|
Loading... The Lost Millennium: History's Timetables Under Siegeby Florin Diacu
LibraryThing recommendationsMember recommendationsLoading...
won't like
will probably not like
will probably like
will like
will love Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. The book puts out a provocative hypothesis: that history has somehow miscounted, and our past is actually 1,000 years shorter than we thought. Unfortunately, the author seems to spend as much time undermining the hypothesis as exploring it. If the idea is so stupid, why write a book? If there's merit to it, the book did it a grave disservice. At the heart of it, the book had glimmers of potential, but was overall very disappointing. At least it was short. ( )This book examines the ideas of a controversial Russian mathematician, Anatoli Fomenko, who argues that traditional calculations of ancient and medieval world history are incorrect, by as much as 1000 years. Arguments are brought forward from celestial mechanics, radiocarbon dating, and historical chronology, to suggest that our calendar is wrong, perhaps by a great many years. Maybe "the Middle Ages never happened"? Steve (my husband who is a scientist) found the book to be interesting, but not convincing. Most of the theories are coming from non-historians, and none of the evidence is complete or water-tight. The author is a mathematician, and he cites the work of a Russian mathematician and other scientists, who are working outside their fields with this theory that traditional historical accounts are wrong. Still it's an interesting challenge to historians to re-examine their accepted wisdom, and prove the accuracy or errors in these claims. no reviews | add a review
Amazon.com Product Description (ISBN 0676976573, Hardcover)Have you ever wondered how we really know what year it is? Part detective story, part conspiracy theory, part scientific history, The Lost Millennium explores the astonishing possibility that our calendar is out by a thousand years.A chance conversation at a conference in Mexico started mathematician Florin Diacu on an amazing journey to make sense of one of the strangest — and if true, most revolutionary — theories you’ll ever encounter. To understand how scientists could be sceptical about what year it is, Florin Diacu explores the fascinating history of chronology — from Egyptian horoscopes to the work of Isaac Newton, with cameos by Voltaire and Edmund Halley — making the startling discovery that our calendar is far from ironclad. It all depends, rather, on the dating of ancient events — about which there is real controversy. At once accessible and profound, The Lost Millennium examines the arguments of present-day chronological revisionists such as the Russian scholar Anatoli Fomenko, who claims that our system of dating is horribly askew. Fomenko cites evidence from ancient astronomy, linguistics and cartography, and a crucial manuscript by Ptolemy, staking his scientific prestige on a theory so controversial that it will change the way you think about time, history and the calendar on your wall. The field has also inspired its share of now-discredited cranks, such as Immanuel Velikovsky, a media celebrity of the 1950s. His notorious book Worlds in Collision argued that biblical events are incorrectly dated. Beautifully written and peopled with fascinating characters from past and present, The Lost Millennium is essential reading for anyone who believes they’re living in the year 2005. (retrieved from Amazon Fri, 24 Apr 2009 07:58:04 -0400) The first test round has been closed. Visit the Open Shelves Classification group for details. |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||