If They Give You Lined Paper, Write Sideways

by Daniel Quinn

Members	Reviews	Popularity	Average rating	Conversations
55	1	111,716	(3.7)	8

Work details

Book details

Title	If They Give You Lined Paper, Write Sideways
Author	Daniel Quinn
Rating
Tags	2-own-home, xmas 2007, non-fiction, 1-b, read 2008, evolution, human evolution, culture, anthropology, society, extinction, 4-gift, sociology, 3-read, R-2008-01, A-2007-12, 6loc2
Collections	Your library, Books I have read, Books I can lend you
Your review	Summary: For those of you reading this review who are unfamiliar with Quinn's work, I'd recommend starting with Ishmael or Story of B. I can, without hesitation or hyperbole, say that these books are the most important books I've ever read. If you're not ready to commit to a reading a book, read either or both of the essays linked below. If you can't commit that far, you'll have to do with my horribly inadequate summary: Currently, there are six billion people on the planet, and although we're supposed rational, we're living in a way that is systematically destroying the very support of human life. Quinn attempts to get to the bottom of why this is the case, and points out that if we as a species are going to survive the next few hundred years, we're going to have to live differently... and that means we're going to have to start thinking differently about who we are as a culture, and as a species, and as a participant of life on this planet. This book is a way of understanding what exactly it means to think differently. It's set up as a transcript of a four-day dialogue between Daniel Quinn and one of his readers. The fundamental question they set out to answer is "How do you do what you do?"; that is, what does it mean to see the world from a Daniel Quinn-ian perspective, and how can the rest of us go about achieving that perspective? In achieving that, it covers a lot of ground familiar from Quinn's other work, but the focus is not so much on the answers, but rather on the method of discovering those answers for yourself. It's formatted so that when Quinn tells Elaine to take a break and think about things, the reader can also set the book aside for a moment and attempt to think through the problem on their own - although of course we're denied feedback when our answer differs from Elaine's. This book also includes the text of two of Quinn's speeches, The New Renaissance and Our Religions, which have never before been published, but are available on the web. Review: The preface to this book states that "the reading of [Quinn's] other books is not in any way a prerequisite to reading this one." I have to disagree. Well, I do think that this work would probably be understandable to readers unfamiliar with Quinn's oeuvre, although they'd miss a lot of the subtleties. He references a lot of topics - tribalism, animism, Takers and Leavers, Mother Culture, the Gebusi of New Guinea, the Great Forgetting - and more-or-less takes it for granted that the reader will understand what he means with minimal explanation. His point may come across to new readers, but the full impact of that point may not. However, whether or not a new reader could understand this book is immaterial, since I can't really see why someone who is not familiar with Quinn's work would want to read a book that explains how Quinn thinks. The book itself is excellent at accomplishing its twin goals - of not only explaining how Quinn thinks, but also in giving those of us who have read the rest of his books a means of checking how "changed" our minds really are - if we're just repeating Quinn's answers, or if we've absorbed the message enough to generate new answers on our own. Ideally, we'd all get to sit down with Daniel for a couple of days and chat... but failing that, this book is a good substitute. Recommendation: For newcomers to Quinn, don't start here. For Quinn devotees (if you are B - or think you are) then this book is definitely worthwhile, a quick-reading but deceptively simple kick in the butt that makes you really think about how you think, and the things that Culture tells us that you automatically take for granted.
Other authors 1
Publication	Steerforth (2007), Paperback, 208 pages
Publication date	2007
ISBN	1586421263 / 9781586421267
LC classification 1	GN502 .Q85
Dewey	153
Subjects	Cognition and culture Ethnopsychology
Primary language eng	English
Secondary language	(blank)
Original language
Date acquired	2007-12-25
Date started	2008-01-09
Date finished	2008-01-09
Summary 1	If They Give You Lined Paper, Write Sideways by Daniel Quinn (2007)
Comments
BCID	XXX-
Number of copies	1
Citation	MLA, APA, Chicago/Turabian, Wikipedia citation
Data source	amazon.com