were thought to be unreliable. Indeed, in1916, the Catholic southern counties of Ireland erupted in the Easter Uprising.

The United States entered the war only in 1917, and did so by a circuitous route related to the Mexican Revolution. Because of America’s incompetence against Pancho Villa, Germany concluded that the American military would not pose a threat. In 1917, German ambassador Arthur Zimmerman tried to get Mexico to enter WWI on the side of Germany, offering them New Mexico, Arizona, and California if the Central Powers were successful. British intelligence intercepted the offer in the notorious Zimmerman Telegram and disclosed its contents to the Americans. This provocation proved too much for American public opinion, and the U.S. entered the war on the side of the Triple Entente.

In France, Joseph Caillaux, the leader of the Radical party, favored a policy of conciliation with Germany. In 1914 he was Minister of Finance and was expected to become Prime Minister shortly but for a scandal involving his wife. Had he been premier at the time of the assassination, Beatty argues that he would have sought peace with the Central Powers, and based on his previous record, he might have been successful at avoiding war.

As for Austria-Hungary, Beatty contends that if Franz Ferdinand had not been assassinated, he would have become Emperor very shortly (Emperor Francis Joseph was 84 in 1914). Since he was more concerned with controlling Hungary than with warring against Serbia, his domestic policies would have prevented Austria-Hungary from initiating a continental war.

Beatty does not limit his analysis to events that might have precluded the war—he also describes other aspects of the era that have been neglected by historians or, as he calls them, "lost." But for the most part, he is concerned with explicating the causes for WWI.

Beatty is contrasting (though not explicitly rebutting) David Fromkin’s thesis in the masterful book Europe’s Last Summer: Who Started the Great War in 1914? Fromkin argues that the assassination of Franz Ferdinand provided the pretext the major powers needed to proceed with the Great War they all wanted. (As an example, he notes that Vienna started drafting the memorandum-plan to crush Serbia two weeks BEFORE Sarajevo.) Fromkin places especial blame on Germany's General Helmuth von Moltke, but contends that all the Powers sought war. As Teddy Roosevelt said in 1897, "No triumph of peace is quite so great as the supreme triumphs of war."

Adam Hochschild also addresses the War’s causes in his latest book, To End All Wars. His focus is more on Zeitgeist, contending that the impetus to war was built on multiple illusions: (1) wars are quick and easy; (2) you will shoot at the enemy but they will not shoot at you; and (3) weaponry doesn’t change or advance: whatever helped you in the last war will help you in the current one. These illusions were probably shared by the belligerents of WWI. Beatty doesn’t address these issues, being more concerned with specific people and events that proved definitive.

Evaluation: Beatty makes an excellent contribution to a growing body of literature asserting that the hecatomb of WWI might never have occurred but for a few little-known flips of history’s coins. This stimulating book shows how contingent earth shaking events can be.

(JAB) ( )
  nbmars | May 29, 2012 |
Compelling testimony to the background intrigues of the primary belligerents in 1914. Although familiar with many of the issues facing Germany, France, Austria-Hungary, Russia, England the the U.S., Beatty's book uncovers even deeper layers to expose at the same time the inevitability of and opportunites to avoid the coming disaster. ( )
  Parkerla1961 | May 25, 2012 |
Showing 3 of 3
no reviews | add a review
You must log in to edit Common Knowledge data.
For more help see the Common Knowledge help page.
Series (with order)
Canonical title
Original title
Alternative titles
Original publication date
People/Characters
Important places
Important events
Related movies
Awards and honors
Epigraph
Dedication
First words
Quotations
Last words
Disambiguation notice
Publisher's editors
Blurbers
Publisher series

References to this work on external resources.

Wikipedia in English

None

Book description
Haiku summary

Amazon.com Product Description (ISBN 0802778119, Hardcover)

In The Lost History of 1914, Jack Beatty offers a highly original view of World War I, testing against fresh evidence the long-dominant assumption that it was inevitable. "Most books set in 1914 map the path leading to war," Beatty writes. "This one maps the multiple paths that led away from it."

Chronicling largely forgotten events faced by each of the belligerent countries in the months before the war started in August, Beatty shows how any one of them-a possible military coup in Germany; an imminent civil war in Britain; the murder trial of the wife of the likely next premier of France, who sought détente with Germany-might have derailed the war or brought it to a different end. In Beatty's hands, these stories open into epiphanies of national character, and offer dramatic portraits of the year's major actors-Kaiser Wilhelm, Tsar Nicholas II , Woodrow Wilson, along with forgotten or overlooked characters such as Pancho Villa, Rasputin, and Herbert Hoover. Europe's ruling classes, Beatty shows, were so haunted by fear of those below that they mistook democratization for revolution, and were tempted to "escape forward" into war to head it off. Beatty's powerful rendering of the combat between August 1914 and January 1915 which killed more than one million men, restores lost history, revealing how trench warfare, long depicted as death's victory, was actually a life-saving strategy.

Beatty's deeply insightful book-as elegantly written as it is thought-provoking and probing-lights a lost world about to blow itself up in what George Kennan called "the seminal catastrophe of the twentieth century." It also arms readers against narratives of historical inevitability in today's world.

(retrieved from Amazon Mon, 30 Sep 2013 14:00:56 -0400)

Challenges beliefs that World War I was inevitable, documenting largely forgotten events in each of the warring countries to reveal how several factors may have prevented the war or caused a different outcome.

» see all 2 descriptions

Quick Links

Swap Ebooks Audio
11 wanted2 pay

Popular covers

Rating

Average: (3.8)
0.5
1
1.5
2 1
2.5
3 2
3.5
4 5
4.5
5 2

Is this you?

Become a LibraryThing Author.

 

Help/FAQs | About | Privacy/Terms | Blog | Contact | LibraryThing.com | APIs | WikiThing | Common Knowledge | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | 89,551,688 books! | Top bar: Always visible