|
Loading... American lightning: terror, mystery, movie-making, and the crime of the…by Howard Blum
LibraryThing recommendationsMember recommendationsLoading...
won't like
will probably not like
will probably like
will like
will love Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. Overall, it's a good book. As others have said, it is better when the story is about the investigation into the bombing at the LA Times. Then it's gripping and a edge-of-your-seat mystery. The DW Griffith/Hollywood sections seem to belong to another book and really seem to be out of place in this story. I enjoyed Blum's American Lightning, especially in his portrayal of life in the early 1900s. I felt, like other reviewers, that the first half of the book was stronger than the second half, as the detective closes in and the trial takes place. Blum had to walk the narrow line of providing biographies of three different men and then linking together in their final meeting, and I thought that he accomplished this in a readable fashion. The book was easy and quick to read, and at times I yearned for more detail, for more lingering, and more details in certain sections, especially in the early movie industry of D. 'W. Griffeth. However, the book was an entertaining, engaging read that brought to light many details in early 19th century America. A Whodunit Mystery I picked up "American Lightning" with much anticipation after recently reading Erik Larson's "Devil in the White City." Both are period pieces, narrative history, set in roughly the same time period. On the surface, Howard Blum appears to have a real whodunit mystery thriller about a terrorist bomb in 1910 Los Angeles and the intersection of the three principal characters as a result of that attack. Those three characters include: William J. Burns (aka Billy Burns), an American Sherlock Holmes who is hired to find the culprits; D.W. Griffith, a pioneering filmmaker in early Hollywood; and Clarence Darrow, the bombastic lawyer famous for defending Eugene V. Debs for the Pullman strike and Scopes in the evolution vs. creation trials of the 1920s. The story is about the bombing of the Los Angeles Times building, and the resulting manhunt, trial, and movie that followed. The central theme of the period, the progressive era, is the epic struggle between capital and labor. This is where I think Blum's book fundamentally falls short, he fails to really capture the reader with the bitterness of the struggle, on both sides. We never really get the 'on the ground' story, and are instead locked into these three principal characters and their surrogates. Blum never really tells us why this struggle was so hard-fought, why the anarchists so die-hard, why the industrials so ruthless. The best part of the book is definitely the manhunt. Blum takes the reader on a wild journey up and down the west coast, to Chicago, then Indianapolis. It is fast-paced mystery writing at its finest. Blum uses real sources to back up his work, but his lack of extensive notes is also disappointing as it makes it difficult to followup on the details he explores. Overall, the book is a decent read and well-written. However, Blum fails to capture the essence of what he characterizes as "a second civil war... and the inequities of industrial life." Unlike Larson's "Devil in the White City", Blum is unable to situate the reader into the time-period as Larson is able to do. The book is ultimately a mystery novel that is mildly entertaining with little educational value. no reviews | add a review
References to this work on external resources.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Book description |
|
(retrieved from Amazon Tue, 05 Jan 2010 14:47:51 -0500)
The first test round has been closed. Visit the Open Shelves Classification group for details.
Quick Links |
Clarence Darrow, DW Griffith, Mary Pickford, and others are all a part of this story.
Anarchists, water wars, unions vs. non-union men, were all suspected in the bombing. It turned out to be the leaders of the unions, "suggesting" non-union places to bomb. The men who actually did the bombing, had done over 100 bombings across the country.
Burn's life was threatened, more than once. Scandal, bribery, and violence were all part of the trial, and at the conclusion, there was a surprise. Showmanship, and theater in the courtroom played out, much like what we see on Court TV. Movies were made about each side of the case, while the case was ongoing.
I learned alot from this book, most interestingly, that Edgar Lee Masters, one of my favorite authors, was a law partner of Clarence Darrow. It really showed that there is a big difference, then as today between justice for the rich and famous, and justice for the everyday man.
The whole story was intriguing, and a very sad part of American history.
I got this book from the Library.