Elmer Kelton's style of writing closely emulates that of Louis L'Amour but instead of romanticizing the west, Kelton infuses his stories with the solidity of real places and historical characters.

This story, however, differs significantly from previous books by the same author which I have read. The historical figure in question, Judge Parker, stays largely in the background. Instead, the story focuses on Justin Moffit, a young man who feels he has a personal debt to discharge to society. In many ways, it's a coming-of-age story as Justin learns the value of oaths and friendships and that the law in order to be effective must truly be blind with regard to those relationships between the lawman and those who break the law.

The book's ending leaves the reader unsatisfied, however, with a feeling that nothing has been resolved. A lot of questions are left unanswered and the manner in which Justin deals with the final situation seems out of character for him. ( )