A decent old HP. He was an opera tenor and she was a girl who didn't care much at all for music. It was fairly well written. One thing that makes a good older HP is if I don't skip ahead to the end. This one kept my interest and kept me reading straight through. The characters were well developed. This wasn't one where the hero is an asshat and the heroine is wimpy. They get together and he asks her to marry him. She says no, but when he leaves, she realizes she's made a mistake and wishes she could have a do over but alas, she must suffer until the end of the book. ( )