HomeGroupsTalkMoreZeitgeist
Search Site
This site uses cookies to deliver our services, improve performance, for analytics, and (if not signed in) for advertising. By using LibraryThing you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your use of the site and services is subject to these policies and terms.
Hide this

Results from Google Books

Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.

The Duchess War by Courtney Milan
Loading...

The Duchess War

by Courtney Milan

MembersReviewsPopularityAverage ratingMentions
7885321,559 (3.91)27
Miss Minerva Lane is a quiet, bespectled wallflower, and she wants to keep it that way. After all, the last time she was the center of attention, it ended badly--so badly that she changed her name to escape her scandalous past. Wallflowers may not be the prettiest of blooms, but at least they don't get trampled. So when a handsome duke comes to town, the last thing she wants is his attention. But that's precisely what she gets. Because Robert Blaisdell, the Duke of Clermont, is not fooled. When Minnie figures out what he's up to, he realizes there is more to her than her spectacles and her quiet ways. And he's determined to lay her every secret bare before she can discover his. But this time, one shy miss may prove to be more than his match.… (more)
Member:Shira_Tamar
Title:The Duchess War
Authors:Courtney Milan
Info:Publisher Unknown
Collections:Your library
Rating:
Tags:None

Work details

The Duchess War by Courtney Milan

Loading...

Sign up for LibraryThing to find out whether you'll like this book.

No current Talk conversations about this book.

» See also 27 mentions

Showing 1-5 of 53 (next | show all)
"The Duchess War" is the first book in the Brother Sinister series, the tale of Robert Blaisdell, a duke with class conscience, and Wilhelmina “Minny” Pursling, wallflower and secret identity haver, which the blurb of this book sadly gives away, even though knowing her real name (Minerva Lane) doesn’t really take away from discovering the juicy secrets that loom in her past. It’s a story about dichotomies – poor versus rich, (in)famous versus anonymous, ignorant versus progressive, and the tension these contrasts create made the whole book extremely entertaining and a generally very enjoyable read. Though the longer I have been thinking about it, the more I have realized that while this book is one of the better romance novels I’ve read lately, it’s still far from perfect.

Bit Of A Mountains and Molehills Situation

To be honest, I still don’t know where the title is coming from. Unlike some other historical romance books I’ve read, the wedding in this book takes place at the end, not somewhere in the middle, so our protagonist, Minny, doesn’t actually become a duchess until the end, and the other duchess mentioned in this book doesn’t really seem to wage a war? Strange, but whatever. A title does not a book make, after all.

What makes a book, though, are of course its characters, and Milan has a talent for highlighting the blotches and stains on a person’s psyche. Both Minny and Robert are people with a past that affects their every move, and even though I personally didn’t really feel like a lot of Minny’s problems were realistic, Robert’s abandonment by his parents and his constant childhood fantasies of finally actually having a family, fantasies that he has long learned to suppress by the time he meets Minny, definitely tore at my heartstrings. There is a scene where Minny tells him he is not at all like his father, and the desperate joy he feels at that is so well-written and so viscerally understandable to the reader that it just lingers and echoes in their relationship for the rest of the book. Robert is not a clever man or a witty man, he is incredibly insecure and desperately vulnerable, but he is a man with a good heart, and I would really say that he is one of the best romance heroes I have read.

And then we get to Minny. Don’t get me wrong, I loved Minny as a character, I loved that she isn’t pretty, I loved that she is complicated, that she isn’t clever in public and that she is basically a bundle of fears sewn together by the sheer will to survive. She, like Robert, is a person with a kind and generous heart, but other than Robert’s past, her own scandal-ridden childhood leaves a few questions to be answered. And a lot of those questions are related to the fact that Milan doesn’t seem to know a lot about the ‘common folk’ in Victorian England, especially in London, and about how people of the lower echelons of society would be thinking and perceiving the world.

It’s difficult not to spoil Minny’s story here. Let me just say: Victorians were not very superstitious people, not even the poor masses. They did not believe everything a charismatic speaker would say, they did not believe in supernatural intervention in the real world, for the most part, and angry mobs were reserved for labor protests. While the first part of Minny’s childhood is realistic enough, the big event that changed her life forever is just too unrealistic to make you sympathize with Minny. It is also absolutely not understandable why her life had to change so extremely afterwards – why she had to go from the brilliant Minerva Lane to the mousy Wilhelmina Pursling, who keeps telling herself that she is nothing because that’s the only way she will survive? But why? Isn’t there some kind of halfway point between being nothing and being brilliant? The whole thing with Wilhelmina constantly telling herself how she is nothing, and how she is worth nothing, was not congruous with the character, and it definitely put me as a reader off. I mean, alright, she is poor and she has little options in her life and so on, but first of all, she is not really poor in the extreme sense of the word, she lives on a very nice farm (even though her living situation is precarious), she gets invited to society events, she is acquainted with all the movers and doers of her city, and she is part of a charity through which she knows very well how bad her life could be. It just sits kind of wrong with me that somebody whose life is, if not perfect, then still comfortable, would be so insistent that she is worth nothing.

I’m not saying her life isn’t hard. It definitely is, especially the fact that she and her aunt might be homeless once her aunt’s best friend (and likely life partner) dies. She feels like she has to marry, and she feels like nobody but the lowest of the low would marry her. Still, the scenes where she tells herself that she is nothing are just… I don’t know, it seems too much.

Socialist Rant Incoming

Just like in Minny’s past, a lot of the behavior of lower class people in this book seems strange and kind of cliché. It is natural that a book about a Duke with socialist leanings and a woman with charity ties would involve a lot of poor people, but bar a few exceptions, most of them just feel stereotypical or just plain unrealistic. They are also exclusively portrayed as either hapless victims of the world they live in, or as ignorant luddites, both not exactly flattering or humanizing descriptions. Like I said, it’s not exactly easy to make relative poverty a big point in a character’s personality when they are surrounded by abject poverty, and that becomes even starker against this background of stereotypes and clichés.

Having a noble character with such strong socialist leanings as Robert was interesting, but his political engagement was sadly undercut by the portrayal of the poor people he tries to help. They are either complacent or show a ‘This is the world we live in, we can’t do anything about that’ attitude, and Robert comes across pretty patronizing at a few points in the book. The rich, educated savior trying to lift the huddled masses out of their misery – that’s not exactly something that sits very well with me, to say the truth.

Of course, one could argue that this is a romance book, and that the focus of course has to be on the main characters, and that too many focus on side-characters might distract from that. But let’s be honest, there are some side-characters that get a lot of focus – we definitely get to know Robert’s best friends Oliver, Sebastian and Violet, for example, as well as Lydia, Minny’s best friend. But as it often is with romance novels, this is a series, and the people we actually get to know in this book are exactly the people who get to star in further books of this series. And, spoiler alert, nobody in Romancelandia is going to romance a factory girl, or get swept away by a gaffer anytime soon. So there is not really a lot of use in actually giving these sorts of people personalities other than ‘This character facilitates the main character’s growth’, ‘This character illustrates the main character’s personality’ or ‘This character stands in the way of the main character’s goal’.

Socialist Rant Over, So How About The Romance?

I do admit that all this stuff is a little nitpicky and focused on subplots and not really on point regarding the genre the book is in. I mean, this is a romance, so the important part is the relationship between the main characters, right? Well, I’m not quite sure if I think so, dear straw(wo)man, but it has to be said that "The Duchess War" has a really, really good romance plot. The two main characters keep dancing around each other, coming closer, drawing back, hurting each other because they do not realize how vulnerable they are, making stupid decisions and paying the price for it until the misunderstandings and wounds of the past are finally disentangled and laid open, and it really is a joy to read. One of the reasons why most of my criticism on this book actually only formed after I read it is just this incredible pull of the story, which makes you want nothing more than for Robert to finally find somebody who loves him and for Minny to escape her worries and fears, which does happen at the end (and I don’t think I’m spoiling you here, we all know how romances end, and we wouldn’t read them if they didn’t have happy ends). The characters are touching and loveable, and the plot woven around them is just frustrating enough to keep you turning the pages.

One thing that might be criticized about the romance plot is that the resolution just comes too fast. Minny does something horrible to push Robert away, and it would have done the book a lot of good if the inevitable resolution of the whole thing had been drawn out a little more. I have a personal vendetta against rushed endings going, and this book definitely belongs on the ‘rushed resolution’ list.

One last point I’d like to make here is that I really liked the ostensible antagonist of the story, Robert’s mother, as a character. She is not necessarily a likable person, but like her son and like Minny she has a pretty horrible past, and just the process of going from absolutely hating a character to reluctantly understanding them is incredibly rewarding for me. Robert’s mother introduces a conflict that can’t be easily resolved, other than the plot involving another villain of the book, and it gives the book an unfinished, open-ended sort of feeling that definitely makes it feel rounder and more organic.

All in all, "The Duchess War" is a great romance that tries to be too socio-critical for its own good. That kind of flaw might be easily forgiven in a contemporary novel, but since this is a historical romance, and since socio-cultural issues are a large part of its plot, I don’t feel comfortable giving it more than 3.5 points.


Want to read more of my reviews? Visit me on The Bookabelles Blog or follow/friend me here on Goodreads :) ( )
  LadyLudovica | Sep 20, 2021 |
Loved it. The romance was wonderful but different than many others I have read. She was different. They were both in a way broken and were able to complete each other. It was a great read. ( )
  starslight86 | Jul 20, 2021 |
The Duchess War is the first novel in the Brothers Sinister series by Courtney Milan.

Plot:
Minnie has perfected the art of going unnoticed. Afer a scandal forced her to change her name, she had no other choice. Now all she needs is a husband to find some security in her life. Impoverished and with her secret, she doesn’t have much choice. That is why she really can’t have it that none other than the Duke of Clermont, Robert Blaisdell, seems to actually notice her. His curiosity about her is a threat, and Minnie is determined to uncover his secrets first to protect herself. This decision leads both of them down unexpected paths.

The Duchess War is a really sweet book with wonderful protagonists and a good plot that makes good use of the period it is set in. More importantly, it’s easy to root for Millie and Robert and to enjoy their falling in love.

Read more on my blog: https://kalafudra.com/2021/05/24/the-duchess-war-courtney-milan/ ( )
  kalafudra | May 24, 2021 |
Good book. I thought the beginning was a little bit slow, but it picked up quickly. The story's premise was interesting, if a bit unlikely, and ended up being a fun read.

Robert and Minnie first meet at a ball where he hid behind a curtain to avoid dealing with people. While he is there, Minnie comes looking for a place to escape her wannabe fiancé and ends up hiding behind the couch that's in front of his curtain. The subsequent conversation leaves Robert intrigued with her intelligence and fire.

Minnie is a young woman with a big secret. After an unusual childhood that ended in scandal and betrayal by her father, she changed her name and moved in with her aunts. Since that time, Minnie cultivated a persona of a quiet, meek, and mild wallflower, frequently compared to a mouse. Thanks to her past, she fears crowds and being the center of attention. She also craves love and a feeling of security. Minnie works quietly with others for better conditions for the poor. She was a chess prodigy as a child and is highly intelligent as an adult.

Robert is deeply ashamed of his father, the previous duke, and vows to be nothing like him. To that end, he came to Leicester to right a wrong done to some workers at a factory he owns. Robert also has a deeper purpose, one that employs an unexpected method of investigation.

As the story opens, a local law enforcement official confronts Minnie, accusing her of writing and distributing seditious flyers. These flyers encourage workers to strike, form unions, and do other anti-business/pro-worker activities. He informs her of his investigation of her and knows she is not who she claims to be. Minnie, terrified of being exposed, decides finding the actual author of the flyers will prove her innocence. It doesn't take her long to settle on Robert as the most likely suspect.

I loved Minnie's visit to Robert at his home. She laid out her suspicions and requested that he confess, thus taking the heat off her. Robert, of course, refuses her request, citing a lack of proof. He doesn't intend to quit until he reaches his goal. Minnie promises to get the evidence and that she won't hesitate to use it. Meanwhile, Robert vows to flirt with her and make her the center of attention. I love how she laughs at him and tells him no one will believe it. I loved the scene where she proved him right, her public mouse-like persona making a hash of his attempts to flirt with her.

I enjoyed the development of the relationship between Minnie and Robert. She intrigues him, and the more he gets to know her, the deeper his fascination goes. I liked how he found so many chances to spend time with Minnie, getting to know her, and enjoying getting past her mouse façade. There's a fun scene that takes place on the train from London to Leicester. Robert wants to spend the time talking to Minnie, but his cousin Sebastian and their friend Violet take over the conversation. Minnie is equally fascinated by Robert, but she sees no future in it with her past what it is.

As Robert continues his investigation, he unwittingly implicates Minnie in his latest flyer. Through a twisted series of events, the only way to save Minnie is for her to marry Robert. I liked their discussion of the practicalities, but both dropped the ball by not admitting their feelings. I loved their honeymoon to Paris and seeing them come together. But their honeymoon comes to an abrupt end when they receive a message that Robert's half-brother has been arrested and accused of writing those damning flyers. I ached for Robert, who had to decide whether to save his brother by betraying Minnie or protecting Minnie and allowing Oliver to suffer. The courtroom scene was intense and had me on the edge of my seat as it played out.

The ending surprised me with a couple of unexpected twists. I enjoyed the scene with the reporters, especially Robert's unswerving support for Minnie. I also liked the resolution of Robert's investigation.

One of the things I enjoyed most about this book was the look at the plight of workers in Victorian times. It's a subject not often seen in romance novels, and it made a nice change. I also found Robert's views on the aristocracy unexpected.

I liked getting to know Robert's half-brother, Oliver, a bit and learning a little of the complicated history of the two of them. Robert's cousin, Sebastian, was an interesting character with his flirtatious manner and high spirits. There was a great scene with the three men as Sebastian and Oliver have pre-wedding advice for Robert.

I can't wait to read the other two books in the series. ( )
  scoutmomskf | Apr 18, 2021 |
Light, romantic. Maybe a bit unrealistic, but I wasn't really looking for realism here. So, delivered what it promised :) ( )
  RankkaApina | Feb 22, 2021 |
Showing 1-5 of 53 (next | show all)
no reviews | add a review

» Add other authors

Author nameRoleType of authorWork?Status
Milan, Courtneyprimary authorall editionsconfirmed
Agentur LibelliTranslatorsecondary authorsome editionsconfirmed
Geiler, Ute-ChristineTranslatorsecondary authorsome editionsconfirmed
Landor, RosalynNarratorsecondary authorsome editionsconfirmed
Libelli, AgenturTranslatorsecondary authorsome editionsconfirmed
You must log in to edit Common Knowledge data.
For more help see the Common Knowledge help page.
Canonical title
Original title
Alternative titles
Original publication date
People/Characters
Important places
Important events
Related movies
Awards and honors
Epigraph
Dedication
For Carey
who prefers beagles over bagels
First words
Robert Blaisdell, the ninth duke of Clermont, was not hiding.
Quotations
Last words
Disambiguation notice
Publisher's editors
Blurbers
Original language
Canonical DDC/MDS
Canonical LCC

References to this work on external resources.

Wikipedia in English (1)

Miss Minerva Lane is a quiet, bespectled wallflower, and she wants to keep it that way. After all, the last time she was the center of attention, it ended badly--so badly that she changed her name to escape her scandalous past. Wallflowers may not be the prettiest of blooms, but at least they don't get trampled. So when a handsome duke comes to town, the last thing she wants is his attention. But that's precisely what she gets. Because Robert Blaisdell, the Duke of Clermont, is not fooled. When Minnie figures out what he's up to, he realizes there is more to her than her spectacles and her quiet ways. And he's determined to lay her every secret bare before she can discover his. But this time, one shy miss may prove to be more than his match.

No library descriptions found.

Book description
Haiku summary

LibraryThing Author

Courtney Milan is a LibraryThing Author, an author who lists their personal library on LibraryThing.

profile page | author page

Popular covers

Quick Links

Rating

Average: (3.91)
0.5
1 1
1.5
2 10
2.5 2
3 55
3.5 26
4 152
4.5 13
5 58

 

About | Contact | Privacy/Terms | Help/FAQs | Blog | Store | APIs | TinyCat | Legacy Libraries | Early Reviewers | Common Knowledge | 163,337,882 books! | Top bar: Always visible