A pregnant cat finds a home with an abused hunting dog under the porch of a really bad person who makes his living trapping animals in the swamp. Appelt layers several myths into this tale of neglected and abandoned people, animals and mythic creatures. Perfect book for 10 year olds who love to read. ( )

I picked up the book because I liked the cover and was pleased that I'd picked up a Newbery winner. I can tell you that the people who select Newbery awards probably do not confer with children. It took me months to get through this book with my son who is 10. During this time we read other books to completion. We kept going back to this book because I felt that there had to be something we were missing and it was going to get better if we just kept reading. It didn't happen. I didn't care for the way the author interwove the two stories. My son didn't care for the story and though it is geared toward children I can't imagine too many of them actually enjoying it. ( )

This book will capture the attention of students that love cats and dogs. It is an enduring story of friendship and will to live. ( )

This is a wonderful novel. I love the way Kathi Appelt weaves in the Native American legends. ( )

Reviewed by Julie M. Prince for TeensReadToo.com

I've stated before that if a book can make me laugh hysterically or cry hysterically, it's guaranteed a good review because it means the author has gone above and beyond. That is the case with THE UNDERNEATH. Except, a good review isn't enough for this book. It is not. I only hope that my review can begin to do justice to this amazing work.

THE UNDERNEATH is lyrical, strong, and extremely well-written. It is thought provoking and "can't put it down" fantastic. Kathy Appelt does not lower the bar in the slightest from page one until the book is done. Not one bit.

Appelt weaves a brilliant tale about an old, beaten-down hound dog and the felines he loves. She also weaves an almost entirely separate folktale of a miserable, bitter, shape-shifting snake. How do these two stories fit into the same book? Ask Kathi Appelt, because I'm still trying to figure out how she beautifully intertwined them. But she did. She did.

In the acknowledgements, Appelt mentions advice from M.T. Anderson (THE ASTONISHING LIFE OF OCTAVIAN NOTHING) that she took to heart: "Write what you think you can't." Obviously, this author put her heart and her soul into the writing of a beautiful book, and it has paid off with a tale that will last for generations.

You know that gut feeling you get when you read a book like CHARLOTTE'S WEB or THE MIRACULOUS JOURNEY OF EDWARD TULANE? That Lasting feeling? Lasting wraps itself around you and urges you to read this book carefully because you'll want it in good condition on your shelf for a long time to come. That is this book. This perfect and Lasting book. ( )