HomeGroupsTalkMoreZeitgeist
Search Site
This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.

Results from Google Books

Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.

Trying Leviathan: The Nineteenth-Century New…
Loading...

Trying Leviathan: The Nineteenth-Century New York Court Case That Put the Whale on Trial and Challenged the Order of Nature (original 2007; edition 2010)

by D. Graham Burnett

MembersReviewsPopularityAverage ratingMentions
923292,131 (3.39)3
In Moby-Dick, Ishmael declares, "Be it known that, waiving all argument, I take the good old fashioned ground that a whale is a fish, and call upon holy Jonah to back me." Few readers today know just how much argument Ishmael is waiving aside. In fact, Melville's antihero here takes sides in one of the great controversies of the early nineteenth century--one that ultimately had to be resolved in the courts of New York City. In Trying Leviathan, D. Graham Burnett recovers the strange story of Maurice v. Judd, an 1818 trial that pitted the new sciences of taxonomy against the then-popular--and biblically sanctioned--view that the whale was a fish. The immediate dispute was mundane: whether whale oil was fish oil and therefore subject to state inspection. But the trial fueled a sensational public debate in which nothing less than the order of nature--and how we know it--was at stake. Burnett vividly recreates the trial, during which a parade of experts--pea-coated whalemen, pompous philosophers, Jacobin lawyers--took the witness stand, brandishing books, drawings, and anatomical reports, and telling tall tales from whaling voyages. Falling in the middle of the century between Linnaeus and Darwin, the trial dramatized a revolutionary period that saw radical transformations in the understanding of the natural world. Out went comfortable biblical categories, and in came new sorting methods based on the minutiae of interior anatomy--and louche details about the sexual behaviors of God's creatures. When leviathan breached in New York in 1818, this strange beast churned both the natural and social orders--and not everyone would survive.… (more)
Member:meggyweg
Title:Trying Leviathan: The Nineteenth-Century New York Court Case That Put the Whale on Trial and Challenged the Order of Nature
Authors:D. Graham Burnett
Info:Princeton University Press (2010), Paperback, 288 pages
Collections:To read, In Library
Rating:
Tags:animals

Work Information

Trying Leviathan by D. Graham Burnett (2007)

None
Loading...

Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book.

No current Talk conversations about this book.

» See also 3 mentions

Showing 3 of 3
In Trying Leviathan: The Nineteenth-Century New York Court Case That Put the Whale on Trial and Challenged the Order of Nature, D. Graham Burnett examines James Maurice v. Samuel Judd (1818), a three-day trial in which Judd, an oil merchant, argued that Maurice, the inspector, did not have the authority to collect his fee on fish oil since whale oil came from a whale, not a fish. Burnett argues that the case affords "a valuable opportunity to contribute to a growing revisionist literature that has called into question a dominant narrative in the history of science - a narrative that considers the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries the 'golden age' of classificatory sciences" (pg. 194). According to Burnett, from the perspective of those claiming lay expertise in the natural world, "the early nineteenth century looked less like a taxonomic calm before the Darwinian storm..., and more like an era of instability and change, when established orders were under siege and taxonomic expertise various and hotly contested" (pg. 194). The laypeople struck back at the threat they perceived from the social and political elites, deciding after a three-day trial that whales were fish. Burnett writes, "The verdict, by these lights, struck a blow for plain folk everywhere" (pg. 179). These same conflicts parallel the issues modern American society currently faces. As Burnett argues, "the case provides...a compelling example of the perennially reciprocal constitution of natural and social orders" (pg. 146). Burnett draws upon a wide breadth of background, including the backgrounds of the principals in the trial, various writings about whales and marine life from the period, and sources examining the social changes occurring in turn of the century Manhattan. Burnett offers a fascinating look at this period, but loses focus at times. Despite this, the volume is required reading for anyone interested in the history of science. ( )
  DarthDeverell | Jan 14, 2017 |
A history of the court case where the crucial question was: Is a whale a fish or a mammal? The author gives a great deal of detail, spinning out the history of taxonomy and whaling to set a background for a case that in the end was a dispute between two powerful business groups, both determined to win, and not caring if they made a total fool out of science in the process. This case included a bit of everything: anti-intellectualism, capitalism, government regulators, science, history, and the common man. For people who believe that the anti-science mood in this country is recent, cases like this demonstrate that the roots of anti-intellectualism and anti-science go deep in America. In the end, though, science had the last laugh, as almost no one would insist a whale is a fish today. Decent reading; a bit pedantic. ( )
  Devil_llama | Apr 20, 2014 |
Did you know that a New York jury in 1818 determined that a whale was a fish? I didn't, but I do now, thanks to D. Graham Burnett's Trying Leviathan: The Nineteenth-Century New York Court Case That Put the Whale on Trial and Challenged the Order of Nature (Princeton University Press, 2007). Burnett takes as his subject the notable case of Maurice vs. Judd, in which an inspector of fish oil sued a merchant for $75, the cost of inspecting three barrels of whale oil. Judd, the merchant, claimed that the statute mandating inspections didn't cover his oil, since the law read "fish oil" and his came from whales. A trial ensued over whether the statute applied (and hence, whether "fish oil" included whale oil or not, and thus, whether whales were fish or not).

Featuring the testimony of taxonomists, whalers, merchants and legal experts, the trial offers a great example of the conflict between science, government, and common perception (some things never change). As Burnett writes, this case provides a look into the "contested territory of zoological classification," and he offers a brief but deep look at the problematic nature of cetacean classification through history. He also examines the question from the point of view of whalers (those "on the ground," so to speak), using evidence from logbooks, diaries, and, naturally, Moby-Dick, and he also digs into the question from the perspective of oil merchants and leather manufacturers (those most directly concerned with the practical issues at hand).

Burnett did his homework in writing this book, and it shows. The footnotes (positioned right at the bottom of the page where they belong) are both complete and instructive, and the bibliography is rich (my "to read" list expanded greatly just with the titles from this book). A readable and excellent book which brings an important but forgotten moment to life in fine style.

http://philobiblos.blogspot.com/2008/07/book-review-trying-leviathan.html ( )
4 vote JBD1 | Jul 21, 2008 |
Showing 3 of 3
no reviews | add a review
You must log in to edit Common Knowledge data.
For more help see the Common Knowledge help page.
Canonical title
Original title
Alternative titles
Original publication date
People/Characters
Important places
Important events
Related movies
Epigraph
When Leviathan is the text, the case is altered.

Herman Melville, Moby-Dick
Dedication
For Francesca Socorro
First words
Quotations
Last words
Disambiguation notice
Publisher's editors
Blurbers
Original language
Canonical DDC/MDS
Canonical LCC

References to this work on external resources.

Wikipedia in English

None

In Moby-Dick, Ishmael declares, "Be it known that, waiving all argument, I take the good old fashioned ground that a whale is a fish, and call upon holy Jonah to back me." Few readers today know just how much argument Ishmael is waiving aside. In fact, Melville's antihero here takes sides in one of the great controversies of the early nineteenth century--one that ultimately had to be resolved in the courts of New York City. In Trying Leviathan, D. Graham Burnett recovers the strange story of Maurice v. Judd, an 1818 trial that pitted the new sciences of taxonomy against the then-popular--and biblically sanctioned--view that the whale was a fish. The immediate dispute was mundane: whether whale oil was fish oil and therefore subject to state inspection. But the trial fueled a sensational public debate in which nothing less than the order of nature--and how we know it--was at stake. Burnett vividly recreates the trial, during which a parade of experts--pea-coated whalemen, pompous philosophers, Jacobin lawyers--took the witness stand, brandishing books, drawings, and anatomical reports, and telling tall tales from whaling voyages. Falling in the middle of the century between Linnaeus and Darwin, the trial dramatized a revolutionary period that saw radical transformations in the understanding of the natural world. Out went comfortable biblical categories, and in came new sorting methods based on the minutiae of interior anatomy--and louche details about the sexual behaviors of God's creatures. When leviathan breached in New York in 1818, this strange beast churned both the natural and social orders--and not everyone would survive.

No library descriptions found.

Book description
Haiku summary

Current Discussions

None

Popular covers

Quick Links

Rating

Average: (3.39)
0.5
1 1
1.5
2 1
2.5
3 1
3.5 2
4 2
4.5 1
5 1

Is this you?

Become a LibraryThing Author.

 

About | Contact | Privacy/Terms | Help/FAQs | Blog | Store | APIs | TinyCat | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | Common Knowledge | 203,232,529 books! | Top bar: Always visible