Happy Holidays! The 12 Days of LT scavenger hunt is going on. Can you solve the clues?
This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.
Hide this

Results from Google Books

Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.

Human Traces (Vintage International) by…

Human Traces (Vintage International) (original 2005; edition 2008)

by Sebastian Faulks

MembersReviewsPopularityAverage ratingMentions
1,0933011,159 (3.32)33
Title:Human Traces (Vintage International)
Authors:Sebastian Faulks
Info:Vintage (2008), Edition: Reprint, Paperback, 672 pages
Collections:Your library

Work details

Human Traces by Sebastian Faulks (2005)

  1. 00
    The Magic Mountain by Thomas Mann (hilge)
    hilge: Philosophy, psychology, and sanatorium are key features in both books. Which are both really nice and long in the very best sense.

Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book.

No current Talk conversations about this book.

» See also 33 mentions

English (29)  Italian (1)  All languages (30)
Showing 1-5 of 29 (next | show all)
Only three out of five. A strange kind of novel, with Faulks' usual strong characterisations and settings intermixed with long and often tedious dissertations about the period's efforts to get to grips with mental illnesses. Many times I came close to giving up and at the end still wonder whether I should have invested my limited (therefore precious) reading time. ( )
  NaggedMan | Sep 23, 2017 |
Two young men one English the other French meet and set off together to find cures for mental disease in late XIX Century Europe. Along the way one spends some time in a grim Asylum in England the other attends lectures by Charcot as people begin to see how our characters are related to our brains. But the centre around which the novel turns is really Sonia, who tolerates her first loveless marriage hardly expecting anything better, then marries one of the brothers, and finds love with him and their doomed child Daniel.
There is lots of enjoyable circumstantial detail and perhaps a few blind alleys are explored. Including a rather unlikely escapade up a cable car.
Things don't end happily as the boys do not bring home a cure (which still eludes us).
The novel movingly displays the tragedy of mental illness, especially Schizophrenia.
Sonia however has given and received love, with several of the characters; is there anything more we can expect from life? ( )
  oataker | Sep 7, 2017 |
Started promisingly, but just became a research paper towards the end. ( )
  Soulmuser | May 30, 2017 |
Two men, one French, one English, at the start of the discovery of psychoanalysis, psychiatry and mental health. Their two wives, their children, their journey across Europe, from the start of humanity to the cusp of modernity. Faulks writes about such interesting themes; he has an interested mind that is capable of collecting and digesting enormous amounts of detail and recycling it as fiction; of shocking us with the basic and the crude and delighting us with the seashore and the revelatory. I just wish that I found his writing style a touch more compelling. The sheer amount of effort, of artifice, of planning, of execution that has gone into this monolith of a book really needs to be leavened by some more lightness of touch, some personality, some more writing that would make the pages sing rahter than plod.
  otterley | May 22, 2016 |
This very satisfying novel chronicles the life-long relationship of Jacques Rebiére and Thomas Midwinter, two men in the early vanguard of psychiatry and psychology in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Rebiére and Thomas Midwinter met as boys when Thomas vacationed in Breton near where Jacques lived. Both were intellectually curious and scientifically minded. Jacques’s interest in the human mind was triggered by his older brother, Olivier, who as a young adult was committed to an asylum following a psychotic breakdown. Thomas was drawn to literature, particularly Shakespeare, as a means to examine the human condition. Thomas’s sister Sonia will play a large role in the story as explained later.

The boys developed a deep bond from their shared interest in science. They vowed they would someday partner in a practice of medicine focusing on mental illness. Sonia in an arranged marriage with Richard Prendergast experienced an unhappy life with the vain and failed Richard. They divorced under a deal with Sonia’s father in which he essentially pays Richard to set her free from the marriage.

As they grew into adulthood Jacques and Thomas completed their studies in London and Paris. Thomas took a job as a junior doctor in a large asylum where his dream to help the profoundly ill patients was soon dashed by the dearth of anything that medicine could offer the inmates. Thomas realized the only course of any worth was kind sympathy to their suffering. Jacques studies in Paris where he is particularly interested in the neurological causes of mental disorders, a focus then in vogue.

Jacques visited Thomas at the Midwinter’s country home. Jacques and Sonia fall immediately in love and, when he has finished his studies, they marry. The couple and Thomas move to Paris where the men opened a fledgling practice, treating mostly well-to-do neurotic patients.

Their dream of a clinic is realized when they find a schloss in Austria that they open as a clinic where they treat mostly patients with mild disorders. They devote a portion of their practice to the chronically and severely mentally ill and they bring Olivier from the asylum in France to their hospital.

An attractive young Viennese woman experiencing various symptoms arrives at the clinic. Jacques examines Katharina and concludes that her physical symptoms are manifestations of repressed traumatic memories. Jacques had become enamored with the emerging field of psychoanalysis. Despite her denial of past life traumatic events he determines to treat her using psychoanalytic therapies. He shares her case history with Thomas who is shocked by the descriptions of her symptoms and rushes her to the local hospital where she undergoes emergency surgery for large ovarian cysts. He writes a scathing rebuttal to Jacques’s mistaken conclusions, but does not give it to him. Jacques is aware that he has misdiagnosed Katharina and this creates tension between he and Thomas that will ripen over the ensuring years. The differences of views they hold on the value of psychoanalysis clouds their friendship.

Katharina and Thomas fall in love and marry. Despite the misdiagnosis that nearly cost her her life she remains gracious to Jacques and forms a deep bond with Sonia. Sonia gave birth to Daniel after several miscarriages and Katharina to twin girls.

The lease on the schloss is set to expire and they locate an estate high on a mountain. Jacques takes a sabbatical to visit California where he tours a sanitarium and spa located above Pasadena accessed by a cable-cog railway tram, a means of conveyance ideal for their new clinic. While in California he met Roya, a mysterious Russian beauty of noble descent. (Thomas had met Roya years earlier while traveling as a personal physician to a wealthy patron.)

Returning to Austria the partners commence work on their lofty hospital. Thomas futilely treats Olivier whose insanity is intractable. While at the construction site Olivier responding to voices throws himself to his death from a precipice. Olivier’s condition has sparked an idea that Thomas will explore further – that the psychotic mind is a product of the evolution of the human mind closely related to the creativity and imagination inherent in human thinking. Darwin’s theory of evolution, now about thirty-years old has captivated Thomas.

From a chance encounter with an amateur paleontologist Thomas takes a sabbatical to safari in Africa in search of primal human fossils. It is there that Thomas concludes that the evolution of man is the key to understanding modern human intellect. Leaving the main party to return to Europe Thomas has a near death experience when his party becomes lost.

Back in Austria the clinic is a success. While at a society event, Jacques encounters Roya who has settled in the area with a rich husband (a little too much coincidence here). He is deeply attracted to her and they begin an affair, although he remained loyal to Sonia.

Thomas unlike Jacque had not published a professional paper. Drawing on this ruminations about the origins of schizophrenia (as it has become called) as the result of natural selection gone slightly awry he prepares a treatise on his conclusions. He noted that despite being massively dysfunctional the malady continues to persist in humans; it did not die out as non-sustaining traits would usually do. As the condition is distributed evenly across the world its genesis must have occurred before the human diaspora many millennial ago. Thomas gave a lengthy talk on his conception during which he explicitly critiqued the psychoanalytic school gaining adherents at the time. His speech was not well-received, particularly by Jacques who viewed it as a slap at him. Their rift opened further and deeper.

Thomas and Jacques ultimately decide to dissolve their partnership. Jacques’s and Sonia’s son Daniel has grown to manhood and enlists in the war where he is killed in Italy. Jacques grieves deeply and in desperation visits a medium whose cruel phoniness in summoning spirits shames and insults him. Thomas starts a practice in London, but begins to experience the onset of the disease now known as Alzheimer’s dementia. The two men emotionally wish each other good bye.

Faulk’s work is well-constructed and quite riveting. I thought the periodic reappearance of Roya was a bit contrived and unnecessary to the plot. What was most impressive was how Faulks described the emerging trends in psychiatry while avoiding anachronisms of advances that occurred after the period. The shifting bonds of friendship between the men and their families were a major theme of the novel.

I found the particularly interesting the description of the asylum where Thomas worked as a young doctor. I started my professional career in the mid-1970’s as an administrator in such an asylum in upstate New York. This was near the end of the era of large psychiatric institutions. The main building on the sprawling grounds was built in 1840. On the ground floor as you entered you first encountered the so-called “show wards”. These had the ambience of a graceful, sedate old person’s home. But further on, seldom visited by anyone, were the “back wards” where the most chronic affected and deeply disabled were housed. Although the introduction of psychotropic drugs two decades earlier had drastically reduced the population of severely mentally ill persons by this time, the residual patients with the most intractable illness remained. I recall the notion of providing a “therapeutic milieu” in the hospital, which, as in Thomas’s time, involved treating people with kindness and decency. Active treatment was limited to large doses of medication that had little effect other than to tranquilize. I directed a project called “humanization” (what a terrible term!) that involvement providing privacy and a bit less sterile environment for the residents.

That era is over. By the late 1990’s the hospital of 2,800 individuals was closed, along with a neighboring facility of over 3,000. One would like to think that this was the result of miraculous advances in treatment efficacious, but the record here is certainly not stellar. ( )
  stevesmits | Mar 3, 2016 |
Showing 1-5 of 29 (next | show all)
no reviews | add a review
You must log in to edit Common Knowledge data.
For more help see the Common Knowledge help page.
Series (with order)
Canonical title
Original title
Alternative titles
Original publication date
Important places
Important events
Related movies
Awards and honors
First words
Last words
Disambiguation notice
Publisher's editors
Publisher series
Original language
Canonical DDC/MDS

References to this work on external resources.

Wikipedia in English (2)

Book description
Haiku summary

Amazon.com Product Description (ISBN 0099458268, Paperback)

What is it to be human? This question, as in Birdsong, is at the heart of Human Traces.

The story begins in Brittany where a young, poor boy somehow passes his medical exams and goes to Paris, where he attends the lectures of Charcot, the Parisian neurologist who set the world on its head in the 1870s. With a friend, he sets up a clinic in the mysterious mountain district of Carinthia in south-east Austria.

If The Girl at the Lion d’Or was a simple three-movement symphony, Birdsong an opera, Charlotte Gray a complex four-movement symphony and On Green Dolphin Street a concerto, then Human Traces is a Wagnerian grand opera.

From the Hardcover edition.

(retrieved from Amazon Thu, 12 Mar 2015 18:13:42 -0400)

(see all 4 descriptions)

Sharing its central theme of what it means to be human with 'Birdsong', this is the story of a young man who, after attending medical school, decides to set up a clinic in the mysterious Carinthian mountains in south-east Austria.

(summary from another edition)

» see all 7 descriptions

Quick Links

Popular covers


Average: (3.32)
0.5 1
1 13
1.5 1
2 19
2.5 5
3 61
3.5 16
4 48
4.5 6
5 24

Is this you?

Become a LibraryThing Author.


About | Contact | Privacy/Terms | Help/FAQs | Blog | Store | APIs | TinyCat | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | Common Knowledge | 130,847,698 books! | Top bar: Always visible