Maybe I'm alone in this, but I really found this book to be rudimentary and frustrating, although I found The Rising Tide to be okay. The characters were shallow - I just did not really care about them at all. How much of his research included watching famous films? I really felt like numerous scenes were lifted - almost word for word - from award-winning movies such as Patton, The Longest Day and the mini-series Band of Brothers. He retold one of the most famous stories in world history while adding NOTHING to it. I really cannot recommend this book at all. ( )

Interesting portrayal of the key personalities involved in D day landing from an American viewpoint. I particularly enjoyed the description of how Eisenhower dealt with the conflicts between the various generals under him.

The book would have been improved by the addition of more, and more detailed, maps. ( )

This was a very enjoyable book. I do not typically gravitate to historical novels, preferring non-fiction. This work, however, was well done and filled in the unknown conversations in a manner that was entertaining and true to actual events. The juxtaposition of Eisenhower and Rommel was a good structural choice. I also appreciated the use of character names in lieu of chapter numbers. ( )

This is my favorite of all of Jeff Shaara's historical novels. There is something about the character's of the American flyers, the members of the Lafayette Escadrille, and even the Red Baron, that were so engaging, much more so than the characters in his other books. These characters kept me reading into all hours of the night, and I was sorry to see the book end.

The D-Day story has been told many times in books and movies. The gold standard for years was probably S.L.A. Marshall, until he was displaced by Stephen Ambrose. The Steel Wave complements Ambrose by portraying the personal, emotional side of the events. As with the rest of Shaara’s novels, this is not light fiction. It is interesting, accessible history.

My complete review is on my blog, Nate's Library, specifically at: http://nates-library.blogspot.com/200... ( )

Just about to finish and I have to admit, not being a big fan of the style J.Shaara writes in, this book is really quite good. Just finished new biography about Eisenhower the bits about Ike were quite good. Embellishment and fiction, as no one can really tell us what he was thinking, but true to form. Good perspective of on the para drops and landings at Omaha. Would have like to see more ground level views at Omaha, instead got one grunts perspective of the landing. Still was good and it was obvious the author did his research. Will be interesting to see how this series of books unfolds. ( )

"The Steel Wave," the second book in Jeff Shaara’s proposed World War II trilogy, covers a key period of the war, January-September 1944, months during which plans for the Normandy Invasion were finalized and a successful invasion of France allowed Allied troops to begin the push that would ultimately rid France of the occupying German army. This may sound like just another dry bit of American history, but Jeff Shaara does such a remarkable job of capturing the nerve-wracking tension experienced by those who lived through those nine months that this 493-page book is a page-turner from start to finish.

Shaara does a huge amount of research in preparation for each of his historical novels, largely relying on primary sources such as diaries, interviews, radio transcripts and memoirs in order to place his readers in the minds of those who saw the making of history firsthand. In The Steel Wave, he primarily uses three voices, in alternating chapters, to tell the story of the planning and successful execution of the Normandy Invasion: General Dwight Eisenhower, Field Marshall Erwin Rommel and Sergeant Jesse Adams, a paratrooper of the 82nd Airborne.

The book opens several months prior to the actual invasion with the description of a three-man commando raid on Normandy whose sole purpose was to obtain rock samples from the beach. Even at that late date, Eisenhower and his staff remained uncertain that the surface of the beaches of Normandy could physically support the tanks and heavy artillery pieces that needed to be unloaded there in support of the invading ground troops, and they hoped the gathered rocks would answer that question. But that was only one of the unknowns faced by the Allies as they worked toward a plan that they hoped would surprise the German defenders.

Therein lays the beauty of Shaara’s style of historical fiction. The way that he contrasts the day-to-day activities and mindsets of Eisenhower, the aggressor, and Rommel, the defender, emphasizes the precarious nature of the invasion and just how big a gamble it really was on the part of the Allies. As Eisenhower worries about storm forecasts, German gun emplacements and making the Germans believe that the invasion will happen at Calais rather than at Normandy, Rommel is desperately trying to convince Hitler and Hitler’s staff that the entire French coast needs to be defended, not just the port of Calais. Both men fear failure as the invasion approaches and takes on a life of its own, and the reader gets to spend time in both their heads.

Shaara also uses Rommel and Eisenhower to explore the politics and internal power struggles that nagged at both sides as the war progressed. Eisenhower unexpectedly finds himself defending Montgomery’s lack of success when Churchill and British officers are calling for his head while at the same time he tries to keep George Patton, Montgomery’s opposite in almost every way, under control. Rommel, on the other hand, is determined to do his duty to the German nation without being implicated in a plot to assassinate Hitler, something he was unable to do and which, of course, cost him his life.

"The Steel Wave" is one of those books that make history come alive and it will be enjoyed by more than just the history buffs who will be most likely to pick it up, but it will likely disappoint some readers because of the very limited number of pages it devotes to describing the beach landings themselves, a minor quibble, perhaps, but a noticeable omission.

Rated at: 4.0 ( )

Fascinating writing style of the author, excellent level of detail on World War II, very good read. ( )