Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.
Loading... Strange Boyby Paul Magrs
None Loading...
Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. No current Talk conversations about this book. no reviews | add a review
David's an outsider. He's smart, sensitive - and convinced he has secret super-powers. Life for him and his brother is a constant whirl of would-be step-families and overbearing friends and relations. And even aged ten, he's finding he's not sure what he thinks about fancying girls when 14-year-old John down the road seems so much more interesting... Paul Magrs' warm, vividly told story of childhood's end blends comedy and drama in a wild play-ground of messed-up lives and family feuds. No library descriptions found. |
Current DiscussionsNone
Google Books — Loading... GenresMelvil Decimal System (DDC)823.914Literature English & Old English literatures English fiction Modern Period 1901-1999 1945-1999LC ClassificationRatingAverage:
Is this you?Become a LibraryThing Author. |
I was tempted to stop the review there, but that will only serve to annoy readers of this review, so to flesh out my feelings a bit: Paul Magrs set out to write a book he would have liked to read as a young teen. Presumably he succeeded in this quest, but I know it is not a book I would have wanted at the same age. For some people this will no doubt be a fresh original work, gritty and exploring realistic themes as 10 year old David's parents divorce and find new partners. In the meantime David explores themes of emerging sexuality, as well as friendship, rejection, peer pressure and suchlike.
Whilst the book will find its admirers, I disliked it. The sexual encounter is a brave departure for a children's or young adult book, but it does not really come over well. Something happens and then its forgotten - and the something that happens just does not feel realistic - more like the kind of encounter a 30 something year old might wish they had dared at the age of 10. I could be wrong there, but that was my feeling. In any case it went nowhere and ultimately did not seem to fit with the greater theme of the book.
But then I have to ask myself what the greater themes of the book was, and I am not sure I can really answer that. This is a story without a story. It has all the subtle back story you would expect in a good novel, but it seems to be missing an overarching plot. The book kind of fizzled out, and did not really end.
Many of the themes of this book are so much more expertly put together in books by David Almond or Pauline Fisk and others. Where the book is perhaps highly original, it fails to capitalise on this and unfortunately this is a book that will be quickly forgettable. I would not recommend it to its intended young adult audience - there are many much better works to choose from.
Paul Magrs does show some promise in this book. He just fails to realise it. Perhaps a name to watch in the future, but this book is not one I can recommend. ( )