|
Loading... LibraryThing recommendationsMember recommendationsLoading...
won't like
will probably not like
will probably like
will like
will love Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. multiple levels of plotting, very satisfying ( )I've always enjoyed reading Elizabeth George mysteries because of the high quality of the writings as well as the analytical descriptions of her characters and settings. However, none of her characters, whether they be good or bad, are genuinely likeable. Lynley is a turnoff, he's arrogant and a self-righteous prig. Helen, while nice, is somewhat pretentious. Havers is more sympathetic, but her defeatist attitude is annoying. Simon and Deborah are quiet but not particularly engaging. As for the rest of the characters, they may be interesting, but they're simply not the kind of people you'd want to be friends with. In this novel, Barbara is treated badly (again), she needs a friend, and George should lighten up on her. Lynley is a pompous prat; and he and Helen would, in real life, be in the divorce court – if they ever made it to the altar in the first place. The plot is weak and George is over obsessed with sex. The ending is ridiculously convoluted, improbable, verbose, and pretentious (even a quote from Orwell, for heaven's sake!). There are too many coincidences and loose ends that are never explained. Six hundred pages is absurd; a few hundred could be cut out easily. BUT.... I couldn't put the book down and read it in two solid sittings, so she is clearly doing something right! Gets four stars from me for being so long and keeping me entertained. Some of the characters were a bit wooden and the dialogues sometimes rang a bit false, but I wouldn't mind reading another George novel soon. The setting on the moors is wonderful, the conflict between Lynley and Barbara Havers is unusual, yet maybe it's not a good idea to read two E. George books in quick succession. Still, I like the way she develops all her characters -- and there are many -- and gets to their motivations. I love the way George weaves themes through her plots and subplots. Control was the issue here - who has it, who doesn’t and what anyone does to keep it. How much control can you have over any one person? Sin and guilt is also a strong theme and the “proper” sinner - who’s really in the wrong. Lynley deals with the outfall of Havers previous investigation as well as searches out the murderer of a former colleague’s daughter. Some of the subplots are left open - I don’t know if they’re just glimpses of people’s lives to mislead our eye from the culprit, to confuse things or if George is going to pick them up in later books. Some of them I really want to find out what’s going to happen! Like in this one - what’s going to happen with Julian Britton, his dad and his cousin!? no reviews | add a review
Amazon.com Amazon.com Audiobook Review (ISBN 0553102354, Hardcover)The narrative talents of English stage actor Derek Jacobi are put to excellent use in this intriguing mystery of a double murder most foul. Author Elizabeth George presents her popular detectives Thomas Lynley and Barbara Havers with one of their most grisly and difficult cases ever as they search for clues to a bloody crime while struggling to repair their own strained partnership. George's mystery bobs, weaves, twists, and turns from a packed West End theater through the sumptuous halls of a country manor and into the desolate reaches of the high country moors before revealing its delightfully wicked and suspenseful conclusion. Jacobi tackles the complex plot and diverse cast of characters with relish, working his theatrical skills into an outstanding performance. (Running time: 6 hours, 4 cassettes) --George Laney(retrieved from Amazon Fri, 24 Apr 2009 07:57:53 -0400) The first test round has been closed. Visit the Open Shelves Classification group for details. |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||