I agree with the other three reviews - a fair enough story, easy to read, and interesting teenage characters, but the promise of something more interesting than what ACTUALLY happens never amounts to anything more than an overnight stay in a cold and windy building. The storyline is basically one teen lying to his friends, which gets them into slightly more trouble with the local police than they bargained for, ending in the teens holing up in an abandoned castle while the frustrated and - quite rightly so - angry adults try to get them out.. Sadly, I think this story could have been better... ( )

Summary: A group of children sneak onto the grounds of a local ruined castle - the moat's the best place for sledding. Three of them - loner Emily, local troublemaker Simon, and the decidedly offbeat Marcus - decide to break into the castle to look around, at Marcus's urging. However, once they're inside, they decide to come back to spend the night... and then once they've begun defending the keep, how long can they hold out against the siege of adults come to take them home?

Review: I really enjoyed Stroud's Bartimaeus Trilogy, so I was expecting a lot more from this book than what it managed to deliver. The writing is on par with that of the trilogy: well-written, dry humor, and a feel for the rhythm of teenager's dialogue, but the storytelling aspect is woefully lacking. I kept expecting there to be something more going on than what was presented, something supernatural, or mysterious, or an interesting twist, at least, but it never materialized. Instead, it's a pretty straightforward story about a bunch of kids who break into a castle and don't want to come out, for reasons that are probably pretty familiar to most kids. Unfortunately, instead of feeling relatable, it just comes off as mundane and slightly boring, with plenty of action but not a lot of substantial plot or character development.

Recommendation: It might be of interest to kids who enjoy action-adventure stuff about sieges and battles (like Marcus), but there's not a lot more to it than that, and it failed to really capture my interest. ( )

This account of three children who dare to break into a medeival castle and hold up there was a bit slow. It was more character driven than action driven but it explores friendship, loyalty, and it's limits. ( )

A trio of very different children meet and decide to break into an old castle and camp out there. These three teenagers don't really fit in with other kids and find themselves enjoying the feeling of togetherness. When Marcus returns the next day with bruises and blames his father they have to do something but is it the right something?

Not really what I expected having read the Bartimeaus trilogy but still a good read. ( )