

|
Loading... The Great Unexpectedby Sharon Creech
None. Loved the characters. Loved the settings. Loved the mild suspense. Love Sharon Creech's way with words. ( )I love Sharon Creech's ability to create quirky characters but this cast was a little over the top and distracted me from the story itself. Pleasant reading, but far from her best. Really great. Such a strong beginning, love the strong voice right from the moment the dead boy falls from the tree. This book has friendship, boys coming between sisters, mysterious characters, crows (or rooks?), Ireland and America, dogs, traumatic pasts, orphans, small towns... all unfortunately jumbled together into a mess. I enjoyed Naomi and Lizzie well enough (although Lizzie read like Anne of Green Gables on speed and I kind of wanted to muzzle her most of the time... I have no soul). But I could not have cared less about the interspersed chapters with the elderly ladies in Ireland, and the corresponding elderly folks in America. They were supposed to be mysterious, but I just found them confusing and trying, and I suspect many of my kids will, too. Instead of lending a sense of wonder, all the unexplained bits and too-convenient connections between characters just made me feel like the book hadn't been thought through well enough. Two orphaned girls in a small town called Blackbird Tree meet a boy who falls out of a tree. Strange and unexpected things begin to happen, and lives both near and far intermingle in surprising ways. What appears to be sinister is really very sweet, and a girl who appears to have no one finds family in unimagined ways. I enjoyed the gentle humor and the theme of belonging, but I found the story disjointed and confusing, and I really wonder what children will think of it. I think this may be one of those books for kids that is really for adults. Creech, S. (2012). The great unexpected. New York: Joanna Cotler Books/HarperCollins.
This is "...an enchanting page-turner filled with secrets, humor, decisions, "coincidences," and deeper meanings."
References to this work on external resources.
|
Google Books — Loading...
RatingAverage: (3.64)
Is this you?Become a LibraryThing Author. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||