Picture of author.

Gerhard Herm (1931–2014)

Author of The Celts: The People Who Came Out of the Darkness

27+ Works 1,197 Members 6 Reviews

About the Author

Works by Gerhard Herm

Der Aufstieg des Hauses Habsburg (1988) — Author — 11 copies
I bizantini (1982) 9 copies
Karl der Große (1987) 9 copies
Der Assassine (2000) 5 copies
Die Welt der Diadochen (2005) 3 copies

Associated Works

Götter, Sklaven und Orakel. Antike Mordgeschichten (2001) — Contributor — 2 copies

Tagged

Common Knowledge

Canonical name
Herm, Gerhard
Birthdate
1931-04-26
Date of death
2014-03-09
Gender
male
Nationality
Germany
Birthplace
Crailsheim, Baden-Württemberg, Deutschland
Place of death
Ottobrunn, Bavaria, Germany
Occupations
novelist
journalist

Members

Reviews

I read this a long time ago in a galaxy far away. My first vision of the celts, and this book set the stage for my way of looking at the Dorian Greeks, who were probably celts.
 
Flagged
wickenden | 5 other reviews | Mar 8, 2021 |
TL;DR: Outdated at this point, and clearly written by an enthusiastic amateur, not a specialist. Find a more recent work by an actual expert. I recommend Barry Cunliffe.



So-so. This book clearly has its strengths, but each is muddled (or perhaps cancelled out?) by what I see as some pretty serious flaws. For one, Herm offers an ok large-scale overview of what was known about the Celts, their migrations and their interactions with the Mediterranean world -- back in the seventies. That's fine and dandy, but the intervening forty-odd years have made this book increasingly less reliable, and a similar but more recent book should be preferred.

Secondly, Herm is no historian, but a journalist, and it shows. Herm is at his best when he talks about individual excavations and specific locations: as long as he can rely on archeologists and historians and linguists to guide him through the facts, he's an engaging summarizer. (I found the section on the oppidum at Manching particularly memorable). Where Herm goes off the rails sometimes, in my view, is in linking the large-scale, macro level with the micro-level: I encountered several questionable conclusions and enthusiastic extrapolations that a real historian would be much more careful about. Case in point: at one point the author broaches the topic of Atlantis, and whether it might have been real, and for a few pages he gets lost in speculations about conspiracy theories and cranks' pet theories. He also quotes approvingly a source claiming that all Indo-European peoples are Russians because their putative homeland near the Black Sea lies in 1970s Soviet Russia. Perhaps it's the journalistic training in him that wants to balance a credentialled specialist with a maverick crank or an attention-grabbing soundbite, but I don't think that such silliness should merit inclusion. And finally: I think he is too uncritically accepting of 18th-20th-century claims of Celtic revivalism, taking them too much at face value.

I feel that this book is now too dated to be of much use, and that a specialist would have done a better job of drawing mid-level conclusions. Its strengths are covered in other, more recent books, that do not suffer from these flaws. Check out Barry Cunliffe: he's an archeologist who's also a great science communicator.
… (more)
½
 
Flagged
Petroglyph | 5 other reviews | Nov 2, 2018 |
A chronological event of the Celts from the time they first encountered Roman armies in Italy to the coming of Caesar to the campaigns advancing into England and Ireland to the acceptance of Christianity to the arising of the King Arthur legend due to William of Normandy's defeat on Harold of England in the battle of the Hastings. The book overall was interesting in parts and slow in others. If nothing else it gave me an appreciation of my heritage. From the beginning they were barbarians with their ragged hair, painted bodies, and unduly tactics of war that drove their enemy into fright at first sight. They had an over imaginative superstition to the spirit world in so much that they kept the heads of their victims and decorated their homes, including making drinking vessels out of the skulls, believing that they would protect them. The adoption of Christianity began to tame them to some extent but their ingenious fallacy continued forth in the devising of the Grail and the legend of King Arthur which continues to influence people today.… (more)
1 vote
Flagged
vibrantminds | 5 other reviews | Jul 5, 2010 |
Extensive overview of the origins of Celtic Tribes and their migration through Europe to the British Isles Well written and readable style of writing. Assumes no real previous knowledge of the subject.
 
Flagged
sprowett | 5 other reviews | May 17, 2008 |

Lists

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

Statistics

Works
27
Also by
1
Members
1,197
Popularity
#21,452
Rating
½ 3.4
Reviews
6
ISBNs
63
Languages
8

Charts & Graphs