A great new DMG for 4th edition. Unlike other old schoolers I enjoy the new edition from a DM point a view because this version really streamlines the play so there is less time arguing over rules and more time actually roleplaying. The book will help the new DM a lot, but for the most part, as far as advice and tips go, its the same old game. I even like the new cosmology. ( )

Despite being the least patronizing of the core rule books, the new DMG still manages to be the worst. It as at heart little more than an appendix to the PHB. Shoot, you can even play the game without it since all of the real information is in the PHB.

This version of the DMG contains several sections advising the would-be DM on how to run the game, and how to deal with pesky players. There are sections also on the new cosmology (simplified, but dull) artifacts (there are only five or so presented ; no doubt the others will cost hundreds of dollars to present) and the all-important sample adventure setting carefully couched in silly names and the fantasy register.

Remember how in the 2nd edition how the DMG was basically cut and pasted from the PHB with a couple of extra wordings thrown in? The new edition doesn't go quite that far, but nevertheless cutting and pasting between sections can clearly be seen.

My advice: don't buy this. This is $35 worth of superfluous information, the absence of which won't harm your game one bit. If you really want the low down on the new cosmology, go to the game store, turn to page 160, and take notes. ( )