One of my favorite fear streets, I used to read this every February (its a valentine's day horror). ( )

I did not guess the ending of this one at all- I was sure Rachel was guilty the whole time. I'm not into Stine's nasty characters- like Josie in this one (or nasty Reba from Silent Night), so I wasn't too sad about Josie dying. What did bother me was that Erica's parents do nothing to fix the situation with Josie not helping. ( )