|
Loading... The Emperor of Scent: A True Story of Perfume and Obsessionby Chandler Burr
LibraryThing recommendationsMember recommendationsLoading...
won't like
will probably not like
will probably like
will like
will love Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. Fascinating study of one person's obsession with scent and how people smell (verb!). Some of the chemistry was over my head, but the gossip about perfume was so much fun. Brilliant biophysicist and perfume connoisseur Luca Turin struggles to prove his theory of olfactory vibration. Journalist Chandler Burr turns a unexpected meeting with Turin into a lush and easily engaging tale of scientific inquiry, excitement, and pettiness. Chandler narrates Turin’s complexities of working with “biophysistry”, the unholy trinity of physics, biology, and chemistry to unravel the last mystery of the senses-- smell. Tradition holds that olfactory senses operate by “shape”, connecting smell molecules to the appropriate molecular docking site in the human nose. Turin promptly turns this on its head by reinvigorating a theory of vibration proposed by Malcolm Dyson. The human side of science is exposed as Turin runs into blank stares and closed doors as olfactory scientists refuse or are unable to comprehend Turin’s multi-disciplinary findings. The decidedly biased tilt in favor of Turin’s radical new theory is dealt with by the author when he explains his efforts to interview scientists on the other side of the debate were promptly shut down; phone calls and e-mails were full of vitriol or went unanswered. Despite such opposition, Turin’s struggles bear fruit as his theory and legendary perfumery skills secure him a place among the industrial giants of scent. Burr’s story about Luca Turin, a scientist with an unusually sensitive nose provides some fascinating insights on how dogs may perceive - or more importantly, think about - scent. I found the parts of the book where Turin talks about the way he perceives smells to be utterly fascinating. Much, I imagine, like a dog - Turin can describe a range or odors from feces to flower with both remarkable accuracy and a refreshing lack of judgement. My ideas about odor, and about dogs, were changed after reading this book. (Sidebar: For a discussion on the philosophy and neurobiology of scent perception, skip Turin’s book on smell and read Wilson and Stevenson’s excellent ”Learning to Smell“ instead.) A gripping story - I finished it in a couple of days, almost un-putdownable. Some of the science simplifications are a tad dodgy (titanium is bulletproof?) but by and large those don't detract from the high drama. The value to me apart from Turin's very attractive theory, is the way resentment for the person corrupts the 'reasons' why various establishment people don't accept his work. I couldn't resist chuckling at the fact that almost all the negative comments about Turin's theory arise from people who 'don't have the time' to read his paper. But most memorable of all was the way a researcher from Leceister Uni refused to consider it 'because there's a history involved'. Talk about 'shooting the messenger'! For all those who think science is pure science and personalities don't get involved, read this... on second thoughts no, you won't have time ;-) Thomas Kuhn, eat your heart out... no reviews | add a review
References to this work on external resources.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Book description |
|
(retrieved from Amazon Fri, 24 Apr 2009 07:58:05 -0400)
The first test round has been closed. Visit the Open Shelves Classification group for details.
Quick Links |
| Ebooks | Audio | Swap |
| — | — | 2/49 |
Burr is the perfume writer for the New York Times. In this book he tells the story of an eccentric French scientist, Luca Turin, with an amazing nose and fascination with both perfume and the science of smell. Turin shakes up the perfume industry with his first book and then turns his attention to discovering how we smell. His resurrection of an old theory with new proof threatens to destroy careers and entire industries. Burr explains how Turin’s scientific efforts are silenced by a commitment to profit and institutional resistance to and fear of change. (