When it comes to her earlier works, this one has to be my favorite so far. No rape scene, no undignified hero here folks, just strong characters who're unpredictable as the weather. I read this because I was curious about Derek Craven, I've read in Lisa Kleypas's website that he's her favorite hero. He's a minor character here but his character and history were briefly mentioned.

Lily reminded me of Lillian (It Happened One Autumn) because of her dark hair and wild spirit, but I loved Lily's character because of her strength, her independence, and the way she carried her self. It was really difficult to break her self-constructed barriers but Alex was able to do it. They were a perfect match for each other.

The story was rich in romance, development, lines and actions that were really touching. There was a lot of turmoil in Lily's life and together with Alex, they were able to free themselves from the past that hardened their hearts. This is one of the few books where the hero first utters the three significant words.

I also like the angle of Lily's friendship with Derek and his feelings toward her. They were alike in some ways, both being cynical, trusting no one, but really transparent when faced with a weakness. In Lily's case, it's her daughter. In Derek's case, it's Lily. It was confusing how he treated her, he's not really the comforting type but he had a way of showing friendship. Even though Derek is "flash-gentry", he's still noble and treated Lily with respect, like putting her in a pedestal, knowing she doesn't deserve someone like him.

This book had a solid plot, a little humor, entertaining secondary characters, passionate love scenes, and a happy ending. I can't wait to read Derek's story! ( )

Two likable protagonists, and probably the best version of 'all the men love and totally accept that pretty girl who does manly things like gambling and hunting' that I've seen. By 'best', of course, I mean that it didn't make me want to stab someone in the face. I didn't totally buy it, but close enough. ( )

Really loved this story - worthwhile read!

http://ktleyed.blogspot.com/2009/04/t... ( )

Books like this are why Lisa Kleypas is my five star historical romance writer. The plot is suspenseful and the characters are complicated. As are all of us. Lily Lawson is a particularly compelling heroine, a mixture of strength and insecurity. One of Kleypas's older works; it may be her best series to date. ( )