Author picture

Patricia Morrisroe

Author of Mapplethorpe: A Biography

5 Works 472 Members 51 Reviews

About the Author

Includes the name: Patricia Morrisoe

Works by Patricia Morrisroe

Tagged

Common Knowledge

Birthdate
1951
Gender
female

Members

Reviews

About Beethoven and his dedication of the Moonlight Sonata to a 16 year old student of his (later to become his lover?), Giulietta Guicciardi. Most of the book, however, centered on Giulietta and not Beethoven. I like historical fiction with real characters, places, situations, etc. This book had all of that. However, the writing was not as good nor the story as interesting as some I have read; the titles I can not remember! 380 pages
½
 
Flagged
Tess_W | 2 other reviews | Aug 9, 2022 |
When Julie Guicciardi meets Beethoven, she is instantly enthralled by his intensity and eccentricities. Under the guise of taking piano lessons, she finds a way to be close to him. Naturally, she begins to fall head over heels for him, and finds herself taking risks that could destroy her life.

Although this book started strong, it really seemed to bog down in the middle. I don't know that there was enough going on between the two to keep me interested. In reality, it seems that Julie pined for Beethoven, while he moved on to other lovers. Overall, not a book I would reread or recommend.… (more)
 
Flagged
JanaRose1 | 2 other reviews | Nov 30, 2020 |
In one of the all-time most famous works of classical music (The “Moonlight” Sonata), Beethoven cryptically dedicates the tune to a Countess Guilietta Guicciardi, whom he taught piano to. Julie, as Morrisroe re-nicknames her, did not leave behind much in history, but as detailed in the Author’s Note, she likely had some form of romantic relationship with the Ludwig van Beethoven. Morrisroe imagines this relationship and Julie’s life as a whole in this work of historical fiction.

Morrisroe imagines Julie’s life as active. She married. She had children. She had affairs. She was a spy. She nurtured the enigmatic Beethoven. She was present for Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony. The author bases as much of this as possible on the historical record, but details of the plot twists are her own reckoning.

I found tracking Julie’s life somewhat interesting, but also somewhat lacking. It saddened me that this character was not permitted the freedoms to express herself fully in her contemporary society. The plot also seemed somewhat contrived, but did fit the facts of history accurately. My intrigue did not build substantially until the Third Part in which Beethoven’s character transformed from a mere difficult genius into three-dimensional human being. I wish I would have seen more of this humanity earlier in the book as a reason that Julie first fell in love with him.

Nonetheless, Beethoven’s humanity and Julie’s nurturing play an interesting role in the unfolding of Beethoven’s masterful Ninth Symphony. Morrisroe herself presents this story with beauty. With care, she sets the psychological conflicts that led to the symphony, the staging of the presentation, the scandal of combining orchestra with chorus, and the buzz around the event. By itself, this description makes the book most reading. One can see why Julie was so dedicated to Ludwig – and why Ludwig in turn cared for her so much.

Overall, this work courageously presents the speculative inner life of Beethoven. It also depicts the cultural life of Europeans in the early 1800s. One gets the sense that the class of nobles governed with debauchery (and also gets a hint of why Americans so detested the European incestuous ruling classes). As with most historical fiction, this book does a good job of bringing a few historical facts to life. At the very least, the reader can listen to Beethoven’s Moonlight Sonata in a new light. Even more, the reader can recapture some of the romantic buzz that was prevalent in Beethoven and Julie’s day.
… (more)
 
Flagged
scottjpearson | 2 other reviews | Aug 10, 2020 |
Robert Mapplethorpe was an anomaly. A sometimes mediocre photographer with a keen eye for disrupting scenes through being a punk, sometimes shaking things up in ways that nobody else had done before him.

He seems also to have been a parasite, a racist, a nice guy, brutal and a relentless self-serving publicity-machine.

So, what draws people to Mapplethorpe? Is it because of his images of people, especially the sexually toned ones? His near-marriage with Patti Smith while living with her for seven years? Anything else? Probably the sex-related pictures, and the American trials for obscenity charges that followed after Mapplethorpe's death due to AIDS in 1989.

Mapplethorpe was a shining example of "niceness" until he left the military academy where his parents had sent him to become "a man".

"Robert was a little too intense and conservative for me. He was almost the stereotypic 'good boy.' "
-Nancy Nemeth, ROTC Military Ball Queen, 1964


Mapplethorpe dropped out, moved, dabbled with drugs and blew into the art world with Patti Smith, with whom he lived for seven years.

Discovering his homosexuality, which he hid from his parents for his entire life, was key. Then, interlocked with religion, pain, sex and discovering photography, everything changed. He found Sam Wagstaff, his sugar daddy and main curator, who made his career lift.

The following quote from this book seems to expose a lot about Mapplethorpe:

At the beginning of the semester Mapplethorpe had moved from the apartment on Willoughby Avenue to a ground-floor studio on DeKalb Avenue, which he shared with a pet monkey named Scratch. Of all the stories connected to the photographer, the monkey saga remains one of the strangest. He had purchased the animal from a Brooklyn pet store, where the owner had given him a discount because the monkey was already an adult. The owner failed to tell Mapplethorpe that Scratch wasn't housebroken, and while Mapplethorpe made a few feeble attempts at training Scratch, he pronounced the monkey "uncontrollable" and gave it the run of the apartment. The studio was soon covered in urine and feces, and when friends first came to visit they were rendered speechless by the squalor and by Scratch's habit of entertaining Mapplethorpe by masturbating in front of him.

Scratch's brief and bizarre history encapsulated many of the major themes of Mapplethorpe's adult life - his preoccupation with images of death and violence; his fascination with the devil; his desire to transform the ugly, or freakish, into works of beauty. It also pointed to a darker side of his nature, which would later emerge in his sexual relationships with other men - a need to break all the rules and transgress taboos.


He seemed almost like an utter misfit version of Truman Capote: a social butterfly who used his subjects to his own benefit, not for anything else; his models often spoke of feeling used in a bad way.

Due to a highly promiscuous lifestyle without the use of condoms - and also due to Mapplethorpe's liking of coprophagy - he was often ill, and finally was hit with AIDS, which he denied having until the bitter end.

"Robert was really running away," Myers explained. "He was so angry I kept waiting for him to explode."

And explode he did, by rampaging through the gay bars to pick up black men. Mapplethorpe had confided to several friends that he blamed a black man for infecting him with the AIDS virus, but given his boast of having had sex with an estimated thousand men, he couldn't possibly know for sure. Still, he approached his task like an avenging angel, picking up one black man after another with offers of cocaine, then baiting them with the word "nigger." One man screamed at him to stop, but when Mapplethorpe still kept repeating the word, the man grabbed his clothes and ran out the door. "You're evil," the man shouted, in parting. "Evil!"


Also:

Mapplethorpe's racism intensified with the progression of his disease, and Kelly Edey, who had presumably heard everything, was so startled by Mapplethorpe's venomous comments that he noted one incident in his diary. Mapplethorpe was standing outside Keller's on the evening of August 2 when he suddenly began to shout, "This is the sleaziest corner in New York. How can it be that I'm standing here in the midst of all this human garbage? They're so stupid, every last one of them is so unbelievably stupid." And yet he kept returning to Keller's, hoping his demigod might rise from the debris. "A lot of people yelled at him for continuing to go to the bars," Mark Isaacson explained. "But he looked at it, like, well, that's their problem - if they're not protecting themselves, why should I worry about it? When Robert first got sick, I said to him, 'You've got to stop your old lifestyle,' and he said to me, 'If I have to change my lifestyle, I don't want to live.'"


This book is the result of a massive amount of work, collected, analysed and edited over five years. The author has first and foremost interviewed Robert Mapplethorpe, and then Patti Smith, on a lot of details. This book sprawls, uncovers a lot of details - if you believe them to be true - and unveils a lot more than Smith's own book about her life with Mapplethorpe, "Just Kids".

Morrisroe has interviewed Mapplethorpe's family, friends, lovers, dealers (both in art and drugs), socialites, colleagues and fans.

At the very end of his life, Mapplethorpe mustered enough energy to see a Warhol exhibition, having outlived his former idol by a couple of years:

[...] he stayed for two hours while Tom Peterman wheeled him past Warhol's celebrity icons - the Ten Lizes, the Gold Marilyn, the Silver Marlon, the Red Elvis, the Sixteen Jackies. Peterman found the whole event distasteful, for clearly Mapplethorpe was yesterday's story, and by fame's mercurial standards he had outlived his moment. But to Peterman's surprise, Mapplethorpe didn't seem to notice.


The last show he went to was his own, where he sold loads of his photographs. Surrounded by people he didn't know he called shots from a chair while hooked up to medical equipment, "floating on air", and then, collapsing and vomiting. That might be the final word on Mapplethorpe's persona in every single way, Patti Smith exempt.

All in all, the start of this book was a bit slow for me, a bit of dragging its heels, but then it got off to its real start, just as Mapplethorpe started to find himself during his latter teen years. It's a grand tale of a maladjusted man who wanted to live forever. Pissing nearly everybody off with everything he did must amount to something, right?
… (more)
 
Flagged
pivic | 2 other reviews | Mar 20, 2020 |

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

Angela Dawe Narrator

Statistics

Works
5
Members
472
Popularity
#52,190
Rating
½ 3.7
Reviews
51
ISBNs
21
Languages
4

Charts & Graphs