This was by far the least liked book I've read of Wanda's books. The only reason I finished the book was in hopes of it getting better! Very sorry to say, it never really did get better. Maybe it was because I set it up so HIGH for being a good book before it came out. I'm not for sure, but I was sorry it wasn't better. ( )

Up to this point, my only experience with the stories from Wanda Brunstetter has been the Sisters of Holmes County series. To be honest I must admit that I was not a fan of that series. Overall, I have heard wonderful things about the Amish fiction from Wanda Brunstetter. Starting this book, I came in with mixed feeling and expectations from the things that I have heard and felt myself. In the end, I was pleasantly pleased.

"White Christmas Pie" is a good holiday or anytime of the year read. It is a story of hurt and misconceptions. Feelings that are harbored in one's heart will affect other pieces of their life and this is a story of about finding answers and peace. There are going to be various things in our lies that will prompt questions that will receive no answer.

As Christians, it is an important part of life to forgive and forget when necessary no matter how difficult and even without all the facts. God has a plan for our lives and he knows best. Each day, live to the fullest for him and do not remain caught up in pain. ( )

Wanda Brunstetter
Barbour Publishing
ISBN: 978-1597899376
Reviewed by Rita Goatley for ReviewYourBook.com
5 stars
Another beautiful Amish romance…

One of my favorite things about Wanda Brunstetter’s books is the description of the Amish way of life and beliefs. Even though I do not live that life style, I admire their commitment and dedication. We can all learn much from the Amish.

Will Anderson was left with an Amish family 16 years ago. Originally, it was a temporary situation. His mother passed away, and his father needed to get on his feet. Due to some on foreseen situations, his father did not return for him. Will was contemplating marriage to an Amish girl. Feelings of abandonment plague him. Unexpectedly, his father came back into his life. It was at a time when Will needed him. Truth and faith brings peace to Will. ( )

Although my grandparents lived in Pennsylvania, and I have often visited there and seen the Amish riding in their horse and buggy, I never have read an Amish Christian Fiction book before this one. I knew that Wanda E. Brunstetter has a reputation of being an expert on Amish literature, and so I looked forward to this new experience. I'm glad I had the opportunity. This is a lovely Christmas time story.

In this romance novel, I learned a good bit about the Plain People. Will Henderson, the protagonist, is a well-developed character who is engaged to marry Karen Yoder. He was abandoned as a young six-year-old and wrestles with repressed hostility and jealous rages which he controls by shutting down and walking away. But can this be good for an engagement? I found the plot slowing down in the middle, but the end was satisfying.

A dessert, White Christmas Pie, is an important ingredient in the story and is referred to often. There is a copy of the recipe for that I can't wait to try. White Christmas Pie might become a Christmas tradition at my house. For fans of Wanda E. Brunstetter's writing, this will be an enjoyable one for you.

Your Tags: christmas, christian fiction, amish, pennsylvania, indiana ( )

Written by: Wanda E. Brunstetter
Published by: Barbour
Reviewed by: Stephanie Rollins for ReviewYourBook.com 11/2008
ISBN: 978-1-59789-937-6
“Not up to par” 3 stars
It is no secret that I think Wanda Brunstetter is amazing. I am saddened to have to give this book a 3. Imagine my excitement—a Wanda Brunstetter book with a Christmas theme!
I never connected with the characters. This may be the first time when some much emphasis was placed on the male character—Will. Perhaps, that is a reason for my disconnect. Regardless, I never cared about the plot. Her books are always a bit predictable, but this one was so obvious from the beginning.
Do not let this keep you from Brunstetter’s other works. This one is just not up to par. ( )