

|
Loading... The Birthday Party: A Memoir of Survivalby Stanley N. Alpert
None. http://educationanddeconstruction.com/?p=1415 A very interesting memoir about the 26 hours Stan Alpert spent as a kidnapping victim and the investigation and aftermath. He was incredibly fortunate that they did not murder him. Certainly Alpert had substantially better survival skills than I do (and, I suspect, better than most of us). For me, the weakest part of the book was the final 1/3, which followed the investigation, probably because I worked as a legal assistant in a criminal defense firm for 14 years and it was all very familiar to me. Otherwise, I enjoyed Stanley's story. Very interesting account of Mr. Alpert's kidnapping off the streets of New York City. Nowhere in the book does the author mention being targeted by the kidnappers specifically because he is Jewish. Despite this fact the author felt the need to pepper his book with stereotypical references about Jewish culture and his own Jewish upbringing. They occur so often I found them to be a bit distracting and a little out of place in this book. Stanley Alpert describes, in detail, his ordeal of being kidnapped near his apartment in Greenwich Village by a group who set out to only steal his ATM card and PIN number. Stanley's story is one that I never want to experience and he does a great job of explaining the details of all that happened to him. However, maybe I have a distorted view because I read a lot of suspense novels, but I found it to be lacking in oomph. Just the thought of being kidnapped arouses anxiety in me and I didn't feel any major fear from him throughout the whole episode. Yes, thankfully for his sake, he remained calm, which contributed to his survival, but for a written memoir I would have thought he would have chosen words that would instill a sense of fear or make it more suspenseful. He literally just wrote what happened. By no means am I suggesting that he embellish his story, but I think the manner in which it was told could have been more exciting. (3.75/5) Originally posted on: Thoughts of Joy Stanley Alpert's *The Birthday Party* is a remarkably well done account of an extraordinary story. Of the thousands of books I've read in my life, this one is unique in that the presence of the author's photo is one of the most compelling aspects of the book. Without ruining anything, that Mr. Alpert survived to tell this story borders on the unimaginable. Yet the narrative is so very compelling that *The Birthday Party* remains a page-turner, even though the narrator's voice should make the unlikely but life-affirming conclusion self-evident. In this way, the book resembles the award winning film documentary "Touching the Void" (though I liked *The Birthday Party* much better). I can't understand any issues with the writing style -- I found the story compelling, fast-moving and well-crafted. I highly recommend it. no reviews | add a review
References to this work on external resources.
|
Google Books — Loading...RatingAverage: (3.73)
Is this you?Become a LibraryThing Author. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||