

|
Loading... Lord John and the Private Matter (2003)by Diana Gabaldon (Author)
None. Maybe it’s a case of bad writing, bad galleys, of bad narration or, any combination (or all) of the above, but there were several problems with this audiobook. A perfect example is the scene in which the Catholic widow and the Protestant mistress of a deceased soldier are arguing over the funeral rites. In the scene as delivered, the Catholic woman believes that her husband has been consigned irrevocably to Hell while the Protestant woman believes that her lover’s soul is in Purgatory, able to be helped by intercessionary prayers. Either DG got her dogmas mixed up; the typesetter separated lines that should have come from the same person (“pronoun trouble”) or, JW cast the wrong voices. Even after listening to the scene three times over, I could not decipher what went wrong. Later on in the book, the protagonist ruminates on the Catholic idea of purgatory, believing that as intercessionary prayers can assist the soul in limbo, so too can results from the departed person’s actions can have repercussions that would promote or demote the same soul. While I’m no theologian, I have been a Catholic for a long time, and I’m pretty sure that is NOT how it works! This little bit of theological misinformation I lay squarely at DG’s feet. JW’s character voices were sometimes sloppy: He sometimes lost the accent of the character he was reading and often lost the delineation between characters in dialogue. At other times, JW didn’t drop into “parenthetical voice” to indicate that the character was thinking rather than actually speaking, which made dialogues in the book difficult to negotiate. Just unnecessary. And one of those mystery novels where you don't care about the mystery. 4.5 stars I wasn't sure exactly what to expect with Lord John and the Private Matter. I had read two of Gabaldon's Outlander novels, but I wasn't sure what to expect with Lord John. Turns out it was a historical mystery with Lord John trying to solve a murder of a presumed traitor as well as discover the truth about his cousin's intended. Gabaldon creates an amazingly detailed world of eighteenth century London demonstrating the amount of research done to create the setting of this story. Plus she introduces the secret world that existed amongst this London as Lord John in drawn deeper into his investigation. Lord John is a well developed character that is far from perfect but definitely has the best intentions at heart. The introduction of Tom as John's valet added not just to the story but to the development of the John character as well. Overall this was a great read that kept me guessing, and I plan on reading Lord John's next adventure. no reviews | add a review
References to this work on external resources.
|
Google Books — Loading...Popular coversRatingAverage: (3.42)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Lord John is NOT Jaime, and there's no Claire in there either... Still interesting story, and nice to learn a little more about Lord John. However, I'm only reading these because I'm in Outlander-withdrawal. (