This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.
Hide this

Results from Google Books

Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.

Duel with the Devil: The True Story of How…

Duel with the Devil: The True Story of How Alexander Hamilton and Aaron… (2013)

by Paul Collins

MembersReviewsPopularityAverage ratingMentions
3412648,387 (3.57)23



Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book.

No current Talk conversations about this book.

» See also 23 mentions

Showing 1-5 of 27 (next | show all)
I enjoyed *Duel with the Devil*, Paul Collins' account of how Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr teamed up to prevent an innocent Levi Weeks from being convicted of the murder of Elma Sands in 1799. I appreciated the easy history lessons necessarily integrated into the story, though I should have liked to have learnt more about the process Hamilton and Burr used to discover the exculpatory evidence that led to Weeks' acquittal and to have been privy to how the great rivals divided up the courtroom responsibilities. The book's style was generally fluid, though occasionally stilted, and the structure sometimes a little choppy, but I recommend *Duel* for its unfolding mystery and for Collins' dedication to respecting the historical evidence available to him. ( )
1 vote wardemote | Aug 22, 2015 |
This review was written for LibraryThing Early Reviewers.
Historical true crime is one of my favorite genres and when you have Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr teaming up for the defense, it seems like it should be a perfect set-up. This book is pretty good though I never got a great feel for the primary characters -- the victim and the accused. It does better in providing portraits of Burr and Hamilton, who were already legal and political antagonists even if they would team up on a case if paid to do so. The book is best at providing a portrait of turn of the (19th) century New York, when the commercial city was still the nation's capital and the country was mourning its first president. Recommended for those who are into that time period, or are already into historical true crime. ( )
1 vote keywestnan | Jun 9, 2015 |
Hamilton and Burr. Sounds like a law firm you might see advertised on television. And they were lawyers. But that's not what really ties these two men together. They are Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr. For history buffs, the names may bring to mind the ongoing political battles in the 1790s between Hamilton, the nation's first Secretary of the Treasury, and Burr, a U.S. Senator who defeated Hamilton's father-in-law to gain the seat. Most Americans, though, remember the two from an event more commonly mentioned in American history classes -- in 1804 Burr, then vice president of the U.S., killed Hamilton in a duel over derogatory comments Hamilton supposedly made.

Their enmity is one of the hooks for Duel with the Devil, an account of what was 18th Century New York City's "Trial of the Century." Paul Collins draws on numerous resources, including the trial transcript, in describing how two such foes both end up defending Levi Weeks, a young carpenter, in his trial for murdering Elma Sands, a young woman who lived in the same boarding house.

Although it is the pivot, the trial doesn't actually begin until more than halfway through the book. In fact, the oddity of Burr and Hamilton being allied is, like the trial, a vehicle to explore the social and political landscape of New York City as the 18th Century drew to a close. Largest in the country with a population of 60,000, it's a city where the streets are muddy, two miles of meadows and pastures separate it from Greenwich Village and getting potable water is a central concern. In fact, a project to install underground wooden pipes to bring in water is equally crucial. That project was the Manhattan Company's, whose founding directors included Burr and Henry Brockholst Livingston, who would be on the U.S. Supreme Court less than seven years later. And the prelude to and trial itself give insight to the public attitudes and criminal justice system of the day.

When 22-year-old Gulielma "Elma" Sands' body is found in a well outside the city on January 2, 1800, (in what is now SoHo in Lower Manhattan), suspicion immediately turns to Levi Weeks. Weeks, 24, lived in the boarding house owned and run by Elma's cousin and reportedly was the last to be seen with her when she disappeared on December 22. Rumors were they were sneaking off to be secretly married. Between his arrest and trial at the end of March, virtually the entire city is convinced of his guilt. In fact, the day trial begins at City Hall, the building is swarmed by what one observer reported to be the largest crowd in the city's history. And when it starts, Weeks is represented by Burr, Hamilton and Livingston. How does a common carpenter end up with such a high powered defense team? His brother, Ezra, is one of the city's biggest contractors and not only does his wealth help, but both Burr and Hamilton are reportedly deeply in debt to him for various construction work.

Duel With The Devil unfolds slowly and even has a whodunit feel through the end of trial. The modern reader sees not only an early New York City but how legal procedures have changed over the years. While a judge was the chief presiding officer, he was joined by the city's mayor and recorder. Jurors had to be men and possess $250 worth of property, about what a common laborer would earn in a year. Even murder trials usually took less than a day so, as a rule, they proceeded until complete. Here, though, the first day's testimony went until 1:30 the next morning, with the jurors sleeping on the floor of a second story room in which they were sequestered. The second day went until 2:30 a.m. Seventy-five witnesses testified. The prosecution's case was circumstantial; the defense decimated what we would today call the prosecution's forensic evidence and suggested she committed suicide. Once the jury retired to deliberate at about 3 a.m., the not guilty verdict took minutes, perhaps aided by the fact the judge instructed the jury that he, the mayor and the recorder all believed the evidence was insufficient to convict Levi.

Levi didn't testify during trial. That was a matter of custom in capital cases, where defendants were viewed as having a hopeless bias against conviction, creating a "disqualification of interest." As Collins observes, though, that seems to have been about the only conflict of interest that was recognized. Not only did the city recorder sit on the board of the Manhattan Company at the time of trial, the company "owned the murder scene, had employed the defendant, had rejected a bid by a relative of the deceased, and had financial relationships with the court recorder and the clerk [of courts.]"

New York City was so fascinated with the trial that within hours of the verdict a 16-page pamphlet about it was being snapped up. Another, more complete pamphlet appeared two days after that and within two weeks the clerk of courts published the full transcript, the first such in the new nation. Collins incorporates that testimony in portraying the evidence and machinations at trial. His detail tends to be better focused than in earlier chapters, where there are occaionsal diversions into matters that don't seem quite germane to the story or the portrayal of New York City in 1800. That said, the straightforward, almost journalistic approach, makes this a satisfying look into a unique coalescence of events and personalities.

Collins doesn't abandon the participants once the trial is over. While it didn't establish who killed Elma, Duel With The Devil does. Livingston, Hamilton and Burr would go on to joust in the courtroom and, for the latter two, in politics. Hamilton would meet his fate along the Hudson River in New Jersey. The duel would bring Burr's political career to an end and he would stand trial for (and be acquitted of) treason in 1807, less than nine months after Livingston reached the Supreme Court. As for Levi Weeks? He would leave New York City several years later and go on to become a successful architect in Natchez, Miss., perhaps thankful he never achieved the fame (or infamy) of his legal "dream team."

(Originally posted at A Progressive on the Prairie.)
1 vote PrairieProgressive | Aug 16, 2014 |
This is such a well researched book on New York in 1800. It is filled with great detail including newspaper articles from the time. The author really did some digging around to get this information and he lays out a good case for who the real killer was. Duel with the Devil was a great find and I one I will keep on my shelf for others to read. ( )
  WongXu | Mar 26, 2014 |
This review was written for LibraryThing Early Reviewers.
A wonderful read! When hearing of Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr, I naturally think first about their place in early American History. And their bitter rivalry. But this book tells a bit of a different story, the story of their teaming up for the defense, in the trial of Levi Weeks, a young carpenter who was accused of murdering Elma Sands, a young Quaker woman and boarding house owner in late eighteenth century Manhattan.

The book is written in an easy to read style, and held my attention throughout. If you enjoy a good mystery, and a true story from early America, put this book on your reading list. ( )
  Berkshires | Jan 19, 2014 |
Showing 1-5 of 27 (next | show all)
no reviews | add a review
You must log in to edit Common Knowledge data.
For more help see the Common Knowledge help page.
Series (with order)
Canonical title
Original title
Alternative titles
Original publication date
Important places
Important events
Related movies
Awards and honors
To my brother Peter, whose room was my first library
First words
(Prologue) Andrew Blanck had just been sitting down to lunch with a horsebreaker when Elias Ring and Joseph Watkins showed up and battered on his door.
It was a fine day for wonders.
Last words
(Click to show. Warning: May contain spoilers.)
Disambiguation notice
Publisher's editors
Publisher series
Original language
Canonical DDC/MDS

References to this work on external resources.

Wikipedia in English (1)

Book description
Haiku summary

Amazon.com Product Description (ISBN 0307956458, Hardcover)

Duel with the Devil is acclaimed historian Paul Collins’ remarkable true account of a  stunning turn-of-the-19th century murder and the trial that ensued – a showdown in which iconic political rivals Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr joined forces to make sure justice was done. Still our nation’s longest running “cold case,” the mystery of Elma Sands finally comes to a close with this book, which delivers the first substantial break in the case in over 200 years.
            In the closing days of 1799, the United States was still a young republic.  Waging a fierce battle for its uncertain future were two political parties: the well-moneyed Federalists, led by Alexander Hamilton, and the populist Republicans, led by Aaron Burr. The two finest lawyers in New York, Burr and Hamilton were bitter rivals both in and out of the courtroom, and as the next election approached—with Manhattan likely to be the swing district on which the presidency would hinge—their  animosity reached a crescendo. Central to their dispute was the Manhattan water supply, which Burr saw not just as an opportunity to help a city devastated by epidemics but as a chance to heal his battered finances.
             But everything changed when Elma Sands, a beautiful young Quaker woman, was found dead in Burr's newly constructed Manhattan Well. The horrific crime quickly gripped the nation, and before long accusations settled on one of Elma’s suitors, handsome young carpenter Levi Weeks. As the enraged city demanded a noose be draped around the accused murderer’s neck, the only question seemed to be whether Levi would make it to trial or be lynched first.
             The young man’s only hope was to hire a legal dream team.  And thus it was that New York’s most bitter political rivals and greatest attorneys did the unthinkable—they teamed up.
            At once an absorbing legal thriller and an expertly crafted portrait of the United States in the time of the Founding Fathers, Duel with the Devil is a masterpiece of narrative nonfiction.

(retrieved from Amazon Thu, 12 Mar 2015 18:25:18 -0400)

Acclaimed historian Paul Collins' remarkable true account of a stunning turn-of-the-19th century murder and the trial that ensued -- a showdown in which iconic political rivals Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr joined forces to make sure justice was done.… (more)

» see all 2 descriptions

LibraryThing Early Reviewers Alum

Paul Collins's book Duel with the Devil was available from LibraryThing Early Reviewers.

Sign up to get a pre-publication copy in exchange for a review.

Quick Links

Popular covers


Average: (3.57)
1 3
2 4
2.5 1
3 13
3.5 12
4 28
4.5 1
5 7

Is this you?

Become a LibraryThing Author.


About | Contact | Privacy/Terms | Help/FAQs | Blog | Store | APIs | TinyCat | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | Common Knowledge | 134,795,883 books! | Top bar: Always visible