Hide this

Results from Google Books

Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.

Ibid: A Life by Mark Dunn
Loading...

Ibid: A Life

by Mark Dunn

MembersReviewsPopularityAverage ratingConversations
167335,315 (3.5)7
Loading...
won't like will probably not like will probably like will like will love

Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book.

Showing 3 of 3
The idea of a book consisting entirely of footnotes may sound pretentious. And it may sound like it would, unavoidably, result in tedium. That would be wrong.

I bought Mark Dunn's Ibid: A Life long ago, after a friend told me it was something I should read; then I forgot about it. I confess I doubted a little. And I really like footnotes. That is where all the fun stuff is, even when you are supposed to be reading what is really quite interesting in and of itself. And footnotes in fiction is generally the scene of the most deliciously absurd absurdities (although that might be down to the type of fiction I read).

In theory I should therefore have devoured this book the moment it arrived in my mailbox. But, a tiny voice in the corner of my brain, usually more concerned with not talking to strangers or taking candy from unknown men, said: what about the possibility of too much of a good thing? Aren't footnotes primarily charming because they are only incidental, and because you can choose to disregard them; and doesn't this project really sound like hard work, as they are really expecting you to reconstruct a man's life from the allusions in the footnotes to a biography that, in this case, is not there?

Isn't it, in short, an interesting idea, intellectually, and a nice experiment, literarily, but possibly not the world's most relaxing entertainment? Sometimes, occasionally, I am a little prejudiced.

At any rate, I picked up this book (it had been giving me accusatory glances from the bookshelf). And I read it at a time when I was anything but relaxed and full of energy, ready for intellectual labour -- I was too tired and worn out to do any proper work. And this book was lovely.

The beginning sets the tone of it: it consists in an exchange of letters between the author and his publisher, describing how the biography itself, which, after an accident with a paper shredder, only exists in one version, is destroyed in a bathing accident. And why, therefore, all that is available for publication are the footnotes, which were not yet ready when the accident happened.

And the biography about the three-legged man who began his career as a circus attraction before making it big in the male deodorant industry, rises effortlessly from the pages without requiring any extraordinary mental efforts of the reader. A number of the footnotes are longish, allowing them to tell free-standing anecdotes, and several of the shorter function as in-jokes referencing earlier anecdotes or established facts. There is also a great deal of more or less polite disagreement with fictional academics and earlier experts in the field. Sometimes (or, rather, usually) perfectly outrageous. I laughed. Rather a lot. Out loud. ( )
  camillahoel | Sep 21, 2009 |
A man with three legs' life is written in ibid notes. Very wry, very funny. ( )
  majorbabs | Apr 4, 2008 |
In his new novel, Mark Dunn has painstakingly chronicled the life of the world's most famous three-legged deodorant tycoon, Jonathan Blashette. Only trouble is, Dunn's editor lost the manuscript in an unfortunate bathtub accident, reducing the author's sole copy to a soggy, unreadable pulp. All that's left are the biography's footnotes.

Thus, with an exchange of fictional correspondence between Dunn and Pat Walsh, his real-life editor at Macadam/Cage Publishing, the wildly inventive and chokingly funny Ibid: a Life is off and running like drunk picnickers in a three-legged race. Yes, Dunn sometimes veers off course, but half the amusement comes from watching the story stumble around with hilarious riffs on everything from tent revivals to jigsaw puzzles before getting its bearings again and plowing ahead toward the finish line.

The novel is comprised entirely of footnotes so all we get are brief sentences charting the fictional Blashette's life, which are then expanded and expounded upon with the breathless, jokes-and-puns style Dunn displayed in his two previous novels, Ella Minnow Pea and Welcome to Higby. As Dunn explains in a letter to his editor after the loss of the "tragically water-pulped biography": While the notes illuminate the dusty, crepuscular corners of this man's life, they tell its story only through sidebar and discursion. The book, therefore, becomes a biography by inference.

Be honest: when was the last time you saw the word "crepuscular" used in such a witty context? For that matter, when was the last time you saw "crepuscular" used anywhere under any circumstances? Dunn peppers Ibid with esoteric language once found in florid, hyperbolic books published in the early 20th century. Books like Confessions to a Pee Pee Doctor by urologist Byron Blackfoot, My Life as a Wife-Slugging Bastard, with Afterword by Roscoe "Fatty" Arbuckle by Perry Jennings or When We From Sleep Awake by Rev. Boxer Seale, or periodicals like The Journal of American Amputation—all sources cited in Ibid. Dunn celebrates the excess of American culture, throwing the entire 20th century into the pot and coming up with a rich stew of trivia and ephemera.

Jonathan Blashette, the Donald Trump of anti-perspirants, is everywhere in the country's cultural landscape, hob-nobbing with celebrities and politicos. Among the many famous faces who make a cameo appearance in the footnotes: Aimee Semple McPherson, Evelyn Waugh, Leopold and Loeb, Dylan Thomas, Calvin Coolidge, Valentino and James Joyce. He dissuades McDonald's founder Ray Kroc from naming his sandwiches Krocburgers. He even has a hand in helping Lou Gehrig with his famous "I'm the luckiest man" speech. The deodorant king moves through history like Forest Gump.

If there's a flaw in Ibid, it's this: we never get to know Jonathan Blashette as anything more than a cardboard cutout on the flannel board of history. We watch as, at twelve, he joins Thaddeus Grund's Traveling Circus and Wild West Show. Later, he goes off to fight in World War I, where he comes up with the idea of manufacturing deodorant when he's stuck with stinky-pitted men in the trenches. We follow him through all the trials and tribulations of romance—most of his fiancées and wives meet with tragic demises, leaving him bereft, but undaunted. We watch his meteoric rise in the business world with the Dandy-de-odor-o company, whose popular jingle in the Great Depression was "You won't find a job if you smell like a slob." We get all these facts and anecdotes told throughout the novel's marginal digressions, but we never see into the heart of Blashette or understand what makes him tick as the world's most famous three-legged man.

What's center stage in a novel like Ibid is, of course, the novel itself, and the way Dunn bends and twists the idea of what makes a book a book. He's not the first to tell a story through footnotes—Vladimir Nabokov's Pale Fire springs to mind—but he may be the funniest. Dunn, in fact, goes Nabokov one better by eliminating the source text. In Pale Fire, we had those four cantos of the narrative poem; but in Ibid, we have only the ghost of a lost, soggy text.

This gives Dunn the freedom to take off like a rubber ball bouncing around a many-walled room. Timing is everything in his witty repartee. The jokes roll off his pen like a sweaty-haired stand-up comic energized by an enthusiastic crowd on a good night.

Here's just one footnote, reproduced in its entirety to give you some idea of what to expect on these pages:

14. Love finds Jonathan Blashette. Mildred Boyers' family was relatively new to Pettiville. Her father sold Divine Bain sea sponges throughout a territory that included eastern Arkansas, northern Mississippi, and western Tennessee as well as, curiously, Atlantic City, New Jersey, where, it was said, he had a mistress named Sheila who either (sources disagree) ate lye and died, or ate dye and lied about it, bragging that blue tongues ran in her family. Mildred wasn't close to her father, but found comfort and solace at the rectory of St. Bartholomew Catholic Church of Ambless where she performed light housekeeping chores and posed as famous Greek statuary for the amusement of Father Dwayne and his toothless assistant, Toot.

Ibid is a hysterical celebration of America, literature and American literature—not to mention deodorant, circus freaks, summer camps named Chaubunagungamaug, twelve-step programs, and really bad poetry. Footnotes shouldn't be this fun, but in Dunn's hands they're sublime. ( )
2 vote davidabrams | May 17, 2006 |
Showing 3 of 3
no reviews | add a review
You must log in to edit Common Knowledge data.
For more help see the Common Knowledge help page.
Series (with order)
Canonical Title
Original publication date
People/Characters
Important places
Important events
Related movies
Awards and honors
Epigraph
Footnotes let us hear the missteps of biases, and hear pathos, subtle decisions, scandal an anger. - Chuck Zerby, The Devil's Details
The author may, therefore, include in the notes such things as lists, poems, and discursive adjuncts to the text. - The Chicago Manual of Style
I just love footnotes, don't you? - Diana Gabaldon, The Outlandish Companion
Dedication
For my wife Mary who rocks my world
Thanks for all the years of love and support, and for rescuing me from the Young Republicans
First words
Dear Pat, Greeting to you and all my other friends in the City by the Bay.
Quotations
Last words
(Click to show. Warning: May contain spoilers.)
Disambiguation notice
Publisher's editors
Blurbers

References to this work on external resources.

Wikipedia in English (1)

Ibid: A Life

Book description

Amazon.com (ISBN 0156031000, Paperback)

Mark Dunn's early forays into the novel, Ella Minnow Pea and Welcome to Higby, were praised by critics and relished by bibliophiles for their linguistic gamesmanship. But Ibid: A Life easily outdoes its predecessors for literary audacity. The novel purports to be not a novel at all, but the endnotes of a biography. The main text of the supposed life of Jonathan Bashette was destroyed by a careless editor, and, as the wearied author reports in the letters which begin the book, his publisher has decided that the notes can stand alone.

At first, the conceit makes for difficult reading, but Dunn does a remarkable job of slowly revealing three-legged Jonathan Blashette and his odd world without ever departing from the footnote form. Readers learn that Blashette, born in Pettiville, Arkansas, in 1888, was doomed by his extra leg to become a sideshow attraction. But the boy escapes the circus to become a soldier in World War I. There, in the trenches, he first glimpses (or smells) his future calling: male underarm deodorants. Upon his return to the States, he launches the Dandy-de-odor-o Corporation and marries several times (each wife meeting a bizarre end in the cursed city of Boston). Though rocked by adversity, the fictional Blashette lives a rich life full of encounters with the writers, politicians, artists, and celebrities that marked the 20th Century.

Rather than being a limitation in this quirky Horatio Alger story, the notes offer Dunn freedom to explore the diversity of his imagination with brief sketches and "back-story" that are, in fact, all the story there is. The novel becomes a pastiche of parodies of famous documents, speeches, and poems. Dunn includes the "full text" of Lou Gehrig's farewell speech at Yankee Stadium (which includes thanks for a "'Waldorf' Wardrobe Trunk with vulcanized fiber binding and built-in shoe pockets!") and an alternate version of the Alcoholics Anonymous 12 steps, complete with consideration of Dolores Del Rio as a "power greater than ourselves." Throughout, Dunn references one obscure fictional book after another, from Ringleader: A Life in Circus Management, with a Foreword by the Bastard Ringling Brother "Skippy" to a collection of letters sent to a urologist, Confessions to a Pee Pee Doctor.

Ibid's humor, an odd mix of Monty Pythonesque potty jokes and highbrow political and literary satire, may not be for everyone. But Dunn's deft contortion of the usual elements of storytelling into this odd formal experiment proves to be a perfect showcase for his unique wit and intellect. Ibid may not be the Great American Novel, but it is certainly the cleverest American endnotes ever to see print. --Patrick O'Kelley

(retrieved from Amazon Fri, 24 Apr 2009 07:58:24 -0400)

The first test round has been closed. Visit the Open Shelves Classification group for details.

Quick Links

Ebooks Audio Swap
1 pay1/48

Popular covers

 

Help/FAQs | About | Privacy/Terms | Blog | Contact | LibraryThing.com | APIs | WikiThing | Common Knowledge | 46,386,184 books!