A Literary/Fiction Game

TalkThe Green Dragon

Join LibraryThing to post.

A Literary/Fiction Game

This topic is currently marked as "dormant"—the last message is more than 90 days old. You can revive it by posting a reply.

1MrsLee
Aug 6, 2016, 5:26 pm

This is quite the time-eater, but it was a fun exercise for a Saturday morning. I would love to read other folks versions.

Select 12 favorite characters from fiction, any fiction, and answer the questions about their interactions. Some hints from my experience; it helps if they are a mix of male/female and good/evil. Also, don’t read the questions before you make your list.

1. The Doctor (Doctor Who)
2. Archie Goodwin (Nero Wolfe mysteries by Rex Stout)
3. Flavia de Luce (mysteries by Alan Bradley)
4. Harry Dresden (Dresden Files by Jim Butcher)
5. Lt. Nyota Uhura (Star Trek)
6. Arrietty (The Borrowers by Mary Norton)
7. Wolverine (X-men)
8. Samwise Gamgee (Lord of the Rings)
9. Aragorn, son of Arathorn (Lord of the Rings)
10. Dame Frevisse (mysteries by Margaret Frazer)
11. Scout (To Kill a Mockingbird)
12. Precious Ramotswe (No.1 Ladies Detective Agency)

1. Who would make a better college professor, 6 or 11? (Arrietty or Scout) Let’s see, both children, and yet I suspect both have more common sense than many college students these days. That was mean. I’m sorry. My grumpy old woman syndrome is showing. I choose Arrietty. It would be difficult for a 6” tall person to hold the attention of an auditorium, let alone project their voice, but with modern video and sound equipment it could be done. What would she teach? “How not to let your Limitations Limit your Life.”

2. Do you think that 2 would win the “Cutest Guy of the Year”? (Archie Goodwin) Absolutely, although I have no clear picture in my head of what he looks like.

3. 12 sends 8 out on a mission. What is it? Does it succeed? (12.Mma Ramotswe, 8.Samwise Gamgee) The mission is to stay with Note Makoti until he finds her special rooibus tea. “Don't you leave him Samwise Gamgee.” And I don't mean to.” Of course it succeeds.

4. What is or would be 9's favorite book? (Aragorn) Although he has all the books of Elven lore at his fingertips, I’m pretty sure he loves to read “There and Back Again, a Hobbit’s Tale” by Bilbo Baggins

5. Would it make more sense for 2 to swear fealty to 6, or the other way around? (2. Archie Goodwin, 6. Arrietty) Complicated. Archie is used to being the sidekick to a genius, and he can be quite the chauvinist, yet is chivalrous in his own way. He is more worldly-wise than Arrietty. Still, I think he would feel bound to protect and serve her due to his upbringing, the fact that she is female, and 6” or less tall. She would adore Archie and if he allowed it, would love to live in his desk so long as Wolfe didn’t find out.

6. For some reason, 5 is looking for a roommate. Should (s)he share a studio apartment with 9 or 10? (5.Lt. Uhura, 9.Aragorn, 10. Dame Frevisse) This is a poser. Aragorn and Uhura would make an awesome couple. However, if she is still involved with Mr. Spock, perhaps Dame Frevisse would be the better choice. Frevisse would be a great roommate. She is quiet, understanding, and keeps to her schedule, when people aren’t being murdered.

7. 2, 7, and 12 have dinner together. Where do they go, and what do they discuss? (2.Archie, 7. Wolverine, 12. Mma Ramotswe) Well, if anyone could keep Archie from being murdered by Wolverine, it would be Mma Ramotswe. They would all enjoy a quality steak house, or perhaps Ethiopian cuisine would do? It would be a stretch for Archie, but he could manage with aplomb I think. Mma Ramotswe would have to lead the conversation, probably about her childhood. If Archie were to talk much, Wolverine would end him.

8. 3 challenges 10 to a duel. What happens? (3. Flavia de Luce, 10. Dame Frevisse) This would have to be a duel of words, because Dame Frevisse would not participate otherwise. Flavia would precociously expound in her juvenile genius way on science and the marvels of chemistry, etc. and why that absolves us from any moral obligations. Then Dame Frevisse would say something quiet, in a gentle way, but absolutely devastatingly demolish all the conflated arguments Flavia had put forth.

9. If 1 stole 8's most precious possession, how would she/he get it back? (1. The Doctor, 8. Samwise Gamgee) Samwise’s most precious possession of course is his friend, Frodo Baggins; if a friend can be said to be a possession. As to how he would get Frodo back, I suppose that depends on whether Frodo had destroyed the ring yet or not. If he had not, and the Doctor stole Frodo to keep him from taking over Middle Earth or being destroyed by the ring and Sauron in the attempt (I’m sure the Doctor could travel to a place just as likely to destroy the ring as Mt. Doom), then Sam would find a way to follow and make sure Frodo was okay; clinging to the outside of the TARDIS if he had to. If on the other hand, Frodo had already destroyed the ring, and the Doctor merely came to offer him a change of pace before he headed into the West, then Samwise might let him go because of needing to get on with life with Rosie and understanding there was not much more he could do for his friend.

10. Suggest a title for a story in which 7 and 12 both attain what they most desire. (7.Wolverine, 12. Mma Ramotswe) “The Cow and the Wolverine” Precious dreams of a cattle ranch, Wolverine dreams of death, but apart from that, of anonymity. This story would have him enjoying a quiet life managing Mma’s cattle ranch in Botswana.

11. What kind of plot device would you use if you wanted 4 and 1 to work together? (4. Harry Dresden, 1. The Doctor) No plot devise needed. I would love to see Harry Dresden as the next companion for the Doctor! Think of the villains! Think how much worse things could always get before they saved everyone in the end! Think of the manic energy and the wise-cracks!

12. If 7 visited you for the weekend, how would you get along? (7. Wolverine) I can’t write this. I’m happily married and I want to stay that way.

13. If you could command 3 to perform any one task or service for you, what would it be? (3.Flavia de Luce) Hmmm, she’s not very good at following commands. I would ask her to find a cure for cancer.

14. If 12 had to choose sides between 4 and 5, which would it be? (12. Mma Ramotswe, 4. Harry Dresden, 5. Lt. Nyota Uhura) Mma would find a way to bring everyone together so that choosing sides was unnecessary. Then they would have tea.

15. What might 10 shout while charging into battle? (10.Dame Frevisse) I’m sure she would have an appropriate litany for the situation, although I don’t know what it is.

16. If you chose a song to represent 8, which song would you choose? (8. Samwise Gamgee) I Will Take You Home by Ed Sheeran. His song “Firefly” seems like a song Samwise would write for Rosie. Have I mentioned that I love Ed Sheeran’s songs?

17. 1, 6, and 12 are having dim sum at a Chinese restaurant. There is only one scallion pancake left, and they all reach for it at the same time. Who gets to eat it? (1. The Doctor, 6. Arrietty, 12. Mma Ramotswe) This isn’t a Christmas dinner, right? Because the Doctor doesn’t do Christmas dinners. Mma Romotswe would insist that the Doctor have it, but she would also mention that he could cut off a tiny bit for Arrietty; after all, a small bite would be a meal for her.

18. What might be a good pick-up line for 2 to use on 10? (2. Archie Goodwin, 10. Dame Frevisse) Hah! As good as Archie is at pick-up lines, there isn’t one in the world that she wouldn’t see through. She would love the Puck in Archie though and might very well enlist him to help her solve murders.
19. What would 5 most likely be arrested for? (5.Lt. Uhura) Trying to get one of her crewmates out of a jam and getting caught up in their shenanigans is the only thing I can imagine.

20. What is 6's secret? (Arrietty) That she converses with normal sized humans.

21. If 11 and 9 were racing to a destination, who would get there first? (11. Scout, 9. Aragorn) Aragorn would never leave Scout behind. He would probably make it look like she won.

22. If you had to walk home through a bad neighborhood late at night, would you feel safer in the company of 7 or 8? (7.Wolverine, 8. Samwise) Sorry Sam, it’s Wolverine every time, but you can come with us.

23. 1 (The Doctor) and 9 (Aragorn) reluctantly team up to save the world from the threat posed by 4's (Harry Dresden) sinister secret organization. 11 (Scout) volunteers to help them, but it is later discovered that s/he is actually a spy for 4 (Harry). Meanwhile, 4 (Harry) has kidnapped 12 (Mma Ramotswe) in an attempt to force their surrender. Following the wise advice of 5 (Lt. Uhura), they seek out 3 (Flavia de Luce), who gives them what they need to complete their quest. What title would you give this fic? Space,Time and the Natural order of Things versus Mad Faerie Magic. Of course the plot twist is that Harry would be secretly working against his sinister secret organization all along.

2Bookmarque
Aug 6, 2016, 7:21 pm

That was weirdly fun. I lost a little steam at the end, but here goes!

1. Zaphod Beeblebrox (President of the Galaxy, Hitchhiker’s Guide)
2. Virgil Flowers (cop, Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension)
3. Cass Neary (washed-up photographer, drug addict, thief)
4. Elvis Cole (The World’s Greatest Detective, Vietnam vet)
5. Philip Marlowe (ex-cop, now the hardest of boiled Private Eyes)
6. Milady de Winter (arch villain from The Three Musketeers)
7. Amelia Peabody (feminist, amateur detective & Egyptologist)
8. The Black Stallion (race horse, awesome stud)
9. Erik (The Phantom of the Opera)
10. Tom Ripley (sociopath, thief)
11. Bridget Jones (modern woman trying to lose a few and win a few)
12. Mrs. Danvers (psycho, housekeeper extraordinaire)

Who would make the better college professor, 6 or 11? Well Bridget would probably have her TA teach a lot of the classes since she’d probably be hung over or having a crisis so you’d probably make an easy A. Milady de Winter on the other hand would be perfect for Villainy 101 and who thinks that won’t be helpful in life?

Do you think 2 would win “Cutest Guy of the Year”? That fucking Flowers? Sure thing. Just ask his ex-wives.

12 sends 8 out on a mission. What is it? Does it Succeed? Mrs. Danvers would send The Black away from Manderly to look for clues to Rebecca’s death. He being a horse can only paw the earth, whinney, and run really really fast, so he’d probably fail tremendously and Danvers would take out her vengeance by fixing his next race so he would come in dead last.

What is or would be 9’s favorite book? Greta Garbo: A Life Apart

Would it make more sense for 2 to swear fealty to 6 or the other way around? Virgil would never swear loyalty to Milady de Winter because he’s a stand up guy and Davenport would kick his ass. Milady, on the other hand, would definitely swear, but would have her fingers crossed behind her back.

For some reason 5 is looking for a roommate. Should s/he share a studio apartment with 9 or 11? Marlowe should share with The Phantom of the Opera for sure since he’d spend all his time trying to build a lake in the basement and Marlowe could have the place to himself. Bridget would be the wrong dame for him since she would probably want him to spend all his time following Mr. Darcy to see if he likes her.

2, 7 and 12 have dinner together. Where would they go, and what would they discuss? Virgil would probably insist on going to a cowboy bar where he could dance. Amelia Peabody would probably lecture Mrs. Danvers on her lack of scruples, but would admire her single-minded focus and ability to think on her feet.

3 challenges 10 to a duel. What happens? Cass Neary would probably show up stoned or drunk and Tom Ripley would coerce some dupe to take his place and would the poor idiot would end up dead because drunk or not, Cass is a mean one.

If 1 stole 8’s most precious possession, how would s/he get it back? The Black’s most precious possession is probably Alec, since the kid feeds him. Zaphod would probably try to get Alec into the Total Perspective Vortex, just to see what would happen. But The Black would go to Ford Prefect who does have a bit of mind-meld ability with animals (just remember the deer) and would immediately understand the predicament. He’d distract Zaphod with tickets to Disaster Area, but slip him a Pan Galactic Gargle Blaster instead. The Black would ride in, rescue Alec and hit Milliways.

Suggest a title for a story in which 7 and 12 achieve what the both most desire. The Curse of the Scuttled Boat

What kind of a plot device would you use if you wanted 4 and 1 to work together? Zaphod would need to remember something that was locked off in that portion of his brain that he locked off. He’d need to hire Elvis Cole to find out if he could pick it.

If 7 visited you for the weekend, how would you get along? We’d get along great! Amelia Peabody could teach me all about Egyptology and how to seem like you’re acquiescing to your husband’s ideas, when they were really yours all along. I’d help her select some great new jeans and boots to wear in the desert that are practical and that Emerson will die for.

If you could command 3 to perform any task or service for you, what would it be? Cass Neary could help me put together a decent black and white darkroom set up.

If you had to choose sides between 4 and 5, which would it be? Oh no fair, Elvis Cole is a modern-day Philip Marlowe.

What might 10 shout when charging into battle? Tom Ripley probably wouldn’t shout at all. He’d be back at base camp impersonating an officer.

What song would you choose to represent 8? For The Black Stallion? The theme to Chariots of Fire! Can’t you just see it?

1, 6 and 12 are having dim sum at a Chinese Restaurant. There is only one scallion pancake left, they all reach for it at the same time. Who gets it? Zaphod gets it because he has 3 arms. Danvers and Milady, alas, only have two each.

What might be a good pick up line for 2 to use on 10? Virgil Flowers and Tom Ripley? I really can’t see this happening?

What would 5 most likely be arrested for? Marlowe would be arrested for hiding evidence and lying to the police.

What is 6’s secret? That she (Milady de Winter) has a son more evil than she is.

If 11 and 9 were racing to a destination, who would get there first? Oh Bridget would beat The Phantom for sure since she doesn’t have to wear a mask, a cape or have to stick to the underground.

If you had to walk through a bad neighborhood late at night, who would you feel safer in the company of, 7 or 8? The Black while great at kicking and biting, famously won’t let anyone but Alec ride him, so while he might run faster, I’ll take Amelia Peabody and that parasol of hers.

1 and 9 reluctantly team up to save the world from 4’s sinister organization. 11 volunteers to help them, but is discovered to be a spy for 4. Meanwhile 4 has kidnapped 12 to force their surrender. Following the wise advice of 5, they seek out 3 who gives them what they need to complete their quest. What title would you give this book?

Zaphod and TPOTO team. Elvis Cole head of sinister organization, Bridget spy. Marlowe advises and Cass helps. Title is Double Exposure.

3Bookmarque
Aug 6, 2016, 7:35 pm

Oh and I love how both of our most precious possessions are people.

4MrsLee
Aug 7, 2016, 1:18 pm

I was a little dismayed at how hard it was for me to think of favorite female characters. It's not that I have none, but they are far outweighed by males. Not sure if that is my preference, or the fact that females aren't being portrayed in likable ways. Probably both I'm guessing. I may be more particular about what I like in females than in males.

5LibraryPerilous
Aug 7, 2016, 4:28 pm

This is fun! Thanks for posting, @MrsLee.

1) Ludmilla (If on a winter's night a traveler)
2) Uriah Heep (David Copperfield; my favorite villain that I love to hate)
3) Beth Lambert (Philip Hall likes me. I reckon maybe.; Hurrah for smart girls everywhere!)
4) Kate Sutton (The Perilous Gard: I'm half Kate and half The Lady in the Green)
5) Brother Cadfael
6) Sherlock Holmes
7) Frodo
8) Death (Pratchett's Reaper, I mean)
9) Raptor Red
10) Grendel (esp. the Gardner version)
11) Medea
12) Lizzie Bennet (actually, Persuasion is my favorite Austen, but I relate more to Lizzie)

Who would make a better college professor, 6 or 11? 6: Holmes

Do you think that 2 would win the “Cutest Guy of the Year”? God, I hope no one's taste would be that poor. He's a true slime.

12 sends 8 out on a mission. What is it? Does it succeed? Lizzie entrusts Death to despatch Wickham and give Lady Catherine de Bourgh a genteel fright. Death complies but Lydia falls in love with him. Lizzie is exasperated.

What is or would be 9's favorite book? One does not have time to read when one is trying to survive and raise one's family during the Cretaceous Period.

Would it make more sense for 2 to swear fealty to 6, or the other way around? Uriah Heep in the Baker Street Irregulars? But one suspects his connections to the London Underworld would be invaluable. Perhaps he's already a member of Moriarty's web?

For some reason, 5 is looking for a roommate. Should (s)he share a studio apartment with 9 or 10? 10. If anyone can help Grendel find peace after his accident, may it be Cadfael.

2, 7, and 12 have dinner together. Where do they go, and what do they discuss? They're in Frodo's cozy hobbit hole, pre-ring intrigue. Uriah Heep sneers throughout and Lizzie spends all dinner making cutting remarks about his greasy hair. Frodo eats supper and dinner before the meal ends.

3 challenges 10 to a duel. What happens? 3 outsmarts 10 in five seconds flat.

If 1 stole 8's most precious possession, how would she/he get it back? I think this might be the duel where Death meets his match. Ludmilla would just hide Death's humanity inside book after book. Death would be distracted by all the wonderful stories. & so on and so on ad infinitum.

Suggest a title for a story in which 7 and 12 both attain what they most desire. The Constant Shire, or, Femme Coverture Overruled.

What kind of plot device would you use if you wanted 4 and 1 to work together? Well, this is a perfect pairing. One could picture Ludmilla daydreaming while reading in bed about Kate's adventures and then willing herself into the story itself, where Kate would welcome a kindred spirit.

If 7 visited you for the weekend, how would you get along? Quite cheerfully, but I would be too full to move after a weekend of eating like a hobbit. NB: I did this for a day while watching the LoTR films. Can confirm: I couldn't move afterwards.

If you could command 3 to perform any one task or service for you, what would it be? Stay curious and never apologize for being a girl with a brain.

If 12 had to choose sides between 4 and 5, which would it be? Probably Cadfael would be indulging Kate, and Lizzie would approve, so I doubt the three would fight.

What might 10 shout while charging into battle? "Grrr ... Rawr ... Stop singing you drunken fools!"

If you chose a song to represent 8, which song would you choose? "Don't Fear the Reaper"

1, 6, and 12 are having dim sum at a Chinese restaurant. There is only one scallion pancake left, and they all reach for it at the same time. Who gets to eat it? They divide it into thirds at Holmes' behest.

What might be a good pick-up line for 2 to use on 10? "You complete me." To which, of course, dear Grendel would reply, "“The world is all pointless accident... I exist, nothing else.” Who needs a smarmy two-bit villain when you're a prehistoric monster?

What is 6's secret? That he more than admires Irene Adler.

If 11 and 9 were racing to a destination, who would get there first? Medea, by hook or by crook and with whatever trickery she required. Raptor would only join the race if she sensed danger or prey.

If you had to walk home through a bad neighborhood late at night, would you feel safer in the company of 7 or 8? Skipping this question, as I'm not a fan of the 'bad neighborhood' motif in general.

1 and 9 reluctantly team up to save the world from the threat posed by 4's sinister secret organization. 11 volunteers to help them, but it is later discovered that s/he is actually a spy for 4. Meanwhile, 4 has kidnapped 12 in an attempt to force their surrender. Following the wise advice of 5 they seek out 3, who gives them what they need to complete their quest. What title would you give this fic? The Lady in the Green's Revenge: Foiled by a Clever Girl and Her Best Frenemy

Hmm ... it's interesting that my cast of favorite characters is not very diverse. Must remedy that.

6MrsLee
Aug 7, 2016, 5:03 pm

>5 LibraryPerilous: Glad you enjoyed it! I also found that it shone a light on my preferences and am still digesting what that means.

7zjakkelien
Aug 9, 2016, 3:12 am

I also really like it! I'm working on my own version. I have the reverse 'problem', most of my favorite characters are female. I wonder if it was always like that. I think it's only in the last years that I pay more attention to female representation in what I read...

8LibraryPerilous
Aug 9, 2016, 9:20 am

>7 zjakkelien: Looking forward to your female-heavy list!

Re: paying more attention: I'm reentering my books here on LT (manual entry ftw!), and I'm surprised at how few books by women—especially women of color—and books in translation I've read. It's eye-opening to realize that one's reading doesn't reflect one's personal creeds as much as one thinks.

We also won't talk about the inordinate amounts of fluff I've consumed over the years ...

9SylviaC
Aug 10, 2016, 1:11 am

That took a long time! It was hard to narrow it down to 12 characters. I tried to stay with characters from books that are reasonably well known.

1) Helva (human/spaceship from The Ship Who Sang by Anne McCaffrey)
2) Lord Peter Wimsey
3) The Wife of Bath
4) Harry Crewe/Harimad (heroine of The Blue Sword by Robin McKinley)
5) Dr Chef (doctor and chef in The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet by Becky Chambers)
6) Bad Kitty (from the Bad Kitty books by Nick Bruel)
7) Captain Haddock (from the Tintin books)
8) Keith Stewart (quiet, competent engineer in Trustee from the Toolroom by Nevil Shute)
9) Elfrida Phipps (retired actress from Winter Solstice by Rosamunde Pilcher)
10) Joey Bettany (Chalet School heroine)
11) Jack Staple (my favourite Heyer hero, from The Toll-Gate)
12) Triffids

1. Who would make a better college professor, 6 or 11? I can't see either one of them settling down into the confines of a lecture hall, but Jack Staple would certainly be more coherent than Bad Kitty.

2. Do you think that 2 would win the “Cutest Guy of the Year”? I swear, I didn't look ahead at the questions! Anyone who knows me should know that I would absolutely select Lord Peter as Cutest Guy of any year!

3. 12 sends 8 out on a mission. What is it? Does it succeed? Any mission that Keith Stewart undertakes is bound to succeed. I really don't see why the triffids would need anyone to take on a mission for them, though. They are quite capable of world domination on their own.

4. What is or would be 9's favorite book? Elfrida would like Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day, about a woman who reaches out to grab life with both hands before it passes her by.

5. Would it make more sense for 2 to swear fealty to 6, or the other way around? Lord Peter would swear fealty to the King, his mother, or Harriet, but not to Bad Kitty. Bad Kitty wouldn't swear fealty to anyone. Ever. So it wouldn't make sense either way.

6. For some reason, 5 is looking for a roommate. Should (s)he share a studio apartment with 9 or 10? Dr Chef would be happy living with either Elfrida or Joey. Both are thin, so he would have a reasonable amount of space to move around in a studio apartment. Both women are sociable, so wouldn't mind that he talks so much. Jo would want more privacy for writing, though, so Elfrida would probably be the better choice.

7. 2, 7, and 12 have dinner together. Where do they go, and what do they discuss? Lord Peter Wimsey, Captain Haddock, and the triffids would go to a bar with a patio. They will discuss military service, liquor, and gardening.

8. 3 challenges 10 to a duel. What happens? When the Wife of Bath challenges Joey Bettany to a duel, Joey will accept, because she can't resist a challenge. This will prove to be a mistake, because she is no match for the WoB. Joey may be quick-witted, but the WoB is far more robust, with a natural instinct for attacking her opponent's weak points.

9. If 1 stole 8's most precious possession, how would she/he get it back? Keith Stewart would meet a trillionaire who would be so impressed with Keith's resourcefulness and determination that he would lend him a spaceship to chance Helva through the galaxy.

10. Suggest a title for a story in which 7 (Captain Haddock) and 12 (Triffids) both attain what they most desire. Green Rackham's Apocalypse: A Tale of Rum and Guts

11. What kind of plot device would you use if you wanted 4 and 1 to work together? To get Helva and Harry together, we would have to find a way to meld science fiction and fantasy together. Perhaps Harry would have to travel the universe in Helva, to collect the greatest magical beings from distant galaxies, in order to finally defeat the Evil emanating from the North.

12. If 7 visited you for the weekend, how would you get along? I would enjoy listening to Captain Haddock's stories, but I would probably go to bed early, and leave him to his drinking. The cursing would remind me of my father.

13. If you could command 3 (Wife of Bath) to perform any one task or service for you, what would it be? Marital advice???

14. If 12 had to choose sides between 4 and 5, which would it be? The triffids would choose Dr Chef. Harimad's land of mountains and desert wouldn't give them much scope, but Dr Chef could help them colonize the universe. Or he might cook them.

15. What might 10 shout while charging into battle? Joey would shout, "Buck up, girls! It'll be a jolly scrum!"

16. If you chose a song to represent 8, which song would you choose? The MacGyver theme would represent Keith Stewart.

17. 1, 6, and 12 are having dim sum at a Chinese restaurant. There is only one scallion pancake left, and they all reach for it at the same time. Who gets to eat it? Helva doesn't eat, so it comes down to a close contest between Bad Kitty and the triffid. Bad Kitty wins by a hair. But then the triffid gets Bad Kitty. Then Helva gets the triffid with a blast from her engine.

18. What might be a good pick-up line for 2 to use on 10? Lord Peter simply would not use a pickup line on a schoolgirl. His tastes are much more mature.

19. What would 5 most likely be arrested for? Dr Chef might get arrested for genocide.

20. What is 6's secret? Bad Kitty has a soft spot, hidden deep, deep inside.

21. If 11 and 9 were racing to a destination, who would get there first? Jack Staple would get there way faster than Elfrida, even if he's on a horse while she's driving a car. But, being a gentleman, he would stop to let her catch up at the last minute.

22. If you had to walk home through a bad neighborhood late at night, would you feel safer in the company of 7 or 8? Keith is more resourceful than Captain Haddock, and sober to boot.

23. 1 (Helva) and 9 (Elfrida) reluctantly team up to save the world from the threat posed by 4's (Harry's) sinister secret organization. 11 (Jack) volunteers to help them, but it is later discovered that s/he is actually a spy for 4 (Harry) . Meanwhile, 4 (Harry) has kidnapped 12 (Triffids) in an attempt to force their surrender. Following the wise advice of 5 (Dr Chef), they seek out 3 (the Wife of Bath), who gives them what they need to complete their quest. What title would you give this fic? The Wife of Bath's Guide to Gardening for Fun and Profit, the sequel to the bestselling The Wife of Bath's Guide to Marrying for Fun and Profit.

10Jarandel
Edited: Aug 10, 2016, 2:20 am

01 Estraven (The Left Hand of Darkness by Ursula K. Le Guin)
02 Royina Ista (Paladin of Souls by Lois McMaster Bujold)
03 Tatzel (Lyonesse by Jack Vance)
04 Raven (Shadows Linger by Glen Cook)
05 Katherine Talbert (The Privilege of the Sword by Ellen Kushner)
06 Ajrarn (Tales of the Flat Earth by Tanith Lee )
07 Tavis (The Winged Histories by Sofia Samatar)
08 Piter de Vries (Dune by Frank Herbert)
09 Tenar (Earthsea by Ursula K. Le Guin)
10 Anomander Rake (Malazan Book of the Fallen by Steven Erikson)
11 Bellis Coldwine (The Scar by China Miéville)
12 Benjamin January (A Free Man of Color & seq. by Barbara Hambly)

1. Who would make a better college professor (Bellis Coldwine, Ajrarn)
Bellis, as she's an academic. Ajrarn might be much more fascinating but rather unreliable and not safe at all…

2. Do you think that 2 would win the “Cutest Guy of the Year”? (Ista)
If it's open to a cross-dressing lady a bit on the mature side, she may.

3. 12 sends 8 out on a mission. What is it? Does it succeed?
Benjamin sends Piter in an infiltration mission in some high society dwelling to recover proof of misdeeds. He could succeed, no one will ever notice he was there, but there's a good chance he'd stab the do-gooder two-bit detective who tries to order him around instead.

4. What is or would be 9's favorite book? (Tenar)
During her time in the Tombs of Atuan : an atlas of Earthsea, but she wasn't allowed to know there was a world out there.

5. Would it make more sense for 2 to swear fealty to 6, or the other way around? (Ista & Ajrarn)
Hmm, let's see, a saintly dowager queen and a demon-lord. Nah, nope. By the time Ajrarn grows more palatable he has no care to give for anyone's allegiance.

6. For some reason, 5 is looking for a roommate. Should (s)he share a studio apartment with 9 or 10? (Katherine & Tenar/Anomander)
Tenar's company will be a lot more liveable. Anomander might be to die for, but he has other weightier concerns, and the vicinity of Dragnipur can't be comfortable for anyone.

7. 2, 7, and 12 have dinner together. Where do they go, and what do they discuss? (Ista, Tavis, Benjamin)
Tavis invites the other two to share dinner with her and her love, and they discuss everyone's deeds, and hope for a better world less ravaged by greed and prejudice.

8. 3 challenges 10 to a duel. What happens? (Tatzel, Anomander Rake)
Tatzel is full of spunk, but ends up suspended in the air without having landed a scratch by the much taller and stronger elf who didn't even unsheath his sword, and will let her hang and struggle until she calms down somewhat.

9. If 1 stole 8's most precious possession, how would she/he get it back? (Estraven, Piter de Vries)
Years of torture, with intermittent exploration of Gethenian physiology and anatomy, the Dr. Mengele has nothing on him.

10. Suggest a title for a story in which 7 and 12 both attain what they most desire. (Tavis, Benjamin)
We slew the Dragon, its name was hate and greed.

11. What kind of plot device would you use if you wanted 4 and 1 to work together? (Estraven, Raven)
Definitely some time-travelling portal between worlds to begin with.

12. If 7 visited you for the weekend, how would you get along? (Benjamin)
I'd like him I think, but my daily concerns are very far from his own and thankfully considerably lighter.

13. If you could command 3 to perform any one task or service for you, what would it be? (Tatzel)
She wouldn't listen to me.

14. If 12 had to choose sides between 4 and 5, which would it be? (Benjamin, Raven, Katherine)
I don't know why Raven and Katherine would be fighting, maybe Raven wants her to impersonate a second White Rose to confuse their foes and she'd rather go under her own identity. Benjamin would probably try to convince her of the necessity of cooperating with Raven and the resistance against the Empire of Evil.

15. What might 10 shout while charging into battle? (Anomander)
The sound of over 6 feet of Dragnipur dragged out of the scabbard and groaning awake. Or a dragon's bellow.

16. If you chose a song to represent 8, which song would you choose? (Piter de Vries)
Metallica – Master of Puppets

17. 1, 6, and 12 are having dim sum at a Chinese restaurant. There is only one scallion pancake left, and they all reach for it at the same time. Who gets to eat it? (Estraven, Ajrarn, Benjamin)
Probably Ajrarn, the other two are more polite, and prudent enough not to let a demon-lord go hungry…

18. What might be a good pick-up line for 2 to use on 10? (Ista, Anomander)
Two old warriors can share a fire.

19. What would 5 most likely be arrested for ? (Katherine)
Cross-dressing. Pulling her sword on a fool. Puncturing the fool with it if he still didn't desist.

20. What is 6's secret? (Ajrarn)
That demons can fall as hard as angels.

21. If 11 and 9 were racing to a destination, who would get there first? (Tenar, Bellis)
Tenar I think, she probably gets more exercise on a daily basis.

22. If you had to walk home through a bad neighborhood late at night, would you feel safer in the company of 7 or 8? (Tavis, Piter)
Tavis because she is a warrior, and the other is probably more dangerous than anything else that may be in said neighbourhood.

23. 1 (Estraven) and 9 (Tenar) reluctantly team up to save the world from the threat posed by 4's (Raven) sinister secret organization. 11 (Bellis Coldwine) volunteers to help them, but it is later discovered that s/he is actually a spy for 4. Meanwhile, 4 has kidnapped 12 (Benjamin January) in an attempt to force their surrender. Following the wise advice of 5 (Katherine Talbert), they seek out 3 (Tatzel), who gives them what they need to complete their quest. What title would you give this fic ?
The Necromancer's downfall at the hands of some very determined ladies (and an hermaphrodite).

11aquascum
Aug 10, 2016, 4:49 am

Er... I have a couple of tv/movie dears, but they are fictional, yes?

1 Boromir
2 Sharpe
3 Alec Trevelyan (006)
4 Odysseus
5 Dimidov (Soldiers of Fortune)
6 Vimes
7 Spike (Buffy)
8 Faramir
9 Hagen von Tronje
10 Cthulhu
11 Lister (Red Dwarf)
12 Hiro Protagonist

1. Who would make a better college professor, 6 or 11
... oh dear... have to go with 6, Vimes, but he'd fight tooth and nail and do excursions to the Shades...

2. Do you think that 2 would win the “Cutest Guy of the Year”?
DEFINITELY. And not just 'cutest guy, Sharpe would win 'Most Desirable Male'!

3. 12 sends 8 out on a mission. What is it? Does it succeed?
Hiro sends Faramir on a war against the viral infection of hipsteritis. Relentless battle brings success!

4. What is or would be 9's favorite book?
Ilias, but I don't think Hagen von Tronje was able to read

5. Would it make more sense for 2 to swear fealty to 6, or the other way around?
Hm... Sharpe and Vimes... that would depend entirely on which stage of their careers each of them is at. Both possible.

6. For some reason, 5 is looking for a roommate. Should (s)he share a studio apartment with 9 or 10?
Dimidov should move in with Tronje! Rooming with Cthulhu is bad for ones health!

7. 2, 7, and 12 have dinner together. Where do they go, and what do they discuss?
... that's Sharpe, Spike and Hiro... they go to the Bronze and talk about their heroines, dead and alive ;)

8. 3 challenges 10 to a duel. What happens?
Er... sorry Alec... 006 dies an insane death, Cthulhu means terminal loss of both sanity and health points.

9. If 1 stole 8's most precious possession, how would she/he get it back?
??? Boromir stealing Faramir's most precious possession? No way.

10. Suggest a title for a story in which 7 and 12 both attain what they most desire.
*pets Spike and Hiro* Sidekick no more

11. What kind of plot device would you use if you wanted 4 and 1 to work together?
No plot device needed, I think Boromir and Odysseus would have no problem working together. Their job descriptions aren't that different ;) Hm, well, a war would help...

12. If 7 visited you for the weekend, how would you get along?
Spike visiting for the weekend? Well, he'd drag my CD collection down to the basement and pretend to eat my guinea pigs, but no problem! We'd have a grand time! Go to a concert/festival, watch movies, night drives... have fun!

13. If you could command 3 to perform any one task or service for you, what would it be?
Task for 006? can't answer, gets way too political

14. If 12 had to choose sides between 4 and 5, which would it be?
Hm... I think Hiro would side with Dimidov... not sure Hiro would be on a king's side of a conflict

15. What might 10 shout while charging into battle?
FHTAGN!

16. If you chose a song to represent 8, which song would you choose?
Death In Fire by Amon Amarth, sorry 'bout that Faramir

17. 1, 6, and 12 are having dim sum at a Chinese restaurant. There is only one scallion pancake left, and they all reach for it at the same time. Who gets to eat it?
Hiro ;) neither Boromir nor Vimes are that keen on speciality food

18. What might be a good pick-up line for 2 to use on 10?
None! Sharpe, no hitting on Elder Gods! Just be happy you got out of the battle of Trafalgar alive and let slepping cosmic horrors rest!

19. What would 5 most likely be arrested for?
Weeell... blowing up a competitor's ship with a rocket launcher would be... piracy?

20. What is 6's secret?
Vimes secret? That he's actually quite happy with his station in life by the end of the series

21. If 11 and 9 were racing to a destination, who would get there first?
Hagen, hands down. There is no end to the detours Lister would take ;)

22. If you had to walk home through a bad neighborhood late at night, would you feel safer in the company of 7 or 8?
Oh, I would be safe with either of them! Faramir would capture/disable anyone who set a foot wrong, Spike would eat them or get us invited for drinks and poker...

23. 1 and 9 reluctantly team up to save the world from the threat posed by 4's sinister secret organization. 11 volunteers to help them, but it is later discovered that s/he is actually a spy for 4. Meanwhile, 4 has kidnapped 12 in an attempt to force their surrender. Following the wise advice of 5, they seek out 3, who gives them what they need to complete their quest. What title would you give this fic?

Errrr... Boromir and Hagen von Tronje reluctantly team up to save the world from the threat posed by Odysseus' sinister secret organization. Lister volunteers to help them, but it is later discovered that he is actually a spy for Odysseus. Meanwhile, Odysseus has kidnapped Hiro Protagonist in an attempt to force their surrender. Following the wise advice of Dimidov, they seek out Alec Trevelyan, who gives them what they need to complete their quest. What title would you give this fic?
Error 666. Does.not.compute.

12zjakkelien
Edited: Aug 10, 2016, 4:42 pm

Wow, this took me a while! Now I can finally read other people's lists...

1 Phedre no Delaunay (Kushiel series, Jacqueline Carey)
2 Melisande Shahrizai (Kushiel series, Jacqueline Carey)
3 Breq (Imperial Radch series, Ann Leckie)
4 Jewel (Jay) Markess (House war & Sun sword series, Michelle West)
5 Kiriel (Sun sword series, Michelle West)
6 Raymond Reddington (The blacklist, tv series)
7 Sophronia Temminick (Finishing school series, Gail Carriger)
8 Kerowyn (By the sword, Mercedes Lackey)
9 Rowan (The steerswoman series, Rosemary Kirstein)
10 Joscelin Verreuil (Kushiel series, Jacqueline Carey)
11 Gabriel Walsh (Cainsville series, Kelley Armstrong)
12 Ender Wiggin (Ender series, Orson Scott Card)

1. Who would make a better college professor, 6 or 11? (Reddington or Gabriel Walsh). I think Reddington. Of course he would not be a college professor exclusively. But he is good at covers, pretending to be someone else, and he tends to be knowledgeable. I could see him teaching, history for instance, in the meanwhile doing his shady stuff. Gabriel on the other hand is socially awkward. He can deal with people in his capacity as a lawyer, but students? Well, he could teach law and if he could stick to facts and the pure dissemination of knowledge, perhaps he could manage. He wouldn't like dealing with the people-side of teaching, though. Gabriel could handle the technicalities of teaching, but not the heart of it. Therefore I think Reddington would be the better college professor.

2. Do you think that 2 would win the “Cutest Guy of the Year”? (Melisande Shahrizai)
Hell, no! For one, she is not a guy. For two, I don't think anyone would have the guts to describe her as cute. She would be devastatingly gorgeous, dangerously sensual or powerfully elegant. Not cute.

3. 12 sends 8 out on a mission. What is it? Does it succeed? (Ender Wiggin & Kerowyn)
I’m taking the liberty of choosing the timing on this. I’m having a hard time imaging Ender sending anyone out on a mission as an adult. But of course, at his time in battle school or right after, it would make perfect sense. Kerowyn essentially being a military person, she would have no problems taking orders, even from a young person, as long as they are sensible. If I transplant Ender into Kerowyn’s world, I’m sure he would be a tactical genius there just as well as in space, so he would send her to fight a certain battle or conquer some outpost and Kerowyn would totally succeed.

4. What is or would be 9's favorite book? (Rowan)
As a steerswoman, Rowan’s passion is knowledge. Her favorite book would therefore be something non-fiction. My guess is it would either be an encyclopedia or a science book. From an encyclopedia she could get a lot of knowledge about our world and she could probably deduce many things from it. However, I don’t believe encyclopedias are big on explanations of science, and I believe Rowan is sufficiently intrigued by the abstract that she would cherish a book about the fundamentals of science most. My guess is a study book about either physics, chemistry, biology or geology.

5. Would it make more sense for 2 to swear fealty to 6, or the other way around (Melisande Shahrizai & Raymond Reddington)
Oh dear. Neither one of them are the fealty-swearing kind… I think both of them are practical enough to do swear fealty to someone if the situation requires it. I don’t think either of them would feel constrained to stick to their oath. I could see Raymond honouring such an oath in spirit at least, if it were made to the right person, but Melisande could never be that person.
So whoever swears fealty to whom, it would never be true fealty, but somehow I could sooner see Raymond do it because of some complicate plan than the other way around. He has less pride.

6. For some reason, 5 is looking for a roommate. Should (s)he share a studio apartment with 9 or 10? (Kiriel, Rowan, Joscelin)
Oh dear, Kiriel is searching for a roommate? She is not the most sociable person… I guess I’ll give this task to Rowan. She’s less likely to get into a fight with Kiriel, and her enforced openness and honesty might intrigue Kiriel, whereas Rowan would have an interesting study object as well.

7. 2, 7, and 12 have dinner together. Where do they go, and what do they discuss? (Melisande, Sophronia & Ender)
Both of the ladies belong to society, so they would pick something equivalent to a fancy French restaurant, and I’m sure Ender would not object. The ladies being who they are, I’m sure they would discuss a plot of some kind; either because they are working together on said plot, or because they are trying to feel each other out. The question is, what on earth is Ender doing there? I guess Melisande is caught up in some plot, Sophronia is trying to gather information about this to stop her, and she ran into Ender before, the two of them like each other, and he is observing and will later arrive at some clever insight that will allow Sophronia to save the day.

8. 3 challenges 10 to a duel. What happens? (Breq & Joscelin)
Man! These questions are crazy! Breq and Joscelin in a fight… Well, no, because Joscelin would refuse to draw his sword. I don’t think Breq would just attack him after that, so there would be no fight. Breq would find another way to achieve whatever goal she was trying to achieve.

9. If 1 stole 8's most precious possession, how would she/he get it back?(Phedre & Kerowyn)
Ok, Phedre could totally steal something if she felt it was necessary. So what would she steal? I guess Kerowyn’s most precious possession is the sword Need. And that could totally work, because Need can only be stolen with Need’s approval, which would be if Phedre needed her. That means that this could only happen if Phedre was under attack (by men of course, since Need would not attack women) while Josceline was elsewhere. Then the matter would be up to Need afterwards. Either she would feel that she would fit better with Phedre, in which case Kerowyn wouldn’t get her back, or she would want to go back to Kerowyn, in which case Phedre would give her back.

10. Suggest a title for a story in which 7 and 12 both attain what they most desire. (Sophronia & Ender)
Ok, Ender wants a place for the hive queen to live. Sophronia? A good sponsor for her spying activities I guess. I could see her meeting Ender, spying and finding him a good position somehow and him employing her. Or something. Hmm. ‘The hive queen, the queen and the Queen’. The second queen would be a vampire queen, and of course there is Queen Victoria.

11. What kind of plot device would you use if you wanted 4 and 1 to work together? (Jewel & Phedre)
Easy. Jewel’s world and Phedre’s world are not so different from each other. I would have Phedre travelling, perhaps as an ambassador to the queen to a strange new land, where Jewel would be the Terafin. They would meet on state visits, and Jewel would befriend Phedre. They could get into a political mess together.

12. If 7 visited you for the weekend, how would you get along? (Sophronia)
Hmm, maybe not so well. I wouldn’t be able to get her into parties where she could spy on people, and I fear she would be climbing all over the place, misusing my possessions for weird purposes.

13. If you could command 3 to perform any one task or service for you, what would it be? (Breq)
Introduce me to one of the ships, give me a tour and have tea with me!

14. If 12 had to choose sides between 4 and 5, which would it be? (Ender, Jewel & Kiriel)
If it had been anyone but Jewel, I would have said Kiriel. Ender had the kind of insight that might show him that Kiriel needs someone to stand with her, even though she is scary. But if it’s Jewel she’s standing against, then Jewel is right. So Ender would choose Jewel.

15. What might 10 shout while charging into battle? (Joscelin)
Joscelin doesn’t shout. He would bow, say ‘I serve and protect’, and do his thing.

16. If you chose a song to represent 8, which song would you choose? (Kerowyn)
Well, Kerowyn’s ride of course! She already has her own song…

17. 1, 6, and 12 are having dim sum at a Chinese restaurant. There is only one scallion pancake left, and they all reach for it at the same time. Who gets to eat it? (Phedre, Raymond & Ender)
Phedre. The others are gentlemen after all.

18. What might be a good pick-up line for 2 to use on 10? (Melisande & Joscelin)
There isn’t one. There is nothing she could say that would work, and she knows it.

19. What would 5 most likely be arrested for? (Kiriel)
Disrupting the piece. She gets into fights in the most public places…

20. What is 6's secret? (Raymond Reddington)
Pff, he has so many… Let’s pick one that’s not too spoilery, he knew Liz’s mom.

21. If 11 and 9 were racing to a destination, who would get there first? (Gabriel & Rowan)
Rowan is used to outside life and walks all day as part of her job. Gabriel has a desk job. My money is on Rowan.

22. If you had to walk home through a bad neighborhood late at night, would you feel safer in the company of 7 or 8? (Sophronia & Kerowyn)
I’m sure Sophronia would not be a bad choice, because she can handle herself well, but Kerowyn is seriously badass. I’m going with Kerowyn.

23. 1 (Phedre) and 9 (Rowan) reluctantly team up to save the world from the threat posed by 4's (Jewel) sinister secret organization. 11 (Gabriel) volunteers to help them, but it is later discovered that s/he is actually a spy for 4 (Jewel). Meanwhile, 4 (Jewel) has kidnapped 12 (Ender) in an attempt to force their surrender. Following the wise advice of 5 (Kiriel), they seek out 3 (Breq), who gives them what they need to complete their quest. What title would you give this fic?
Ancillary house war

13LibraryPerilous
Aug 10, 2016, 3:59 pm

>12 zjakkelien: The Steerswoman!

14zjakkelien
Edited: Aug 10, 2016, 4:43 pm

Woehahahahaha! MrsLee! Your number 12...

>13 LibraryPerilous: Did you forget about her?

15MrsLee
Edited: Aug 10, 2016, 9:17 pm

>14 zjakkelien: One of my favorite parts of this game is seeing other's favorites and how they think about them. In almost every list there are at least one or two characters that I love. :)

It does indeed take a long time! For me, the hardest question to answer was the song title. I enjoy music, but by no means memorize titles or singers or even songs. That took a lot of internet searching.

16SylviaC
Aug 10, 2016, 9:32 pm

The battle cry one took me the longest, because I went to look up exact terminology in a book, and one thing led to another...

17LibraryPerilous
Aug 10, 2016, 10:26 pm

>14 zjakkelien: Yes. :(

But I'm glad she's made an appearance!

18zjakkelien
Aug 11, 2016, 12:33 pm

>17 LibraryPerilous: Haha, glad to be of service!

I took very long for several questions. There are so many ways to interpret the question, so I kept thinking up different answers.

>15 MrsLee: True, I had that too. But there are also many I don't know, so I liked your format with the source behind the character, and with the repeating of the names at each question.