Picture of author.
23+ Works 211 Members 21 Reviews 1 Favorited

About the Author

Gillian Polack is a writer, editor, historian and critic based at the Australian National University. Her main research interests are cultural development and transmission in both the Middle Ages and the contemporary period. She has published several novels and seventeen short stories and has show more edited two anthologies. One of her stories won a Victorian Ministry of the Arts award and three more have been listed as recommended reading in the international lists of world's best fantasy and science fiction short stories. Her non-fiction includes work on historiography, the Middle Ages, Arthurian studies and literature. show less

Series

Works by Gillian Polack

Associated Works

Nevertheless, She Persisted: A Book View Café Anthology (2017) — Contributor — 47 copies
Other Covenants: Alternate Histories of the Jewish People (2020) — Contributor — 17 copies
Subterranean Magazine, Issue #4 (Spring 2006) (2006) — Contributor — 12 copies
It Happened at the Ball (2018) — Contributor — 10 copies
Next (2013) — Contributor — 2 copies
Lace and Blade 5 (2019) — Contributor — 1 copy

Tagged

Common Knowledge

Members

Reviews

This is an academic text for a field that I'm not in, and thus I was expecting some amount of difficulty getting through. It has taken me many months to read, and it was very helpful that each chapter is quite short, and that the topics discussed were carefully introduced and expanded upon.

However, this desperately needed a better edit than it got. Stray punctuation, repetition of phrases where it didn't make sense (ie. sentences that felt like they'd been half re-written, after part of the idea was moved earlier in the chapter). Polack acknowledges that there were multiple events that interfered with the production of this book, and my guess would be that print deadlines won out over robust editing.

I hope that this will become a foundational work on a topic that isn't widely written about, if at all. There are sections where Polack only has their previous work to point at, acknowledging that the scholarship just isn't there. Which must be frustrating as the writer--as it is as the reader--because the value of this kind of work for me is in the dialogue amongst and between the experts, which couldn't happen.
… (more)
½
 
Flagged
fred_mouse | May 10, 2024 |
I feel that this is one of those books that I will come back to and appreciate something new in it each time. On the first read-through, the one I have just completed, I felt most drawn to Rhonda's story. I felt an affinity with her, and I spent most of the book sure that it would turn out that all her online friends would be other screennames of her own. The fact that they didn't speaks to Gillian's ability to challenge her readers' expectations, and it's only one example of how she does.

I really liked how matter-of-fact the usage of magic was throughout the book. It went so well with how matter-of-fact everything was: there wasn't a whole lot of infodumping about the characters' backstories; everything just came out organically. It seems like that's something basic that any book should provide, but unlike some books I've read I never had a sense of frustration that I didn't know enough about the characters to understand what was going on.

There is just so much gentle wisdom in this book that I know I'll be rereading it more than once.
… (more)
 
Flagged
LaurenThemself | 1 other review | Feb 20, 2024 |
There are some really interesting ideas in this story -- about fantasy places, and how we inhabit them vs our 'real' lives. And I liked bits of it. But for some reason it didn't all gel into an enjoyable whole. I think that I was missing some aspect of it, reading from the wrong viewpoint. I really didn't understand what the ending did, or how it worked.

It didn't help that I didn't particularly like any of the characters, because that is often the most important part of a story for me. I can enjoy and understand a story where I don't get the characters, but there has to be something else to fill that space in.… (more)
 
Flagged
fred_mouse | Jan 2, 2024 |

Lists

Awards

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

Maxine McArthur Contributor
Laura E Goodin Contributor
Monica Carroll Contributor
Simon Petrie Contributor
Yaritji Green Contributor
Jennifer Fallon Contributor
Tessa Kum Contributor
Janeen Webb Contributor
Simon Brown Contributor
K. J. Bishop Contributor
Kaaron Warren Contributor
Jack Dann Contributor
Deborah Biancotti Contributor
Lucy Sussex Contributor
Andrew J McKiernan Contributor
Cat Sheely Contributor
Doug Fry Contributor
Ariella Adler Contributor
Shauna O'Meara Contributor
Matthew Sini Contributor
Phillip Berrie Contributor
Anne Mok Contributor
Kylie Bullivant Contributor
Ross C. Hamilton Contributor
Marcus Olsson Contributor
Joanne Anderton Contributor
Jacob Edwards Contributor
Amelia Walker Contributor
Justin Thomas Contributor
Valerie YL Toh Contributor
Graham Storrs Contributor
Jason Fischer Contributor
Nicole R Murphy Contributor
Cat Sparks Contributor
Donna Maree Hanson Contributor
Astrid Cooper Contributor
Mik Bennett Contributor
R. J. Astruc Contributor
Richard Harland Contributor
Chris Jones Contributor
Megan Tones Contributor

Statistics

Works
23
Also by
7
Members
211
Popularity
#105,256
Rating
3.8
Reviews
21
ISBNs
36
Favorited
1

Charts & Graphs