This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.
Hide this

Results from Google Books

Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.

Watson and Holmes: A Study In Black by Karl…

Watson and Holmes: A Study In Black (2013)

by Karl Bollers, Rick Leonardi (Illustrator)

Other authors: Paul Mendoza (Creator), Brandon Perlow (Creator), Larry Stroman (Illustrator)

Series: Watson and Holmes (1)

MembersReviewsPopularityAverage ratingMentions
483362,743 (3.93)3



Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book.

No current Talk conversations about this book.

» See also 3 mentions

Showing 3 of 3
The buzz was right -- this is a really good book. The first ingredient in a good Holmes story is a mesmerizing Holmes, and we've got it. He's a good detective, almost otherworldly but then when he explains his reasoning, it's obvious! His reveal scenes are much better than most of the TV and cinematic versions I've seen recently. His Watson is a big guy, a modern medical intern and war veteran, and as the title indicates he's just as important as Holmes. As usual, much of the character development surrounds the question of why these two guys feel the need to investigate crime together, but there are no answers, at least not yet.

I was concerned about the quality at first. Watson is referred to as both "Jon" and "John," for instance. However, that's pretty common in mainstream comics, let alone small-press books, so I'll overlook it since the rest of the book is great. In my opinion, with all the other Holmes versions out there, the black Harlem setting is worth doing and brings something new to the table, but it's not just a gimmick. It's well-thought and a good book in its own right. ( )
  FFortuna | Jan 22, 2015 |
[Source: Personal Copy] This review also appears on www.words.blank-stare.com

Anyone who knows me remotely knows I adore Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s famous Sherlock Holmes. I grew up seeing two thick volumes of “The Complete Sherlock Holmes” on the bookshelf and always knew he was a brilliant detective. It wasn’t until a few years ago, when I endeavored to read Doyle’s works, that I understood the hype. Sherlock Holmes is my spirit animal, if spirit animals could be literary characters from the 19th century. When I discovered New Paradigm Studios had jumped into the arena with a modern, urban re-imagining of the famous detective duo, in graphic novel format no less, I had to check it out.

Image-based reading isn’t my primary area of expertise; I read the newspaper comics as a teen, but with the exception of one, I never latched on to any comic strip with passion. Frankly, I wasn’t at all sure what to expect with Watson and Holmes and worried that it wouldn’t hold my interest due to a lack of depth to the story. Admittedly, I prefer novels to any other form of literature, but I was willing to give a graphic novel a try. I was NOT disappointed. It’s a bit of a leap to go from the wordy Doyle stories to a format that relies as much on the imagery as the dialogue to bring the story to life. I also had to adjust to the serial nature of this tradebook. Each chapter’s cliffhanger made the reading experience much different than sitting with a straightforward short story or book. With Watson and Holmes, however, both parts work together amazingly to create a cohesive story across the chapters.

The graphics were deserving of their own attention (obviously?). They were dynamic and conveyed a great amount of detail and nuances between the characters. Regarding colors, I found them to be appropriate for each scene. Some scenes were more monochromatic and somber, while others were vibrant. I would have liked to see more of the black and white images, though. There are a few included in the back to let you know which artists were a part of which chapters, but I’m curious to see how the full chapters, either in whole or in part, would change without the colors. There are noir editions available, so I’ll likely get those in addition (maybe a future printing could include all of them).

I loved the portrayal of Watson and Holmes in modern-day Harlem. Early 20th century England is cool, but the modern take is fascinating as the story incorporates technology into how crimes are carried out. As a reader, you get to see the workings of Holmes mind play out in a world filled with cell phones, emails and hackers. I found the deductive reasoning he used entertaining as he and Watson (bobbed and) weaved their way through the plot. Moreover, the personalities of the Watson and Holmes we’ve come to know are translated into such a gritty environment seamlessly. You really get to see them in their own elements, which helps to make this interpretation easier to believe. The writers were able to stay true to the core of each character, but it’s definitely not just an update.

One piece that I did not expect was the depth to Watson’s back-story. It’s definitely a departure from most other versions I’ve seen. Giving him a troubled family life lends realism to his characterization and makes his motives much easier to understand. It also fits the story of how he and Holmes find themselves as unlikely roommates. Holmes, on the other hand, is harder to pin down — but what’s new? He’s still idiosyncratic and pensive, but always engaging. His dialogue is modernized appropriately, but his well-known quips are still there, blending in perfectly.

The story itself is substantial. It’s similar to previous stories but is a full departure from them as well. There are requisite plot twists that threw the entire path of logic to the wind, but the writing was solid, so seeing it woven together was classic. A plus of the graphic novel format is that details the reader missed are “footnoted” as Holmes works through his solutions. I spent quite a bit of time after I’d finished reading just going back and looking for points that I’d missed in the dialogue and artwork. Reading is rarely that fun for me, so the new format is definitely beneficial with this set of characters.

The only thing I didn’t care for was the shift in illustrators toward the end of the story arc. I was reading a tradebook, so I had all of them together in one sitting. The artists responsible for the art in the Epilogue were different from the other chapters and it’s evident in the details. I noticed the subtle differences in the coils of Holmes’ dreadlocks and Watson’s hairline. All things considered, these aren’t major detractors from the overall product, but it was enough to give me pause to flip back and forth a few times.

I was genuinely impressed with this take on a story near and dear to me. I’m definitely going to keep an eye out for future Watson and Holmes stories. ( )
1 vote lenabean84 | Jun 20, 2014 |
Yeah, this was pretty much exactly as amazing as I wanted it to be. There had better be more. (And yes, I will buy a copy for myself. And maybe one for a friend. But I had to make the library buy it first.) ( )
2 vote jen.e.moore | Feb 26, 2014 |
Showing 3 of 3
no reviews | add a review

» Add other authors

Author nameRoleType of authorWork?Status
Karl Bollersprimary authorall editionscalculated
Leonardi, RickIllustratormain authorall editionsconfirmed
Mendoza, PaulCreatorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Perlow, BrandonCreatorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
Stroman, LarryIllustratorsecondary authorall editionsconfirmed
You must log in to edit Common Knowledge data.
For more help see the Common Knowledge help page.
Series (with order)
Canonical title
Original title
Alternative titles
Original publication date
Important places
Important events
Related movies
Awards and honors
First words
It's crazy what people'll throw away.
Last words
Disambiguation notice
Publisher's editors
Publisher series
Original language
Canonical DDC/MDS

References to this work on external resources.

Wikipedia in English


Book description
Haiku summary

No descriptions found.

"...re-imagining of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's classic characters as African Americans living and operating in New York City's famous Harlem district. Watson, an Afghanistan war vet, works in an inner-city clinic; Holmes, a local P.I. who takes unusual cases..."--Back cover.… (more)

Quick Links

Popular covers


Average: (3.93)
2 2
3 1
3.5 1
4 6
4.5 1
5 4

Is this you?

Become a LibraryThing Author.


About | Contact | Privacy/Terms | Help/FAQs | Blog | Store | APIs | TinyCat | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | Common Knowledge | 136,458,763 books! | Top bar: Always visible