This a very different book to The Forever War, and not really a sequel. It covers some similar territory, but there are no characters in common, and the overall plots are unrelated (and conflicting). However, this book is as well written as The Forever War, and I enjoyed it.

http://www.stillhq.com/book/Joe_Halde... ( )

In the future world of Forever Peace, the United States possesses nanoforge technology, which can create pretty much anything out of raw materials. The U.S. is also in a perpetual war with most of the countries in the Southern hemisphere, which don’t have the nanoforge. U.S. military fights the war virtually via robots called “soldierboys,” which are controlled by soldiers who are “jacked in” to the killing machines hundreds of miles away.

Julian is one of those soldiers, but when a mission goes horribly wrong, he can no longer bring himself to fight. When his lover, Amelia, discovers that a planned physics experiment will destroy the universe, creating a doomsday device that anyone with a nanoforge and enough raw materials can build, Julian realizes that mankind can no longer afford our warlike nature. Then another scientist friend reveals a solution, one that may either enhance our humanity or remove it altogether.

This was a very entertaining book, with a lot of interesting ideas. I particularly like the way the experience of jacking, not such a new concept in science fiction, is explored. However, after a very long build-up and way too much exposition, I found the end to be unsatisfactorily abrupt and too cut-and-dried. It does seem like eliminating our warlike tendencies is the right course of action to take, but how ethical is it to do so against peoples’ will? No character really takes a stand on this or offers an alternative viewpoint for the rather sticky ethical question raised. The only opposition are such grotesque nutjobs who will do literally anything to bring about the apocalypse so that of course the protagonists seem very sane by comparison.

So even though I really enjoyed Forever Peace, I ended up wishing for a bit more depth to it. ( )

Not a continuation of The Forever War (one of the all-time classics of science fiction), but more of an intellectual sequel, this turns out to be half of a great book. ( )

The book is very well written, but I just couldn't get into it. The story is kind of bland and it's really more psy-fi than sci-fi to me. It doesn't have very much action or suspense. It hits on a lot of things, it's got romance, racism, and as someone else said above, the ethics of forcing an operation on individuals for the good of the world as a whole. But it never really goes deep in any of them. I may be being too hard on it, but I was just expecting more from a Hugo and Nebula winner. ( )

I fairly like this novel. The story was very engaging in the beginning, but fell off in the middle. Mr. Haldeman explores in much detail a very interesting topic. How does a particular advancement in technology impact the world. And not just in total, but down to an individual. I would recommend this book, even if you have not read Forever War. They are written in the same universe, but are completely disjointed. ( )