HomeGroupsTalkZeitgeist
Hide this

Results from Google Books

Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.

Carnival of Souls by Melissa Marr
Loading...

Carnival of Souls (edition 2012)

by Melissa Marr

MembersReviewsPopularityAverage ratingMentions
3043936,791 (3.67)4
Member:jmchshannon
Title:Carnival of Souls
Authors:Melissa Marr
Info:HarperCollins (2012), Hardcover, 320 pages
Collections:Your library
Rating:
Tags:None

Work details

Carnival of Souls by Melissa Marr

None

None.

Loading...

Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book.

No current Talk conversations about this book.

» See also 4 mentions

Showing 1-5 of 39 (next | show all)
This book is intense. The world building is seamless and perfect. I really really hope that someday we can entice Ms. Marr to write an adult book in this world because that would be something.

I loved the characters and the people. I adored how this book is meant for teens but it's not sugarcoated in anyway. Some might call it controversial because of a few aspects but I love that it's part of the world and that Ms. Marr isn't afraid to go there.

Definitely will be watching for more in this series. My only complaint is the ending. I hate leave-offs. ( )
  mojo09226 | Nov 21, 2014 |
Great first book in the series. I love the idea of the fight between witches and daemons, and the fight to survive as a daemon or witch. The main chatacters are great and I am eager to continue to follow their journey. ( )
  mnm123 | Nov 20, 2014 |
Mallory and her father Adam have been running from something for years. She knows he’s a witch, and stole something from the daimons, but Adam has kept everything a mystery. She’s been raised to learn of the evils of daimons, and has spent her life learning how to kill them.

Read the rest of my review at: http://shouldireaditornot.wordpress.com/2012/09/01/carnival-of-souls-melissa-mar... ( )
  ShouldIReadIt | Sep 26, 2014 |
Carnival of Souls has a great sound bite and intriguing cover. Who wouldn't want to read about a daimon world where blood and sex and violence determine your caste and lot in life? Who doesn't want to read about dark love and even darker secrets that you have to keep from your most beloved?

See, I totally would, except I had a lot of issues with this book. Many characters were weak, each character revealed their main motivation too easily, the world was basically a bare-bones world, the transition from scenes of the city to the witches' world was not smooth at all, etc.

The only character of note was Aya, with minor appreciations for scenes with Kaleb without Mallory. I pretty much skipped every scene with Mallory because it was the most cliche depiction of a female in a paranormal romance novel. I couldn't bear it to the point I seriously considered dropping the book, but luckily it didn't focus on her too heavily. She gets all the pretense of being considered a strong female character because she is physically adept with guns and hand fighting despite her "human" weakness. But honestly.... Is she that interesting of a character besides her parentage? The answer is NO. All she does is be a good daughter and fall in love with someone. And that falling in love is a very very stupid insta-love with freaking "magic" to make it legit. But that does not make it legit in my book at all. Just stupider. If you have to rely on magic to create attraction, then you haven't developed the characters enough to interact with love.

Okay here is where it gets interesting. Y'know the last sentence I just wrote? Strangely enough it is only true for MalLory and not Kaleb. It's because Kaleb was given scenes that developed him as a character with the freaking annoying burden of instalove over his character self. He fought, he interacted with Zevi and tried to protect, he schemed and showed the reader his dilemma of being a cur, forfeiting and dying. He was skeptical of good intentions from Aya but had to deal with it. Even his decision to marry Mallory was an insight into this character. We were able to see something more from Kaleb than just dumb love. But from Mallory, all we get is a girl in love. Whoop de doo. What a waste of pages.

Aya was also by far the most interesting character from the get go because she had a greater, more desperate secret she had to kept quiet. Even from the readers. Every move she did was based on that secret motivation. But the readers did not know, but could only guess as she stabbed her ex fiancé with a poisoned knife. That is what real characters should do. Have hidden motivations, change the world in some sort of way. Mallory made zero impact in the book. Aya, in chapter one, had already flipped the entire daimon world into recognizing upper caste women in battle. She concocts plans and executes them rather than just sitting around. Even her "romance" with Belias is interesting because it is a power play of some sorts. A question of true love or not.
However, when her secret was revealed, it seems like she is a little overpowered... Future books will tell.

I am not enthrall with the two world. Nothing is written to detail and everything seems to be compared to our world. I've noted many times where daimons were critical of their own world. But they know of basically no other world, so how would they know? It was jarring to see such sentiments because it felt like a human's perspective of the world rather than a daimon's. The lack of detail was frustrating. Caste system, a carnival of souls, red and black masks, curs, teeth and your true form. All of it was more like a necessity of plot rather than a revelation of the world. What do we know of the caste system besides Aya is the upper and curs are at the bottom? What do we know of red and black masks besides potential people who were them? The carnival of souls, what does it contain besides the battle for leadership? Does transforming hurt or feel good? Are there merchants in the caste level? Can a cur ever rise above the bottom caste system?
There is nothing in this book. It is a bare bones world that hints of blood and decadence but never delivers.

So. Subpar characters. A bare world. A mildly interesting plot.
1.5 stars reluctantly rounded up.
Not recommended unless you have a tolerance for the flaws I mentioned. I am pretty disappointed in Marr. I am not sure if I just read her older books so long ago that I wasn't as picky or cynical about these types of books, but I probably won't pick up the sequel. The cliffhanger doesn't interest me at all. ( )
  NineLarks | Sep 15, 2014 |
Carnival of Souls has a great sound bite and intriguing cover. Who wouldn't want to read about a daimon world where blood and sex and violence determine your caste and lot in life? Who doesn't want to read about dark love and even darker secrets that you have to keep from your most beloved?

See, I totally would, except I had a lot of issues with this book. Many characters were weak, each character revealed their main motivation too easily, the world was basically a bare-bones world, the transition from scenes of the city to the witches' world was not smooth at all, etc.

The only character of note was Aya, with minor appreciations for scenes with Kaleb without Mallory. I pretty much skipped every scene with Mallory because it was the most cliche depiction of a female in a paranormal romance novel. I couldn't bear it to the point I seriously considered dropping the book, but luckily it didn't focus on her too heavily. She gets all the pretense of being considered a strong female character because she is physically adept with guns and hand fighting despite her "human" weakness. But honestly.... Is she that interesting of a character besides her parentage? The answer is NO. All she does is be a good daughter and fall in love with someone. And that falling in love is a very very stupid insta-love with freaking "magic" to make it legit. But that does not make it legit in my book at all. Just stupider. If you have to rely on magic to create attraction, then you haven't developed the characters enough to interact with love.

Okay here is where it gets interesting. Y'know the last sentence I just wrote? Strangely enough it is only true for MalLory and not Kaleb. It's because Kaleb was given scenes that developed him as a character with the freaking annoying burden of instalove over his character self. He fought, he interacted with Zevi and tried to protect, he schemed and showed the reader his dilemma of being a cur, forfeiting and dying. He was skeptical of good intentions from Aya but had to deal with it. Even his decision to marry Mallory was an insight into this character. We were able to see something more from Kaleb than just dumb love. But from Mallory, all we get is a girl in love. Whoop de doo. What a waste of pages.

Aya was also by far the most interesting character from the get go because she had a greater, more desperate secret she had to kept quiet. Even from the readers. Every move she did was based on that secret motivation. But the readers did not know, but could only guess as she stabbed her ex fiancé with a poisoned knife. That is what real characters should do. Have hidden motivations, change the world in some sort of way. Mallory made zero impact in the book. Aya, in chapter one, had already flipped the entire daimon world into recognizing upper caste women in battle. She concocts plans and executes them rather than just sitting around. Even her "romance" with Belias is interesting because it is a power play of some sorts. A question of true love or not.
However, when her secret was revealed, it seems like she is a little overpowered... Future books will tell.

I am not enthrall with the two world. Nothing is written to detail and everything seems to be compared to our world. I've noted many times where daimons were critical of their own world. But they know of basically no other world, so how would they know? It was jarring to see such sentiments because it felt like a human's perspective of the world rather than a daimon's. The lack of detail was frustrating. Caste system, a carnival of souls, red and black masks, curs, teeth and your true form. All of it was more like a necessity of plot rather than a revelation of the world. What do we know of the caste system besides Aya is the upper and curs are at the bottom? What do we know of red and black masks besides potential people who were them? The carnival of souls, what does it contain besides the battle for leadership? Does transforming hurt or feel good? Are there merchants in the caste level? Can a cur ever rise above the bottom caste system?
There is nothing in this book. It is a bare bones world that hints of blood and decadence but never delivers.

So. Subpar characters. A bare world. A mildly interesting plot.
1.5 stars reluctantly rounded up.
Not recommended unless you have a tolerance for the flaws I mentioned. I am pretty disappointed in Marr. I am not sure if I just read her older books so long ago that I wasn't as picky or cynical about these types of books, but I probably won't pick up the sequel. The cliffhanger doesn't interest me at all. ( )
  NineLarks | Sep 15, 2014 |
Showing 1-5 of 39 (next | show all)
no reviews | add a review
You must log in to edit Common Knowledge data.
For more help see the Common Knowledge help page.
Series (with order)
Canonical title
Original title
Alternative titles
Original publication date
People/Characters
Important places
Important events
Related movies
Awards and honors
Epigraph
Dedication
First words
Quotations
Last words
Disambiguation notice
Publisher's editors
Blurbers
Publisher series
Original language

References to this work on external resources.

Wikipedia in English

None

Book description
Haiku summary

No descriptions found.

"A centuries-long war between daimons and witches sets the stage for three teens caught up in a deadly struggle for power and autonomy in the exotic and otherworldly Carnival of Souls, the mercantile center of the daimon dimension"--Provided by publisher.… (more)

(summary from another edition)

» see all 2 descriptions

LibraryThing Author

Melissa Marr is a LibraryThing Author, an author who lists their personal library on LibraryThing.

profile page | author page

Quick Links

Swap Ebooks Audio
1 avail.
88 wanted
2 pay

Popular covers

Rating

Average: (3.67)
0.5
1
1.5
2 11
2.5
3 17
3.5 5
4 22
4.5 4
5 15

 

Help/FAQs | About | Privacy/Terms | Blog | Contact | LibraryThing.com | APIs | WikiThing | Common Knowledge | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | 94,359,004 books! | Top bar: Always visible