The back cover of my edition says that this novel is "regarded by many as the greatest historical novel ever written". Opinion on Amazon is also almost unanimously very positive. So it must be me, but I found this novel mostly pretty tedious. Breem was obviously a very good writer and researched the subject very well, but for me this does not work as a novel; I found no emotional engagement in the characters and situations and found I did not care who won battles or betrayed or killed other characters. There were a few good set piece scenes but this did not make it for me. Very disappointing, speaking as a fan of Graves, McCullough, Saylor, Massie and excellent novelists of ancient Rome. ( )

I'm not particularly interested in military history, but this book haunts me. I'd never have found it if Ammianus had not suggested it somewhere, on some post. ( )

"Eagle in the Snow" by Wallace Breem brings to vivid life the final surreal days of the 20th legion and their fateful last stand against the invaders of Rome in Gaul. Mr. Breem's ability to portray the bitterness, hardship and helplessness of a major historical event and the real and not-so-real people who took part is tantamount to a majestic dolour. There was a point during the final stand as comrades and friends were being cut down like so much wheat that I almost began to sob. A definite must read for those who enjoy their historical fiction with exceptionally accuracy, emotion and action. ( )

A great story centered upon the ill-fated Roman defense of Gaul following the crossing of the frozen Rhine on 31 DEC 406AD by the Alans, Sueves and Vandals. Especially recommended to wargamers of the Late Roman era. ( )

Thoughtful and interesting historical military fiction. Considered by some to be a classic in the genre. Definitely worth reading if you're interested in the later Roman empire. ( )