This is some of Miller's finest work. If you love Batman, there's no comic that makes him more the hero than this one. Or gives him a harder time. The world is so against Batman, you begin to wonder if he isn't the villain. But for Miller there's no doubt Batman is the only thread of justice the world is clinging to. Be warned, this will paint your other favorite heroes in a negative light, if it even bothers to mention them. But if you look past that, you are in for a great ride. ( )

Batman comes out of retirement, older, weaker, and more tortured, but still capable of taking on Gotham City's criminals. Over the course of the four books in the novel, Batman meets up with Harvey Two-Face, the Joker, a new Robing, and *drumroll please* Superman. And through it all the public is still engaged in a neverending battle discussing whether Batman is a hero or a villain. I'm not sure even Batman himself knows the answer to that question.

I loved it. I enjoyed this new twist on the Batman character. Always a bit darker than his "superhero" counterparts, Batman's dark side and his mental anguish are given free reign in Miller's adaptation of the Batman icon. The inclusion of Superman into the mix was a nice foil, helping the reader to see Batman as the black sheep among his kind, but one who is doing what's necessary to help society. That has always been a theme within the series, then and now, in novels and film: Batman is whatever Gotham City needs him to be. As always, James Gordon is my favorite character. He had a decent sized role in this story with his retirement and thoughts on his replacement as well as a short and nice action sequence.

On the down side, there were a few times where the repetition got to me. All four stories had numerous lines on how Batman was getting old and tired, and all four included none-too-small segments showing the media debate over the necessity, sanity, and morality of Batman. Now and then I was thinking "yeah, I get it already". But overall, those two annoyances did function as literary devices within the text, foreshadowing events mainly. Despite the downside, this was an excellent novel and I highly recommend reading it. ( )

I know that pretty much everyone raves about how awesome these comics are, but I just didn't like them. It took me forever to read this collection, and I never got into the story. Maybe if I'd read more Batman comics I'd think this was awesome. ( )

Another great adventure, and apparently Miller’s first Batman ever. It was a great read and but perfect in how different it was compared to what I expected.

This specific graphic novel focuses on Gotham City after Batman has been missing or inactive for over 10 years. He’s now growing older but crime is continuing to rise dramatically and Batman is faced with having to choose whether to intervene. Commissioner Gordon is also reaching his prime and handing down his title to someone new, who can’t wait to rid the world of Batman.

It was a great read, very interesting and I look forward to others in the future.

The comic that changed comics. Frank Miller upped the ante for all super hero stories that have followed proving that comics aren't just for kid. The supercool badass Batman we love today? Thank Frank. Worthy of all the hype and praise. ( )