|
Loading... Black Holeby Charles Burns
LibraryThing recommendationsMember recommendationsLoading...
won't like
will probably not like
will probably like
will like
will love Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book. Burns manages to pack disease, teen angst and isolation, love, sex and high school all into one gorgeous, stark graphic novel. It evokes the lonely feeling of adolescence beautifully, and the art itself is amazing to look at. It manages to be both tender and creepy at the same time, and the layers of story and art are blended together seamlessly. I don't really know what to say about this one. It was interesting, with both the good and bad connotations of the word implied. Burns uses disease & mutation as a metaphor for teen angst, alienation, and growing pains. Although the book post-dates the AIDS crisis, it is set in the 1970s & so aptly evokes the time that one forgets that its not a foreshadowing of the 1980s reactions to HIV-AIDS. Striking contrast, shifting narrator, with a cold, dark black hole at the heart of the story. - last frame “I’d stay out here forever if I could”” Well, reading the Avengers book and then this after Understanding Comics definitely helped me realize how much more craft went into this one. In particular, I'm afraid that whenever I read comics from now on I'll be obsessively checking the panel transitions. Oh well. This is a freaky story about a sexually-transmitted disease in 1970's Seattle that is turning kids into shambling monstrosities who live out in the woods, and how they feel about that. It hits all the angles you want it to hit - changing bodies, self-loathing, taking control of your own life - and would come across as a kind of combination Anastasia novel/Young Werther/That '70s Show if it weren't for the total weirdness of what's happening. The disease manages to be disturbing without being horrific, and it made me wish Burns had treated it a bit (a bit) more realistically - like, I get that this is a psychological story about teens, and the disease is just an externalization of their confusions and fears and the oh-so-jaded, used-up feeling that only a 17-year-old who's done some drugs in an unwise manner and been involved in ill-considered sexual practices and had to get up to a filthy house and wished they could go home to mother knows. (God, it's nice to be a grownup. You go from "Nobody knows the trouble I've seen" to "Everybody knows, so let's speak of pleasant things.") Anyway, I got into this, and that's why I wished Burns had given us some more background, made the disease and the world more realistic - not, like CDC men, but a bit of explanation. But I understand wh that might have compromised the mental realityof the images and the weirdness, and that's a more interesting reality anyway, and so I am content. Also, I really like how the first thing any teen does in these stories when they get happy or sad or, like, gassy or whatever is to go straight to the beach or the forest. We here on the west coast have a powerful ally in keeping ourselves spiritually fed - that being nature, of course - and I suspect that our consumption of pharmaceutical mood stabilizers lags correspondingly. Cascadia! Although I've found Charles Burns' graphic style to be somewhat unappealing in other contexts, there's no denying that Black Hole is a triumph both in terms of its visual and narrative storytelling aspects. Burns weaves a highly dramatic (yet realistic) portrait of teenage angst, with an invocation of a specific locale that rings true - as a current Seattle resident, I find that his method of depicting local weather and topography is easily recognizable, even when delivered in necessarily small doses. I do find that the overall story is somewhat weakened by a series of murders that enter into the proceedings fairly late in the game. This additional dramatic element distracts from the otherwise strong metaphorical plot that Burns delivers, and steals away some of the powerful outcomes that derive from the core of this tale, which is the strange but all-too-familiar world of teenage doubt and alienation. What is so effective is the use of a mysterious disfiguring disease as a symbol for all of the tormented feelings of these characters - in this device alone Burns has achieved something deep, believable, and highly original. 0.101 seconds to build listing no reviews | add a review
Amazon.com (ISBN 037542380X, Hardcover)The first issues of Charles Burns's comics series Black Hole began appearing in 1995, and long before it was completed a decade later, readers and fellow artists were speaking of it in tones of awe and comparing it to recent classics of the form like Chris Ware's Jimmy Corrigan and Daniel Clowes's Ghost World. Burns is the sort of meticulous, uncompromising artist whom other artists speak of with envy and reverence, and we asked Ware and Clowes to comment on their admiration for Black Hole:
Questions for Charles Burns
(retrieved from Amazon Fri, 24 Apr 2009 07:58:04 -0400) The first test round has been closed. Visit the Open Shelves Classification group for details. |
Abebooks |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||