Author picture
3+ Works 327 Members 6 Reviews

Works by Don Robins

Associated Works

Tagged

Common Knowledge

There is no Common Knowledge data for this author yet. You can help.

Members

Reviews

I read this book a few years ago so have consulted notes made at the time:

This was a follow on from the BBC documentary 'The Body in the Bog'. Interesting but I could only go so far with the conclusions which in a lot of places took theory/speculation and treated it as established fact. In fact someone wrote a review that pretty much sums up what I thought along those lines - target="_top">https://www.amazon.com/review/R33VAG5RSKIT0R/ref=cm_cr_dp_title/183-9137747-6337....… (more)
 
Flagged
kitsune_reader | 5 other reviews | Nov 23, 2023 |
The life and death of a Druid prince is the story of the Lindow man who was found in a peat bog in the early 1980's; other bodies were found in the same location and all were at least 1000 years old or more. The authors, Anne Ross and Don Robins, both experts in Celtic England and the Druids, have taken the bare "bones" of the story and hypothesized the rest. All we really know from the remains found is that he was a relatively healthy male in his 20s wearing nothing but an armband. He was brutally killed, using torture devices, and his last meal was identified. Ross and Robins have gone beyond the facts to posit a story about a Druid priest or other high ranking official from Ireland named Llovernio who came to England during the dark time when the Romans battled the Celts in Britain. Through a retelling of ancient history as well as a multitude of maps, the authors make their case. I believe it is a well crafted story, not fact.

In addition to the maps and the many illustrations, there is a bibliography and index. The text is not footnoted, as it would have been if this were a serious scholarly work. The bibliography has many books of interest listed, all published before 1989. There are many newer articles and books including a recent one by The British Museum. If you want to know the real facts about the Lindow man, you need to read more than this book.
… (more)
½
1 vote
Flagged
fdholt | 5 other reviews | Aug 13, 2019 |
In 1984, peat cutters on Lindow Moss (about 15 miles south of Manchester) came up with a human leg along with the peat. Which must have been disconcerting. The local police were called in, and after some examination and probing around some more remains were found. Interestingly, the body was, in fact, a murder victim – he’d been garroted (the noose was still around his neck), bashed on the head hard enough to fracture his skull, and had his throat cut – somebody really wanted him dead – but the murder was committed in the first century AD.


The gentlemen picked up the name “Lindow Man” and is currently entertaining visitors in the British Museum.


The Life and Death of a Druid Prince purports to be the story of Lindow Man, but stretches the evidence way beyond what it justifies. The authors claim to know Lindow Man’s name (Lovernios), his ethnic origins (Irish), the exact date of his death (April 30, 61 AD) and why he was killed (as a human sacrifice to placate Celtic gods and persuade them to intervene against the Roman conquest).


None of the authors’ arguments for each step of their theory is particularly farfetched – for example, Lindow Man was naked except for a fox fur armband and “Lovernios” means “fox” in Gaulish Celtic – but the odds of stringing together so many hypotheses to make a theory like this is vanishingly small, even if each individual hypothesis is fairly likely. Some of the data collected is quite interesting – the possibly survival of various Celtic rituals into recent times as folk traditions, for example – and the simple facts about Lindlow Man – height, weight, facial reconstruction, gut contents, etc. – are worth reading. The rest of it, however, reads like the authors had suddenly begun channeling Eric von Daniken.
… (more)
 
Flagged
setnahkt | 5 other reviews | Dec 21, 2017 |
Here is a book that will give the reader a good feel for what the Roman invasion of Britain was like to the Celtic inhabitants of the island at the time. Most of the information is (admittedly) taken from Tacitus' historical essays, but there is also a lot of Celtic info derived from archaeological sources. Plus the reader gets to see what bog bodies are about and how they are handled. What arcanophile could ask for more?
1 vote
Flagged
Farree | 5 other reviews | Dec 25, 2014 |

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

Statistics

Works
3
Also by
1
Members
327
Popularity
#72,482
Rating
½ 3.7
Reviews
6
ISBNs
7
Languages
1

Charts & Graphs