|
Loading... The Long Summer: How Climate Changed Civilizationby Brian Fagan
LibraryThing recommendationsMember recommendationsLoading...
won't like
will probably not like
will probably like
will like
will love Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. This book traces how climate change has been both a spur to development and a destroyer of civilizations. Beginning with man's pre-history in the stone age he traces how civilizations have tended to increase in size which can only be maintained by the food resources of the existing climate. If climate change occurs which is prolonged on a global scale, there are very few societies which can maintain themselves. ( )Heard Dr. Fagan in a Long Now Foundation lecture. Liked it so much I decided to read some of his books. Glad I did. This is very interesting material, a survey from about 15000 BC of how climate change has had significant effects on humanity. Unfortunately Brian Fagan is just not a very compelling writer. I look forward to seeing the same material covered by a better author. In terms of substance, I was disappointed by the focus only on the Americas and Europe. Coverage of places like Australia, China, India and Africa would have been valuable. The most interesting thesis, I thought, was that claim that in Israel we have Kerbarans (nomadic hunter gatherers, eat mainly animals, 13000BC), followed by Natufians (sedentary hunter gatherers, eat mainly plants, 11000BC), who suffer severe problems of drought caused by the Younger Dryas, which leads to agriculture. The interesting point is that, at this stage, we now have studies of female bones showing stresses caused by hours of daily repetitive work grinding and pounding and whatever to convert agricultural crops into food. Fagan strongly implies that this was a univeral story, that women in pre-agricultural societies do not show these stresses, and those in post-agricultural societies do. I'd like to have seen a lot more discussion of this point from a world-wide perspective. Did the same thing occur when agriculture began in India, China, the Americas, Africa, New Guinea? And was it always women who were saddled with this role? Why not, eg, male and female slaves? And how long did this last? Do we still see these sorts of long term stresses in, eg, bronze age societies? Michael Shermer counts this among the few books that convinced him that global warming is happening and that anthropogenic explanations are plausible. Do get a skeptic like Shermer to switch sides is quite a feat! 0.063 seconds to build listing no reviews | add a review
Amazon.com (ISBN 0465022820, Paperback)A professor of anthropology by training, Fagan traces the effects of climactic change on civilizations over the past 15,000 years--a period of prolonged global warning that has only accelerated over the past 150 years. In particular, he's interested in how civilizations have responded to, or been radically altered by, changes in environment. One of Fagan's most compelling examples is his detailed history of the city of Ur, in what is now modern-day Iraq. Once a great city in one of the world's earliest civilizations, it first thrived thanks to abundant rainfall and then suffered even more severely when the Indian Ocean monsoons shifted southward, changing rain patterns. By 2000 B.C. its agricultural economy had collapsed, and today it is an abandoned landscape, an assemblage of decaying shrines in the harshest of deserts. Fagan views this event as pivotal. It was, he writes, "the first time an entire city disintegrated in the face of environmental catastrophe." But not, Fagan notes, the last. In his epilogue, which covers the last 800 years of human history, Fagan explores the climatic upheavals that left 20 million dead in famine-related epidemics in the 19th century. He notes that today 200 million people barely survive on marginal agricultural land in places such as northeastern Brazil, Ethiopia, and the Saharan Sahel. If temperatures rise much above current levels, and rising seas flood coastal plains, the devastation could dwarf any disaster humankind has previously known. Fagan doesn't offer easy solutions, but he presents a compelling history of climate's role in the background--and sometimes foreground--of human history. --Keith Moerer(retrieved from Amazon Fri, 24 Apr 2009 07:58:16 -0400) The first test round has been closed. Visit the Open Shelves Classification group for details. |
Abebooks |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||