Zoe's Tale

by John Scalzi

Series: Old Man's War (4)

Members	Reviews	Popularity	Average rating	Conversations
537	41	9,128	(3.92)	64

Work details

Book details

Title	Zoe's Tale
Author	John Scalzi
Rating
Tags	fiction, science fiction, novel, juvenile, early reviewers, arc
Collections	Your library
Your review	John Scalzi’s aliens are sparsely described and unconvincingly Other (he’s no Larry Niven) and his characters are usually some variation on smartass. But his novels, with exciting plots and witty dialogue (see “some variation on smartass,” above), never fail to entertain. So it is with Zoe’s Tale, which is a retelling of the story of The Last Colony (which missed winning this year’s Hugo Award for Best Novel by a whisker) from the point of view of the protagonists’ adopted daughter, Zoë. (Why she loses the umlaut in the book’s title, I have no idea.) The Last Colony suffered from a couple of plot holes (viz., where did those werewolves go, and how did Zoë get that deus-ex-machina technology?) that Zoe’s Tale fills fulsomely. In fact, it’s impossible to consider Zoe’s Tale absent The Last Colony: it’s very much a mirror image of that novel. The two novels are both case studies in limited first-person narration: neither John Perry, the protagonist of The Last Colony and Zoë’s stepfather, nor Zoë herself in Zoe’s Tale, knows exactly what the other is doing; essentially, these are two books trying to tell the same story. Two blind grabs at the same elephant. The end result is that Zoe’s Tale deals in detail with what The Last Colony mentioned in passing; unfortunately, the converse is also true: the grand plot of The Last Colony is given short shrift in Zoe’s Tale — key points are mentioned briefly, plot twists are telegraphed — and I’m not sure if Zoe’s Tale stands alone as a result. The tension between the novel’s two ambitions — a retelling of the events of The Last Colony from Zoë’s perspective, and an attempt to explore Zoe’s tragic background and her role as an object of veneration for an entire alien species — is sometimes strained, and I think the latter suffers a little bit at the expense of the former. Despite Scalzi’s breezy and accessible prose and the book’s positioning as a young-adult novel, Zoe’s Tale is an ambitious book. Despite its flaws, it mostly succeeds, in that it’s got lots of good bits in it and is fun to read. Which, in the end, is really what matters, don’t you think? http://www.mcwetboy.com/mcwetlog/2008...
Other authors 1
Publication	Tor Books (2008), Hardcover, 336 pages
Publication date	2008
ISBN	0765316986 / 9780765316981
LC classification
Dewey	813.6
Subjects	Life on other planets › Fiction Science fiction Space colonies › Fiction Space warfare › Fiction Teenage girls › Fiction
Primary language eng	English
Secondary language	(blank)
Original language
Date acquired
Date started
Date finished
Summary 0	Zoe's Tale by John Scalzi (2008)
Comments	Advance reading copy.
BCID	XXX-
Number of copies	1
Citation	MLA, APA, Chicago/Turabian, Wikipedia citation
Data source	amazon.com