Valentina and Julia are mirror twins who live with their parents in Chicago. Their mother Edie is also a twin and when her estranged twin sister Elspeth dies, she leaves her London flat to Valentina and Julia on the condition that her sister Edie and her husband never enter it. The girls move to London to live in the flat and get to know the other residents of the building.

I really liked the first three-fourths of this book. Like The Time Traveler's Wife there are elements of science fiction but somehow they seem believable. The characters are well-developed and if not always likeable, intriguing. Martin, the upstairs neighbor with OCD, was my favorite character. The last fourth of the book was disappointing. It felt rushed and the very ending was particularly unsatisfying - it felt like the author just gave up. ( )

Loved the Time Traveler's Wife and while her new book is well written the plot wanders and the characters are never really convincing. The TTW was an intriguing read but this book never engages sufficiently with the characters who tend to be cardboard-like with little depth. Having said that there were some intriguing twists and because the writing is good I finished the book. I think the book's storyline needed a lot more editing. Had it been the first book of hers I had read I doubt I would look forward to her next. ( )

I usually experience a vague feeling of foreboding when twins are introduced into the story line of a book I'm reading; something in the back of my head whispers, "This can't end well." I guess I've seen too many popular movies featuring the good twin/evil twin trope or -- worse yet -- two evil twins who use their interchangeability to commit murderous deceptions (Jeremy Irons' dual role in Dead Ringers still has me shaking in my boots).

That being said, Niffenegger's initial introduction of Julia and Valentina, the twins in her newest novel, set me at ease. The girls live contentedly with their parents in a normal Chicago suburb. They've graduated from high school, but they're taking their time leaving the nest; it's too easy to sleep in, browse a fashion magazine or two, and slap together a PB&J sandwich for lunch to become overly zealous about college or a career. Their social life is somewhat stunted due to their close relationship, but they don't much care; there's plenty of time to work out the interpersonal logistics of dating in the future, and they're never lonely because they have each other.

The cozy predictability of daily suburban life is abruptly turned on its head when a letter arrives from England, addressed to "Julia and Valentina Poole." The girls' mother, Edie, was also a twin, and her estranged twin sister, Elspeth Noblin, has died a tragically premature death from cancer. Surprisingly, Elspeth has bequeathed her apartment, located in a historical home bordering the stone fence of Highgate Cemetery in London, to her two nieces, conditioned upon a peculiar prerequisite: The twins must live in the house for a full year, during which time their parents cannot visit or enter the house.

An important wrinkle to the story must be added here: Elspeth is dead, but not quite. She has slowly begun to materialize, ectoplasm-like, in her former apartment. Some of the most engaging passages of the book involve her gradual familiarization with her evolving "body," her attempts at mobility (she can't leave her apartment), and her desperate efforts to communicate with her former lover, Robert, who lives one floor down and makes frequent "grieving visits" to her bedroom. She contracts into a misty ball and sleeps in a cozy drawer of her writing desk when she's exhausted herself with attempts to push doors closed and puff pieces of paper across table tops. Unable to communicate with Robert, she must content herself with watching him interact with her nieces as they enjoy their new life.

So far, this may sound like a light-hearted romp of a novel (think "Blythe Spirit"), but things turn dark from here on out. The twins seem basically normal, but Niffenegger informs the reader that despite their age, Julia and Valentina still enjoy dressing identically alike, and they sleep in the same bed (spoon-style, no less). It's also clear that Julia is the increasingly stronger twin of the two, both mentally and physically. Elspeth slowly becomes more adept at making her presence known, and she's not ready to relinquish Robert. Add a budding romance, kittens that die and skitter back to life, eccentric neighbors, and the ever-present spell of Highgate Cemetery and its not-so-sleeping occupants, and you have the makings of a great contemporary ghost tale.

You may think you've figured out the plot, but you haven't. Niffenegger fills the last third of the book with unexpected twists and turns that will keep you guessing. There is one strained plot device that is patently implausible -- you'll know it when when you encounter it -- but the book is a must-read for lovers of gothic mysteries and readers who would enjoy learning the fascinating history of Highgate Cemetery (you'll feel like you've taken a personal tour of its mossy paths and ivy-covered crypts by the time you finish the book).

Once again the writer does not disappoint. a clever book with some nice historical flavor about one of my favorite places....Highgate Cemetery. there were a few surprises...and some points that were predicable. but for the most part a great read. if they make this into a movie (and they should) it would be better to not ruin it like they did the first book. keep this film dark...it is a sad and dark story and that is what works! ( )

http://girlsjustreading.blogspot.com/... ( )