|
Loading... Lost on Planet China: The Strange and True Story of One Man's Attempt to…by J. Maarten Troost
LibraryThing recommendationsMember recommendations
Loading...
won't like
will probably not like
will probably like
will like
will love Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. I read this book for a RL book group; I would probably not have read it otherwise. I have a minimal interest in modern China. I know they are now big players on the world stage, and that their influence will only grow, but still they don't generate great interest in me. I have Troost's 2 other books (The Sex Lives of Cannibals and Getting Stoned With Savages ) and have read the first book and enjoyed it. I am used to Troost's style which is lightly sarcastic. He points out the foibles of the group he is writing about. I know this tendency upsets the PC crowd, but Troost is incredibly accurate in his observations and depictions, as well as being funny. I have lived in 3rd world countries and agree with his observations on the tropical island book, and one of our group members has been to China to teach,in several cities and she said he was spot on. The premise for this book is that he is thinking of moving there with his wife and 2 small children and he wanted to find out what it was like, and the best place for a family. He is a self-proclaimed China neophyte and he wanted to find out what was fact, and what was old, stereotypical, and just plain wrong. Occasionally he remembers the reason for the trip/book, but mostly its just a wander around various parts of the country. He describes his journey, the places he went, stayed, what he ate, and the people he met. He tries to work out the social reasons for what he observes. He doesn't speak Chinese and he didn't have a guide, translator or minder. He points out what he finds that conflicts with what he thought he knew, or heard, or was told. He talks about change as the main characteristic of China, there is also incredible pollution, crowding and noise. He writes about what he observes of the people he sees and meets and situations he ends up in. Since its such a large country its hard to know how broadly it applies to others in China. He finds the Chinese engaged in a rush for money and wealth. They seem to still revere Mao, even though he was an evil killer. They ignore the Cultural Revolution. They may agitate for local issues, but seem not to be connected to the national political questions. They do seem to know what will draw the police and avoid those who cross the line and bring in the authorities. The parts about their behavior regarding personal hygiene and what they eat and how they kill it, was gross. Though I had read articles about both by others, so I know he is not making it up or exaggerating. He travels by car, train and plane. He goes to Hong Kong which is China-lite as the civility of the British still prevails, and to Tibet, where the country is basically overrun with Han Chinese and under military occupation. He also travels in between these 2 extremes. He finds that there are very wealthy people, middle class people, and incredibly poor and abandoned people. As a foreigner he stands out and is treated with kindness, with revulsion, and like a pet, by different groups and individuals. The book was interesting, funny and well written. It seemed a bit slower than his other book, but it might be that there was just more meat in a book about China than there was in a book about living on a small tropical island. The opening sentence: "There are two kinds of people roaming the far fringes of the world: Mormon missionaries and Chinese businessmen," Troost's accounts are current and amusing, but he exaggerates. I was in China recently earlier this year, and some of his tales brought back memories of what it was like. J. Maarten Troost is a curious sort of traveler. Willing to endure the various waterborne intestinal afflictions encountered during his stay in the South Pacific, he's not a typical tourist. So what better place to continue his exploits than in, say, China? Specifically, his curiosity, like that of many, is to discern just exactly what the Chinese context is. His latest book, Lost on Planet China, intriguingly relays his intrepid dispatches. It is a wonderfully gonzo experience, one that readers may come away thinking how glad they are that someone other than themselves took the time to do this. For readers will encounter, through Troost's initial perceptions, that China is the preeminently overpopulated & polluted, tightly controlled yet super-industrialized nation in the world today. That being said, all your perceptions of China are still wrong, because China is different. It is the most complex, contradictory, and rapidly changing country in the world. And because of this, it is impossible to gauge the Chinese experience from a Western perspective. Troost surrenders himself to a China left un-traveled by most laowais (foreigners). Some of his more curious destinations include the windy and dusty streets of Beijing (the Gobi is subtly encroaching), stumbling upon an endangered species black market in Guangzhou (incidentally where SARS is rumored to start), to the seemingly separate kingdoms of Shanghai, Hong Kong & Macau, to deathly day hikes at the Tiger Leaping Gorge, hearing karaoke in a state-sponsored Shangri-La, the frighteningly alien plateau of Tibet, and the frozen northern borders with Russia and North Korea. Despite Troost's unavoidable preoccupations with the crowds, unhealthy air and the ever-present Communist grip, his observations of China really point to the country as being otherworldly. And despite there being so many diverse provinces and minorities adding to his inability to fully communicate, despite the harsh exertion of the ever-present big brother, Troost does discover the human connection, whether exchanging smiles with an old farmer on a crowded midnight train or being happily fed by a street vendor in Xi'an's Muslim Quarter. So as Troost's Chinese experience starts to reach its conclusion, the reader may acknowledge in his writing a sense of fulfillment, perhaps harmony, as his sojourn winds down in the cold northern wilds of Harbin. Despite the temperature, he feels the warmth in his visit to the local Siberian Tiger preserve; literally fishing for tigers with live chickens, his Chinese context slowly blooms upon a fascinating chance encounter within the North Korean neutral zone. Everything, as the saying goes, is not only relative but foreign. Excellent read. While Troost insists that he is not a travel writer because he writes about places he has lived, this book covers his short travels in China (several months) and definitely qualifies as travel writing. Just not the kind you’d expect from Condé Nast Traveler or National Geographic Traveler. Speaking absolutely no Chinese of any dialect, Troost embarks on a cross-country journey to figure out the curious blend of millennia of history and rapidly growing economic powerhouse that is modern China. Along the way, he visits cities large and small (relatively speaking - small being under 10 million inhabitants), examines the changing face of Chinese communism, learns to haggle, repeatedly fends off opportunists of all persuasions, and delights in the culinary adventures of not being able to read the menus at restaurants. Along with highly entertaining, if not especially enlightening, lessons in Chinese history, Troost details memorable trips to Beijing, Nanjing, Hong Kong, and Lhasa in Tibet. Most remarkable, however, is the author’s snarky yet completely unpretentious narrative voice, just a few ticks wide of black cynicism and possessed of wonderful self-depreciation - imagine Anthony Bourdain without the epicurean know-how or a reliable handler. Frequent explicit language, moderately suggestive language and situations, drug use. This book has high YA interest, if limited to ages 14 and up due to content. no reviews | add a review
References to this work on external resources.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Book description |
|
(retrieved from Amazon Fri, 24 Apr 2009 07:57:57 -0400)
The first test round has been closed. Visit the Open Shelves Classification group for details.
Quick Links |
If you've read any of Troost's books before you know pretty much what to expect when he decides to set off to China to see if maybe it would be a good place to move and raise his kids for a few years. If you haven't read him before, what you need to know is that he doesn't speak any dialect of Chinese, that he believes in traveling without a net, and that irreverent is a kind description.
His observations are witty and entertaining, but I suspect that he often doesn't bother much with historical accuracy or critical thinking of his own observations. I've given the book away already, so I can't cite specifics. None the less it is a very entertaining read, and I think gives a good representation of the size and scale and character of the country, and the impression it leaves on someone who is generally open to any experience that won't land him permanently in jail, or get him killed. (